My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[Sifright]

Seriously? Deadline approaching? it's not until bloody thursday

[Geminex]

Right.
ALSO.
I mentioned the game on the Chat, and the following conversation ensued:

(23:58:11) ChatBot: Geminex logs into the Chat.
(23:58:18) Geminex: Sup.
(23:58:25) Geminex: Hey, Smarty. Check the mafia thread.
(23:58:27) Smarty_McBarrelp: Sup. Cracker.
(23:58:34) Smarty_McBarrelp: Why did you show your cock?
(23:58:48) Geminex: No, I only show that on weekends.
(23:58:56) Geminex: If you ask nicely.
(23:59:05) Sifright: You guys
(23:59:09) Sifright: HOF
(23:59:13) Sifright: HOS
(23:59:15) Sifright: even
(23:59:18) Sifright: HOS all over you
(23:59:22) Geminex: No, I explained my bookworm-suspicions and I'd be interested to know what you think
(23:59:25) Geminex: What'd I do?
(23:59:34) Sifright: well alright not you
(23:59:38) Sifright:
(23:59:51) Sifright: but god damn Snake.
(23:59:51) Geminex: : D
(23:59:57) Geminex: Snake is being snake.
(00:00:08) Geminex: Though he's being a lot more snakey than I would have thought.
(00:00:15) Geminex: BUT
(00:00:22) Geminex: We're not allowed to talk about that in private
(00:00:24) Sifright: him posting walls of text like this is a sign of tension and nerves
(00:00:26) Sifright: true
(00:00:35) Geminex: I just wanted to tell smarty to check the thread (00:00:54) Geminex: In fact, gonna edit this into my post so it's public. (00:01:06) Geminex: That cool with everyone?
(00:01:15) Sifright: I don't want to post that though because it could come across as an attack on him personally
(00:01:24) Sifright: and i think snakes a pretty cool guy so eh...
(00:01:32) Smarty_McBarrelp: He has a tinypenis
(00:01:36) Geminex: Well you just cleared up the misunderstanding.

I'll refrain from mentioning it on chat again. Nothing important here, but just thought it'd be good to keep things public.
I'd also like to know how Smarty knows about Snake's penis.

[Mr.Bookworm]

Originally Posted by Geminex

To elaborate on my Bookworm-hunch, he was the first to accuse smarty without much justification,

Yes, that is something you do on Day 1.

and then encouraged people to jump on the 'bandwagon'.

When I said that looked suspcicious, he unvoted smarty two posts later. That too much to go on?

Yeah, no.

You didn't actually say that and I clearly wasn't unvoting in response to you.

You will also note the clear tonal shift to SRSPONY in my post, thus explaining the unvote of Smarty, which was a joke vote in the first place.

Your last post was five posts before, and had nothing to do with the subject matter you claim it did.

HoS: Geminex

[Mr.Bookworm]

Excuse me, you did post something (seven posts earlier), but given that I didn't quote you or otherwise respond to you, I'm not seeing how that can be construed as me being suspicious. Also, as my previous post pretty clearly shows, I had no idea that you had posted that until I looked into the backlog of the thread.

[Geminex]

Yes, that is something you do on Day 1.

True enough. Random voting is fine. But you started by randomly going for Oron and then switched to smarty because... he voted randomly? Seems kinda weird,

As for the 'joke', I'm not sure I get it. You encouraged people to vote for Smarty, despite the fact that you had minimal evidence to go on regarding his scumminess. Again, random voting, fine. Randomly encouraging the lynching of a random guy? Scummy.

I'm not seeing where you said that looked suspicious, and even if you did, I clearly wasn't unvoting in response to you.

As for this, well. You didn't seem to be unvoting in order to vote for someone else. You had just said you didn't have enough info on Nikose. And not much info on Smarty had come up in between that post and your last post. So why unvote him then, of all times? Acting 'randomly' again? Sure. Maybe. But your random unvoting came not long after I pointed out that your eagerness to get him lynched was suspicious.

Edit:

Excuse me, you did post something (seven posts earlier), but given that I didn't quote you or otherwise respond to you, I'm not seeing how that can be construed as me being suspicious. Also, as my previous post pretty clearly shows, I had no idea that you had posted that until I looked into the backlog of the thread.

Yes, seven posts, not two. Sorry bout that. And no, you didn't respond. But fact is, I pointed out that you were suspicious by acting in a certain way (trying to get smarty lynched), and not long after, you stopped acting that way. It may well just be a coincidence!
But given that it's day one, I think it's sufficient to vote for you. Nothing personal or anything.

Also, if you can prove that you hadn't seen my post, that'll be cool, but until then, all that your post 'pretty clearly shows' is you acting like you hadn't seen it. Whether you'd actually seen it is yours to know and ours to suspect.

[The Artist Formerly Known as Hawk]

Originally Posted by rpgdemon

For me, something about Hawk feels decidedly scummy, but I feel bad voting for him day one since he's new. But at the same time, that's the reason why I feel like he's scummy, since he's all, "Well, I'm town! Towning it up! I just have a reason the scum won't target me now, since it's mean to do so! But town won't vote for me, since I'm town."

It feels like he's setting himself up with an excuse, "Oh, they must not have killed me since I'm new.", and not really defending himself aside from, "I'm town, and thus have nothing to fear from a lynch."

