Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[P-Sleazy]

to have leverage against the mafia? Makes it harder for a one man mafia to win.

Originally Posted by Newb

Also, as far as today goes, I figured it wasn't necessary to describe two dead people, since I thought everybody would realize that when I said two people shot each other, I was referring to the two people who turned up dead, having shot each other.

EDIT: and before you ask, no, I did not see the third shooter. They were hidden.

But you always get a description of everyone at the scene. I don't see why you wouldn't get atleast a description you could post for everyone to see of the third shooter.

EDIT: Curse you Pink for simulposting!

[OctoberRaven]

Obviously to use logic to figure out who is scum and diplomaticity to convince others to vote for them.

EDIT- Well that does put my suspicions on PB completely at rest. A bit extreme to do that, IMO (I no longer had a good reason to vote for you besides your spindoctoring me, and I wasn't going to use my night kill on you anyway). However now I want to know how the hell I got B-Real I's investigation, and more importantly, who caused that to happen (if it wasn't a chance misfire that is).

[Fenris]

Pink Bunny be tellin' the truth, yo.

[P-Sleazy]

Fenris is a wolf yo! He he ain't loyal to anyone! And he bites back on promises! He must be a liar! :p

Ok, yea. Thats good enough for me. Now to find out out to confirm October...cause we have a somewhat reasonable way of confirming newb...which would in turn confirm October. One or the other is scum.

[Bailey]

The description WAS that I couldn't see them. They had shadows all over them as if it was some sort of garment.

Obviously not those words.

[Aerozord]

Originally Posted by Ape Boy

Actually, I thought of another angle to look at this:

If we go for RussianReversal, we get the information from his lynching. If he turns up scum, then Newb is pretty much confirmed and worth keeping around.

If he turns up otherwise, well, we pretty much know who to lynch next.

Adding in this new idea with the rest of my previous suspicions, I'm going to...

VOTE: RussianReversal

wow, brilliant, wish I thought of that... :shifty:

Originally Posted by Aerozord

well Newb and RR both show suspicious behavior. For all we know they are both scum. Since one of the main people that pushed for RR was Newb I say we take the risk and vote for RR. If it turns out RR is scum that would give some validity to Newbs role claim. If not, then its proof he is scum and should be next on the chopping block.

Not fool proof, but I think its a good idea

[Pink Bunny]

Originally Posted by Brock Samson

In response to your edited response:

Then what the hell is the point of playing?

Personally, I took the role and pretended to be like an MMO Tank. I took allll the night actions/agro. :0

And rest assured, I did. Multiple people targeting me for shit all over the past two nights. I fought tooth and nail about the lynchings even though I felt no threat, as I had promised, because I wanted to drag this out for awhile.

Its also why I argued against the concept of me being "Night Immune" and tried to imply that it was limited.

It wasn't limited. I just wanted killers to waste their time dealing with me. I may have been able to drag this out longer, but you know, I see some shady movements going on right now so I felt it was time to end the act and be what I am. A townie. :P

[OctoberRaven]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

Now to find out out to confirm October...cause we have a somewhat reasonable way of confirming newb...which would in turn confirm October. One or the other is scum.

Assuming that's true I could kill Newb... no wait, that won't work, as we don't know the roles of the nightkilled.

And B_real, we don't have a reasonable way of confirming anyone if my current theory of someone swapping targets on me is accurate.

[Ape Boy]

Originally Posted by Aerozord

wow, brilliant, wish I thought of that... :shifty:

Sure, yours was good, but it was lacking that certain... je nai se qua.

That, and I somehow completely missed it when you suggested it. Great minds think alike, eh?

[P-Sleazy]

...ok, so now we have 2 conflicting claims on what B_Real I was. You have "evidence" of him being mafia scum while October has evidence of him being town tracker.

Care to explain this then

Originally Posted by Newb

To B_Real the first, I am very sorry. It seems that I misinterpreted the clue I had, at least as far as you being in it goes.

Thats you, apologizing to B_Real I for putting him in a clue cause he's not scum, meaning you agree with October that B_Real I wasn't scum. Now you just put him in yet ANOTHER clue that scumifies him.