MAFIA mafia: The mafiating: Mafia with a Mafia

[Nikose Tyris]

IT IS NOW DAY 1.

PLAYERS:

GREGNESS - Town, Mafia'd Night 2
RPGDEMON - Town, Mafia'd Night 1
BAHAMUTFLARE - MAFIATE
FENRISWOLF - Town
INBRED CHOCOBO - Town, Lynched Day 1
ALDURIN - Town, Lynched Day 2


GAME BEGIN TOTAL PROFESSIONAL BROS GO

[Inbred Chocobo]

I THINK FENRIS IS SCUM!!!

EVERYONE VOTE FOR HIM

VOTE: FENRIS

[Aldurin]

Vote: Fenris

Given how it's Nikose running this and that Fenris does do the awesome betrayal reacharounds, it is the only way to be sure.

[Fenris]

I didn't get a PM fuck you guys

[Gregness]

Ditto on the whole "needing my role information" thing.

[Nikose Tyris]

Posting for clarity's sake:
The only people(s) who got PM's are the mafiate(s).

[Nikose Tyris]

This was stated previously so anyone claiming "I don't have a role no PM" could be lying. Level playing field. No PM = vanilla town.

[Fenris]

you stated it in the stupid thread.

stupid

[rpgdemon]

Vote: IC

I'm guessing he's scum, since scum would have gotten a PM directing them to the thread, whereas we would not, and he got here IMMEDIATELY.

[BahamutFlare]

FoS: Fenris and Gregness for not reading the signup thread after the game started.

On a completely unrelated FoS
FoS: Nikose for not putting that info in this thread.

I'll just use each of my fingers to point at each one of you. I'm watching every one of you!

[Gregness]

FoS: Fenris and Gregness for not reading the signup thread after the game started.

On a completely unrelated FoS
FoS: Nikose for not putting that info in this thread.

I'll just use each of my fingers to point at each one of you. I'm watching every one of you!

The post in question:

SIGNUPS CLOSED. PM SENT TO THE MAFIATE(S).

Literally every single game on this forum has sent out messages to everyone except this one. Forgive me for skimming over his exact words. (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ExactWords)

[BahamutFlare]

I was hoping the FoS Nikose for him not putting that on the first post of this thread meant that I was not really serious about that. I suppose I don't really understand the joke vote period of every game or how to make a joke vote/FoS look jokey.

I did read the post in the other thread though. I'm literally considering this game filler mafia. Which with 6 people, it kind of is. So shoddy production, but on the plus, people get interested for mafia. Which is a thumbs up for me.

I just want to say, careful with your joke votes. We only have 6 people. If Fenris is town, a mislynch because "Hey we all joke voted for him." seems like an awful way to start the game.

[Aldurin]

Unvote: Fenris

FoS: IC

That was an uncannily quick response, but I need more derps to read from before I make a hard vote.

[Nikose Tyris]

I'd like to compliment this group as having a 100% participation rate so far. Keep up the good work guys.

[Inbred Chocobo]

Unvote: Fenris

Hmmm, hindsight me thinks that with only 6 people, joke voting is something I probably shouldn't have done. Well at least it didn't end badly. Thanks to BahamutFlare for bringing that up.

The only thing that struck me as odd right now was Gregness felt the need to actually defend himself against that FoS. Personally I would've just let it slide and not mention it as I didn't think it warranted addressing. Hmmm

FoS: Gregness

Also, I got nothing on anyone else. Bahamut seems friendly, which is never a good thing in Mafia, and Fenris is Fenris and I can never read the guy. And everyone else I can't pick anything up from.

[Nikose Tyris]

Just to clarify: DEADline is Friday Night around Midnight. Possibly Saturday morning if I fall asleep.

[Fenris]

as loathe as I am to admit it, given the absolutely miniscule amount of content this day, rpg's reason for voting IC makes the most sense out of all given options.

Vote: IC

[Inbred Chocobo]

as loathe as I am to admit it, given the absolutely miniscule amount of content this day, rpg's reason for voting IC makes the most sense out of all given options.

Vote: IC

Meh, around 2:30 is about the time I am at work and there is nothing to do. So yeah, I am always on at that moment and spotted Nikose's message he was putting up a thread, so just watched for a new one to appear. I didn't actually get a pm, I just happen to be on at the right time. That same logic train should also indicate Aldurin as well, as he was only 4 minutes from Nikose's post, which is about the time you would expect someone to spend reading a pm. Of course, that means there are two suspects using this train of thought, and I seriously doubt there are two mafiaties, as that means the game ends if we don't lynch a mafia right now. Therefore I don't think this line of thinking is going to be productive.

Instead, I think going after Gregness would be best. Mostly because not only did he chime in on the whole got no pm, but also that Nikose felt like he had to state that only mafiates got pms, but he stated that he said that in the sign-up thread, and people could be lying. I feel like he really felt that, so either Fenris or Gregness need to use that, and of the two I am willing think Gregness is it.

