My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[Revising Ocelot]

Originally Posted by Hawk

it's interesting to note at least that the mafia didn't make a kill last night, only the sk and the vig. So either they were blocked by someone or they just never got their votes in.

I doubt the former, but maybe we do have a working Doctor after all? We've already got one "Doctor" who can't actually do any Doctor...ing. I just assumed there wouldn't be a Doc as it's fairly synonymous with the Bodyguard. That does lead more credence to Nikose being a faulty PO as there could be a working PO too... but then, by that same standard Sifright would have been told that he could save people, which he denies. Hmph.

[Revising Ocelot]

I doubt the former

EDIT: latter. I meant I doubt they didn't get their votes in.

[rpgdemon]

Originally Posted by Sifright

Despite my rather great dislike of the mistake aldurin made with him being confirmed town I can't afford to over look the increased chances that exist to hit mafia.

Putting myself Aldurin and Karesh together gives us 3 of 15 players as a cohesive voting block. Which is a fairly statiscally relevant 20% of which aren't mafia. now I'm presuming there are a total of five mafia and one SK. This leads to 6 out of 15 being Scum. meaning any one my self or karesh votes for has a 50/50 chance of being scum assuming we were to pick randomly.

Well, we can't trust yourself and Karesh. So we have 1/15 players that we know isn't scum.

Originally Posted by Sifright

I'm still for voting Nikose because I don't believe him and on the off chance that he is telling the truth about his role it may tell us more about whether IHMN is trust worthy. I don't like the idea of killing a potential towny for that but the stuff nikose was saying about Snake was based on alot of half truths and the one thing townies should never ever do is lie. Lieing as a townie only ever hurts town unless your hiding your own power role.

Based on what Snake was saying earlier, going off of what we've seen from previous games, was last game your first game? Since, I remember you being no where near this proactive. You're definitely acting differently than you were before, but it might just be the difference between your first game and a second game.

Originally Posted by Sifright

Ok from what i can see only Smarty voted for Fawful.

How ever Hawk showed a fair amount of interest in him earlier in the thread and wanted to push people towards him.

So my list of suspicions are

Nikose (Lied about stuff snake said)
Hawk (interested in Fawfulcopter)
Bard (Posted about Fawful as well *tenous link*)

As someone mentioned above, a fair number of people voted Fawful, actually. Myself included. As such, I'm hesitant to think anyone who voted Fawful is scum. :P

I voted him because he was active during the nighttime, but hadn't posted at all in the thread, and also because I had assumed Fenris had made inactive replacements, but he said that he hadn't.

Also, Aldurin, stop being so gung ho about who you think is scum. Last game you did it to me, and killed the bulletproof, this game you killed the doctor. D:< Additional bluh bluhs.

In general actually, I encourage everyone to keep an open mind and be willing to change what you think about people, either scum or town, if given reason not to vote someone. I mean, make sure it's a GOOD reason, but I'm just thinking back to last game, where there were like 50 reasons not to lynch me, and Aldurin just kept going, "NOPE, NOT LISTENING, YOU'RE SCUM SCUMMY SCUM SCUM YOU SHOULD STOP ARGUING."

[Verifiedz]

Well maybe it is that i dont get the game, but its gonna take like a half hour to read all that stuff. I dont have the patience.i read a bit but otherwise nothing.

[rpgdemon]

Also, I think the mafia were the nightmarish mare that visited Zacora, then got chased away.

Zacora seems like she was a bulletproof role, but then got killed off because of a second attack, which is exactly how my bulletproof role worked last game. It even implied that she wouldn't have been killed by the SK, had she not been so distracted, since she would have been able to will herself back from stone.

I don't know how likely it is that we have two bulletproofs, but having one who has unlimited immunity to everything, and one who has only a single kill block doesn't seem right. I'm really suspicious of Karesh right now.

[Bard The 5th LW]

Aldurin flat knew I was Scum last game but didn't lynch me, so there's a bit of a bad track record there. We should all apply logic to this, and not just go off a hunch, or else we get more moon'd ponies.

[Revising Ocelot]

Originally Posted by rpgdemon

Also, I think the mafia were the nightmarish mare that visited Zacora, then got chased away.

Zacora seems like she was a bulletproof role, but then got killed off because of a second attack, which is exactly how my bulletproof role worked last game.

I'd say that falls in line with Doctor protection, actually. Can block one kill, but not two simultaneously.

[rpgdemon]

Originally Posted by Fenris

In the Everfree forest:

The nightly mare slowly crept towards the unassuming hut. Unfortunately for the mare, the resident of said hut was not nearly as daft as the rest of the easily tricked ponies.

"What sort of creature dares to roam this near to my humble home?" Zecora yelled.

The mare took off in a gallop, plunging deeper into the Everfree forest. The zebra pursued her, yelling in rhyme the entire time while.

Minutes, or perhaps hours, or perhaps some combination of the two later, the mare had managed to elude the zebra.

"I had almost caught that Nightmare... she was practically right there! Now how am I to return to my chamber, when I am this far lost in nature?"

"Nightly Mare", sorry, not "Nightmarish Mare." But I'd think that's where the Mafia's kill went.

[Sifright]

If you vote lynch Karesh I will kill you IRL, just so you know. Any one who suggest vote lynching Karesh with out lynching me first is a complete and utter retarded moronic fool and I will hold no punches with calling people that. Kill me first at the very god damn least before you lynch the person who is immune to bloody mafia night actions.

Based on Rpgdemons last post alone

FOS:RPGDEMON

[rpgdemon]

Originally Posted by Revolving Ocelot

I'd say that falls in line with Doctor protection, actually. Can block one kill, but not two simultaneously.

If we're allowed to quote what Snake said last game to us, I'll post my role from that here, but it was decidedly one kill would fail, and then I'd no longer be bulletproof.

And our doctor died, is why I'm guessing bulletproof. Unless we have two.