Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[Pink Bunny]

Originally Posted by Demetrius

No, I said the original vote was a joke. The second one was on faulty logic, which I admitted to.

You did admit to it. Awhile back when you changed your vote. However, when Moogle went to vote for you and reinterrated why, you downplayed your actions significantly by making it sound like all you did was a single joke vote and nothing else.

That was a huge downplay. It made it sound like persecution just for you joking around, when that wasn't the main reason you were being voted for at all.

I proposed a truce after your attack on me.

Fair, but one must be reminded who jumped who. Striking at someone, failing at your goal, and then discovering that you might pay for it is hardly the foundation of a real truce. It looks more like someone trying to scrape together damage control.

The one solid vote is based on logic and was made after your attacks on me which broke any holding the truce may have had.

True. I was just reminding the audience/voters how hypocritical your offer of truce was. This doesn't make you any significantly scummier or anything. Its just personally satisfying. :P

I am assuming nothing.
Most often the mafia has one night kill proof member, and so does the cult.

You're assuming I can't be killed at night. I'm not going to confirm or deny it for you, but a assumption is an assumption. There are many spins of that power. True immunity, many one time uses of multiple powers, one time procs, etc.

I'm not disagreeing with the fact that I did open up with a vote on you, and that you responded as you usually do. That is why I decided to offer a truce. You kept up the pressure so I looked back more closely and made a vote based on what was suspicious.

Fair. That isn't why I think you're voting me though.

I agree, however I think that the slip was in the night post. You survived an attack with no other interference. That fact alone makes you scum. Using me as a scapegoat is a tried and true tactic, it works both ways...

On the contrary, it supports my innocence. We know that the vigilante (although there could be more than one) was out being Silly Kitty's hero. That decreases the chances that a town-aligned killer tried to kill me significantly— which leads to the more likely result that scum tried to kill me last night. As scum tends to know scum, that eliminates a good percentage of probability that I was some form of scum. It doesn't clear me though; it could've been the serial killer. It could've been a cultist. It does mean that Town didn't find me a threat that night.

Again though, a vote on you makes the most sense based on the facts and clues given in the night post.

Fair, although I really do think you're reading them in a biased slant.

Another thing that must be said is that whoever made the attack on you would be wise to sit back and let me take the heat, especially considering our history and my stupid vote on you at the beginning of the day.

That is a decent point I didn't consider until now... The original person illogically concluding I was cult before changing to you was Tendronai. What are your thoughts?