Vote: Gregness

[BahamutFlare]

I really don't like the time stamp logic because as far as I can tell, that is stretching things. I do fall into line with IC's way of thinking. My original thing with Gregness was having to defend himself against an FoS. Did anyone really think that it was serious?

Although, it's not usual for me to see Fenris just vote with time left on the clock. And for a pretty flimsy reason.

Vote: Gregness

[Aldurin]

Didn't even notice I was four minutes off from the first post, and I always check with the "Today's Posts" buttons so the whole quick reaction thing isn't exactly something hard to ride on since innocent and mafia could be that quick if they checked at the right time. But the way IC is defending it by deflecting suspicion away and giving a very non-logical reason for being so early. Not the action itself but the way he's reacting (am I overthinking it?).

Anyways,

Vote: IC

It's very unusual for a mafia game to not PM everyone at the start, so the confusion seems justified around that part.

[Nikose Tyris]

VOTE COUNT:

GREGNESS: 2
Inbred Chocobo
BahamutFlare

INBRED CHOCOBO: 3
Aldurin
Fenris
RPGDemon

ROUGHLY ONE HOUR REMAINING. Will there be an upset in the vote? Keep watching, Sports Fans!

[Nikose Tyris]

A THING HAPPENED WHERE INBRED TOTALLY DIED.

Sorry Inbred Chocobo!

It is now Night!

NIGHT HAPPENS - RPGDEMON TOTALLY DIED!

Sorry RPGDemon!

It is now Day 2!

Three To Lynch!

[rpgdemon]

THIS IS THE WORST GAME OF MAFIA EVER.

[Aldurin]

Vote: Fenris

I know how this movie ends.

[Fenris]

if you keep doing this it ends with town losing.

also, pretty sure I don't trust how bandwaggony you were last round.

Vote: Aldurin to tie it up for now, also because bandwagons without presentation of original thought.

[BahamutFlare]

FoS: Aldurin You joke bandwagoned 2/6 is still pretty close to lynching. And you definitely nailed the coffin in for IC. You also started today with voting for Fenris with such confidence. I would like to know what for because confidence is not really something I have at the moment. Maybe it's because I don't know Fenris's playing style and you see something I don't.

I think it's one of you two, but I don't know whom as of now.

[Nikose Tyris]

Due to low participant count, I believe I can safely set the "End of Day" to Monday. Would that be okay with everyone?

[Fenris]

yo somebody make this a not-tie.

[Nikose Tyris]

cause like, I'll kill two motherfuckers.

[BahamutFlare]

Vote: Aldurin

[Nikose Tyris]

Aldurin: 2
Fenris
BahamutFlare

Fenris: 1
Aldurin

Edit: I'll wait till sometime reasonable Monday to end the day, waiting to see if Gregness posts.

[Nikose Tyris]

Eh, I gave it enough time.

ALDURIN, TOWN, IS DEAD. LONG LIVE THE KING!

Night falls. Waiting for the final kill to see who the last pair of people are, just for tension purposes.

[Nikose Tyris]

GREGNESS, TOWN, IS DEAD.

BahamutFlare and Fenris have a staredown. Guess who was your mafiate, guys?

You can never trust that wolfish rogue.

[Fenris]

son of a bitch, why is this game still going on.

[BahamutFlare]

Dang you Fenris! Good game everyone. I believe it is over and anyone can comment on who they think the mafiate was.

[Fenris]

Nikose you motherfucker.

It was you all along, or Baha is really good at poker

[BahamutFlare]

Super good at poker Fenris. ;)

[Fenris]

Oh wassup first post

To be fair, fuck Nikose.

[Aldurin]

Mafia is dicks, like all the dicks.

[rpgdemon]

I can only assume that I was killed because of my pro sleuthing skills.

[Nikose Tyris]

I'm just glad everyone had fun

And that BahamutFlare is fucking fantastic at mafia.

[BahamutFlare]

I figured IC or RPGdemon might've taken a chance and get people to rally against me. Lucky for me IC was lynched and I shot RPG. I wasn't sure how many people even remotely suspected me or what.

[Gregness]

Dammit, I was out of town all weekend. >.<

[Nikose Tyris]

Well I hope everyone had fun, and that we can run more in the future. :3

[rpgdemon]

If the people on the list keep not running theirs, I might have the time to run my Meta-Mafia game, but I'd want to do some setup first.

[Nikose Tyris]

I think what we need is like, an email sent out to check if a person is interested, and if they don't answer for, I dunno, 5 days? is 5 days fair? then we just tell them "You're bumped down the line" and we move to the next person, and repeat as necessary. I think that'd be an okay thing.

[Ryong]

I do not understand how there isn't a policy lynch on BahamutFlare yet.

He's too good.

[rpgdemon]

I pegged him D2, actually.

But I was dead. :(