Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[OctoberRaven]

Fair enough, but that doesn't mean he is.

Originally Posted by David Hume

No matter how many times you drop a stone, it doesn't mean the next time you drop it it will fall to the ground.

However, as I'm obviously alone on this... don't say I didn't warn you if I turn out to right about this.

Anyway.

Vote: Roy for being full of shit and a possible Cult member/leader.

[Pink Bunny]

Especially now that there's knowledge that killing the leader saves any corrupted family members. That should really be the big incentive.

[OctoberRaven]

He didn't know that yesterday, though. Just saying.

Once again, I guarantee that if I'm lynched now, I will not come up Cult. If you want to prove me wrong, well, go ahead and try.

[Moogle0119]

There's no point in wasting lynches. Even if you did turn up Cult it doesn't mean anything when there's still a Cult Leader running around. I can tell you Roy is not with the Condatino family, which makes me wonder if he's the remaining Alberto family roleblocker that may or may not be culted (who should be alive still according to my count). That would explain how he was able to target Tendronai without Tendronai being killed/culted/etc...

[OctoberRaven]

...Unless, you know, he was protected by Ryanderman, who nobody roleblocked? (B_Real II publicly said he Roleblocked me)

EDIT- Not saying you're wrong, of course. The roleblocking thing is a possibility, but he could have also been culting him.

[wasoe]

Now here's why I am suspicious of Roy: He cringed at the sight of valuable information given by Zavage and Tendronai.

Here was his response to Zavage's information:

Originally Posted by Roy_D_Mylote

I'm also going to say it was a real bad idea to release those names with nothing known about them, because now the bad guys have a nice big list with every townie with powers.

And his response to Tendy:

Originally Posted by Roy_D_Mylote

...telling us that hurts the town so bad.

So my question is: Why cringe at this? This was valuable information that we used to take out the Cult of Personality.

Unless, of course, Roy was a former member of the cult of personality and is now whatever he was before. I highly doubt this.

FoS: Roy

[Pink Bunny]

Alright, I'm going to parse this and I want people to help me fill this in.
Names that are in gold mean they are in NO WAY the Cult Leader, not that they're town. I want that distinction to be clear.

ACTIVE

05. bananarama : Suspicious Vanilla Townie. (His actions are dubious.)
07. OctoberRaven : Inventor. Alignment: ??? (Why are you still alive?)
08. Moogle0119 : Condatino Family Bodyguard.
14. secretskull : Mason (I'm not giving any of the masons colors because I want to see when this masonry business started in old posts and make sure it isn't a growing thing.)
21. Captain Combustible : ??? (Seems pro-town but no identification.)
22. Ape Boy x2 : ??? (Allegiance is uncertain. Replaced an idler; the Cult of Music is not an inactive entity.)
25. wasoe : ??? (Has been put on the chopping block multiple times. Has tried to convince people to waste lynches before. Suddenly quiet.)
29. DarthMauler64 : Mayor (Could be culted now due to his awesome power, but is not a leader. A leader with such a power would be game breaking.)
33. Demonlink2 : ??? (Has he posted recently?)
37. Aerozord : ??? (Quiet lately. Usually very outspoken, but blends into the background.)
38. h4x.m4g3 : ??? (Aerozord's Twin Brother.)
39. Brock Samson: Mason (Isn't he?)
42. Pink Bunny, Sage, Town-aligned (Fenris even said I can't be culted...)
43. Roy_D_Mylote : ??? (Can target people, or has a power that targets self. Was either re-routed his self-power to someone else, or targeted someone else and is lying.)
44. Ryanderman : Mason (Appears to be a rival of Wasoe's...?)
45. Axl : Roleblocker (Was he a mason as well?)
47. Jeneralissimo : ??? (......... ???)


INACTIVE

11. Inbred Chocobo : ??? (Why is this Idler still playing when Bookie died from inactivity? Because he isn't inactive...)
15. Zell : ??? (Who the hell is this guy? I might be blind.)
36. Twiddy : ??? (Who?)
48. Rygar : ??? (Has he even posted? Why is he alive if Bookie isn't?)
50. Giever : ??? (Deja vu?)

[Moogle0119]

Yeah but it doesn't really matter at the point whether or not he's a mafiate or even a Cultist, we really need to find the Cult Leader and stop it before it ends up taking over the remaining mafias (Condatino & Alberto). If they manage to nab them it'll be much harder for the town to win and damned near impossible to win for the mafia since we'll be taking orders.

Edit: Awesome list PB. Let's work off of that and try to fill in more gaps on our player list.

[OctoberRaven]

I want to know why I haven't been killed/culted myself. But there is precendent to this in Spiderman Mafia, where I outed myself as one REALLY incompetant Vig. Nobody questioned this, and I was targeted only once (and was protected).

EDIT- Yes, I am aware of the irony of citing precedent after doubting precedent with a quote.

[Pink Bunny]

I have a hunch who it is, but I want more discussion before I go that route so I don't immediately make them jump on the defensive. Plus input from former members of the Cult of Personality would be nice to hear.