Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[Tophat]

Vote: Ole'Dude with the Face

Don't have anything to go on so I'll put my faith in Sith's maths.

[Ole' Dude With the Face]

Originally Posted by Darthmauler

Vote Count...

I am no longer voting for Skyshot. I unvoted him and voted for Masked Jedi like two pages ago (40 posts per page view).

[Doppler12]

UNVOTE,VOTE: DBS

He's too eager to kill people, granted its day one, so any kill can't be all that terrible, assuming the scum groups are small/ normal size. Then again we have a evil bastard running the game, so who knows?

[Demonlink2]

I can only assume, with 3 mafia, that they are all at best no more than 5, since the average mafia game is 25-30 player, 5-6 Mafia. Ergo, it would have been either 2 mafias of 5 or 1 of 10, but since there are 3 I cannot see any action with scum in groups of more than 5.

So, assuming 15/50 is mafiascum, 2 or 4/50 is cultscum, I 'unno if they went last night or not, and ???/50 is selfallignedscum, including 2 SKs.

Ergo, we have about 20/50 scum, but likely no more than 25/50, lord knows who they are, and as such 2/5 to 1/2 are bad.

As such, Voting DBS does seem logical since he is a little too bandwagonhappy, but really, with this many scum, the bandwagon only has 1/2 to 3/5 chance of failure. That's not such a bad chance. I'll keep a vote off of him, for now. But I maintain Skyshot is a whore and also maintain my vote.

[russianreversal]

I think your old avatar was better, Demonlink. Light in one of his "red" moments is way cooler than Light in the helecopter (I think that's what it is). And in conclusion, if we trust Sith's math, there are but two outcomes: One, he's right and we live; Two, he's wrong and we die. That's fifty-fifty odds, way better than guessing at random, which would be closer to a 3/10 chance.

Yes, my math is flawed, but that's why I listen to Sith. :O_o:

EDIT: See? Totaly way more evil.

[Demonlink2]

And the great thing about VLC is, snapshots! Yay AMV Hell 4! Yay old avatar that was lost due to my attempting to use an animated GIF as an avatar but rescreenshotted!

Anyways, I guess Sith's maths are just fine (don't ask me how my finals were...I hate i with every fiber of my algebraic being) but I prefer mine due to the fact that they factor in non-mafia variables as well. Either way, we're bound to hit one of them.

[Death by Stabbing]

Just for the record...I'm not eager to kill anyone...I just think we shouldn't sit around and argue endlessly like in most mafia games...we're 50 smart people and I know we can work together to hunt down the mafia scum

And to show my good faith I'll take back my vote pending further investigations

Unvote: Sithdarth

[Giever]

Originally Posted by Moogle0119

Why does Neyo have two separate listings of one vote each?

Heh, so do I.

That said! Vote: Barrel-Hating Sycophant

Just 'cause, I tend to agree with those guys saying this is going to take forever anyway.

[Ole' Dude With the Face]

Alright, the day is getting on a lot better than I had hoped for(in the fact that the wild randomness of normal day 1s, which I might add, I fervently hate day 1). So yeah, I guess its time I take my joke vote off and see if logic and reasoning can't get us somewhere.

Unvote

And here is something I find intriguing.

Originally Posted by BHS in response to when Sith originally stated his math

Logic has no place in mafia, only wild accusations and name-calling!

Originally Posted by BHS, later on down the road

People, Sith makes sense. His maths work. It will also help our day 2 and 3 votes if we get no further information.
Vote: ODWTF
In favour of Sith's plan.

Looks like we have a convert here in BHS to Sithdarth's reasoning. What I find most interesting is that in the second quote BHS seems to find the prospect of lynching off of Sith's list quite agreeable. Maybe he took a closer look at the people on the list and figured he wouldn't lose anything by getting rid of those people. After all, while the chances of there being a scum somewhere on that list, thats spread out over 3 mafias, 2 cults, and unknown amount of self-aligned people. Its quite likely that he could be in a faction that isn't represented by the 4 people on Sith's list and wouldn't mind seeing the town potentially waste a few days lynching those people.

My theory does include a good bit of speculation and possibilities, but its technically just as probable as the randomness. And its got some logic in the mafia game sense behind it. So, I now (know) support my

Vote: Barrel-Hating Scyophant.

Edit: I noticed that I used know instead of now, so I changed it while leaving the original underlined and in italics.

[Demonlink2]

I am swain by Ole Dude's logic. And Sithdarth's. Skyshot's whorishness shall be reveled later; BHS is slightly worse now.

Unvote: Skyshot and Giant Enemy Crab; Vote: B-HS and the Slowpoke Meme.

So there.