Meh, maybe I am running abit too much towards the sympathy vote right now, but that's only because being lynched/killed night one would suck balls, and I do actually want to stick around long enough to learn the ins and outs of the game. I have no illusions of suriving to the end, hell I'll probably be killed off before I get halfway, but I atleast want a chance to, yano, actually play the game a bit before that happens. I can't really do much else to defend myself right now, I've only made 2 votes, 1 a joke and the other a genuine concern over a suspicious plan that you put forth, and I've stuck with it since. I seem to recall your defence to that was to simply post a youtube video that didn't explain anything.

The only other things I've done is ask questions about the game and try to wrap my head around all these backwards arguments, but none of them have done much to convince me of anything right now. What more can I do to defend myself?

Originally Posted by Bard The 5th LW

Anyways, Hawk gives me an odd vibe because of his weird pseudo presence, but he might just be new or busy so I dunno. However, Snake flipping right around on his head sorta gives him an odd feel to, like what if he's the Jester (whatever that means) like Smarty accused? Also, IHMN seems just flippant enough to get me suspicious.

HOS: Hawk, Snake, and IHMN

You're suspicious of me for... what, not posting on every page in the thread? Or not posting every other post like some people? What?! I do actually have stuff to do in the day man. There are people who haven't posted at all, or posted only once, what about their pseudo presence?

[Mr.Bookworm]

Originally Posted by Mr.Bookworm

Friendship the Hell Out of: Solid Snake

he knows what he did

First I joke voted for Snake.

Originally Posted by Smarty McBarrelpants

Vote: Oron
For being suspiciously quiet. I'm working my up the list because going down lists is what communists do.

Then Smarty posted this.

Originally Posted by Mr.Bookworm

Oh man something is clearly just the fuck up with Smarty.

Offer whimsical night of trotting and magic as apology to: Solid Snake

Friendship the hell out of: Smarty McBarrelpants

So I joke voted for him!

Originally Posted by Geminex

FRIENDSHIPPING THE HELL OUT OF: Smarty

Because
a) he isn't one of the herd and
b) I'm pretty sure smarty breaks things.

Originally Posted by Nikose Tyris

UNFRIENDSHIPPING: BARD

VOTE: SMARTY

BITCHES I DON'T NEED REASONS IT'S DAY 1.

Originally Posted by Mr.Bookworm

Good job, ponies, we got a nice bandwagon going on here, let's keep it rolling forward.

A bunch of people (including Geminex!) voted for Smarty right after I did, so I made a joke about jumping on the bandwagon.

Originally Posted by Nikose Tyris

Alduin was culted night 0.

RPG is serial Killer.

Snake is probably going to die by mafia kill night one.

Bob the merc is Cult leader.

Nikose then made this incredibly suspicious post, so...

Originally Posted by Mr.Bookworm

Nikose's post is such a blatantly obvious lie that I have no idea what he's going for.

He could be a lynch-blocker of some sort for the scum, trying to get us to waste a lynch on him.

He could be a Jester trying to win. I had that role, once, and I did something similar.

He could just be stupid.

Not enough data, unfortunately.

At any rate, Unvote: Smarty McBarrelpants.

...I got vaguely serious and rescinded my joke vote.

Originally Posted by Geminex

Bookworm, outta curiosity.
Why unvote smarty all of a sudden?

Originally Posted by Mr.Bookworm

I was not doing the SRSBIDNESS mafia thing when I voted for him. I might revote for him if I decide he's acting scummy, but I don't think he is right now.

Hell, we even had that exact conversation earlier in the thread.

[Geminex]

So why not vote for Nikose right away? If you suspected him, that'd be the logical thing to do. But you suspect Nikose enough to unvote smarty, but not enough to vote for him? Seems weird. And, again, you did it right after I said it made you look suspicious.

A bunch of people (including Geminex!) voted for Smarty right after I did, so I made a joke about jumping on the bandwagon.

As for this, yes, maybe a joke. But maybe an encouragement for other people to lynch smarty. Seems like a bit of both to me, which, again, begs the question, why would a townie encourage the lynching of a random guy? Even jokingly?

[Mr.Bookworm]

Originally Posted by Geminex

So why not vote for Nikose right away? If you suspected him, that'd be the logical thing to do. Yet you suspect him enough to unvote smarty, but not enough to vote for Nikose. And, again, you did it right after I said it made you look suspicious.

As I pointed out in my post, the possible roles I suspected are roles we don't want to lynch. I'm not going to vote for Nikose if I think he's the Jester or Lynchblocker.

And again, I unvoted Smarty because the vote was a joke, and I never intended to actually keep that vote on there. I unvoted when we started seeing things to go on, instead of just random voting.

As for this, yes, maybe a joke. But maybe an encouragement for other people to lynch smarty. Seems like a bit of both to me, which, again, begs teh question, why would a townie encourage the lynching of a random guy?

You haven't played Mafia before, right?

The people who start out leading the lynching polls on Day 1 because of whatever joke is in vogue at the time don't actually get lynched, unless they act scummy otherwise.

[Nikose Tyris]

Hahahahhaha this is the best day 1 I have ever seen

Like no word of a lie if ever a game was going to get started, 180 posts is just the right way to fuckin' do it.


I'd just like to take a moment and say how proud I am of every single one of you, and remind everyone that someone is going to die today, and then probably like 2, maybe 3 someone's tonight.