My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[Solid Snake]

Originally Posted by Sifright

I'm the town vanilla doctor, I don't have any powers basically I'm supposed to be senile according to my role and the only person i could remember was karesh as fluttershy

Edit persumably the only townies with powers will be the ones are elements of harmony.

...
...There is something very, very suspicious about all of this.
Really, liking Sifright less and less at the moment.

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Originally Posted by Solid Snake

...
...There is something very, very suspicious about all of this.
Really, liking Sifright less and less at the moment.

But liking me more and more, right?

[Solid Snake]

Originally Posted by Karesh

But liking me more and more, right?

I really have no opinion of you at the moment.
I have several objections against Sifright.
Really the only thing that confuses me is why Sifright would threaten to quit and/or be Modkilled when caught 'bending the rules' and claim he was Town if doing so was a lie. He'd have to have real confidence that Fenris wasn't going to toss him and immediately completely invalidate his own supposed 'moment of truth.'

But there's so much not adding up with Sifright right now. So very much.

[Geminex]

Could you elaborate? Cause it seems to make sense. Sif reveals his role on the spur of the moment, and then reveals Karesh's.

And I think they're both truthful.

Sif and Karesh are both claiming that Karesh is fluttershy. A townie. I'm pretty sure Karesh is actually fluttershy, since if he wasn't the real fluttershy could call him out on it. So question is only how Sif knew about Karesh's role. And, I dunno. If he was scummy, why would he reveal something that takes suspicion away from Karesh?

Edit:

Hey, Sifright. The flavor text is usually pretty distinctive. Could you post yours?

[Sifright]

Well I presumed I was going to be mod killed, and I was going to quit because one of the reasons i don't normally partake in mafia games is because how easy it for things to be taken to far from insinuations in the game to be taken personally.

Out of interest what other things aren't adding up prehaps I can help explain what they are, if you are genuinely town discussing things with me so that I can try and explain my position should logically be exactly what you want as lynching a townie even when it's a vanilla role now they my information is out there is pretty harmful.

Full Role name is "Doctor Whooves, The Doctor, town-aligned" Also i've been alive 900 years apparently.

[Sifright]

are we allowed to post flavor text? Will ask fenris for a response before i do that

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Originally Posted by Geminex

Elaborate, maybe? Cause it seems to make sense. Guy reveals his role on the spur of the moment, and then reveals Karesh's.

And I think they're right.

Sif and Karesh are both claiming that Karesh is fluttershy. A townie. I'm pretty sure Karesh is actually fluttershy, since if he wasn't the real fluttershy could call him out on it. So question is only how Sif knew about Karesh's role. And, I dunno. If he was scummy, why would he reveal something that takes suspicion away from Karesh?

Nonoonono.

No.
Sif knew that there was a Fluttershy. That's a basic assumption you could make just from the name of the game. The mane six were always incredibly likely to be involved.

Sif stated outright that he knew who Fluttershy is, and I declared myself Fluttershy and then he confirmed it.
It's very important to keep in mind that Sif didn't declare me Fluttershy directly until I had claimed the role. It's perfectly understandable behavior from his perspective so it's not a suspicious move, but it's also not a move that clears him or me from suspicion.

[Geminex]

Oh, right. Yeah, thanks for that. So, okay. Sif still suspicious. He could be scum and trying to a) lure fluttershy out of hiding (maybe thinking that fluttershy is the doctor?) and b) protect himself from lynching. Hmm.

Does anyone know if Sif is a brony?

Edit: To elaborate on that, Dr. Whooves is more of an inside joke than anything else, a non-brony wouldn't know about him unless that was actually his role.

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

At that I feel the only thing that's slightly off is that Sif is saying he knew ONLY the fluff character name and not the role. This allowed him to make the claim without there being anyway for me as the character he was claiming to make any assertions. If he had said "I Know who fluttershy is and Fluttershy is the Doctor" then suddenly I can pop in and go "HOLD YER HORSES"

Again it's not really all that suspicious. A role like that can easily exist, and from that perspective of "I know who Fluttershy is but not what he can do" it's plain to see why Sif would be hesitant to actually call it out until I revealed.

[Solid Snake]

Strangely enough no one really has enunciated any of my personal objections to Sifright's behavior. Though I almost hope someone other than Karesh actually is Fluttershy, claims Fluttershy, and we can kill Sifright here and now (possibly Karesh as well, though I'd think it's equally possible, and in fact would be strategically smart, if Karesh as a non-Fluttershy Townie claimed Fluttershy just to catch Sifright in the lie.)

But really while Karesh and Sifright's quarrel has been intriguing, there's a lot more basic and fundamental things that Sifright has said and done that sound off alarm bells for me.

EDIT: One of which has now been eliminated. I initially thought Sifright was claiming to be a 'vanilla doctor,' as in both vanilla and the doctor in a Mafia game, you know, the power role that prevents people from dying. Should've enunciated your role a bit more from the get-go.
...Still have issues with Sifright though.