I'm wary about bandwaggoning on B_real. Since I have a bit of a stake in this game being successful (if it is, then I get to run my MLP mafia game) I actually appreciate him taking the effort to help introduce new players to the game.
Besides, your reasoning for suspecting B_real is pretty flimsy, too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inbred Chocobo
I'm casting suspicion on P-sleazy as well, main reason is that if he was truly saying he wanted to protect newbs, he would have realized that Thadius's actions were more the result of the way he posts and acts in general rather than him trying to hide anything in particular, and would've defend appropriately. Feels more like he was trying to sound like a good guy and not make you think bad of him the more I think about it.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by P-Sleazy
Soooo....what it seems to boil down to is Bard or Thad. Of the two, both seem to be making dumb first-timer mistakes. Thad moreso.
IC can't decide between the two but rests on Bard which, Smarty seems to be "going with the flow" and votes Bard.
Then we have the other two goods voting for Thadius. Sifright and Ryanderman. Of the two, Sifright simply says he doesn't like Thadius and thinks he's scummy. Ok. Then Ryanderman pops in and seems to make more of a case than Sifright on Thadius. Albeit, that case is "Well...I see IC's logic on both, but I don't agree with his conclusion".
As such, I'm going to
##VOTE: Sifright
He seems all too keen to vote for Thadius given that Smarty is willing to vote for whomever is of the two.
I also reserve an #FOS: Ryanderman
Because he may be trying to help swing Smarty's opinion away from Bard.
Which leaves me with a final
FOS: BARD, THAD
Guys, stop being reactionary and start being more proactive. We'll never get anywhere if all you do is answer questions posed to you. We need you guys to ask the questions. Research peoples actions. And finally, quite being so worried. Uncle Sleazy will make sure that first time players will get their due defense from a more experienced player.
|
You might note that B_real didn't participate in the bandwagon of Thadius. You, on the other hand, did. You're a smart guy. You're good at this game. Why didn't you take note of Thad's actions being more indicative of his own personality instead of voting him off the island? If you're going to make that argument now, you're clearly aware of that being the case. Why weren't you then?
The fact is, there's not a whole lot to go on. I'm curious where Ryanderman and Bookworm have gone off to? What of Moogle? Frankly, I'm more concerned with inactives than the people who have posted so far, as nothing's really thrown off my scumdar yet.
Looks like the only victim of last night was this game's activity level. I'm not about to let two people decide who dies when seven are needed for majority, especially with such shaky reasoning that you are displaying right now.
Come on, people. Post.