My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[Revising Ocelot]

Yeah, I'd written up that post yesterday as I was initially going to roleclaim early. Didn't proofcheck it, hence the stupid mistake. Then I saw the full role claim idea was going ahead, so I bided my time until my 2 Scum targets took the bait. They did.

[Ravashak]

I'm the new player 14, currently reading up on the thread, will post more when I've caught up.

[Aldurin]

Whoa, shocking developments.

First of all, you're an idiot Sifright, don't try to get yourself lynched when you're the doctor.

Second, this is very useful information we could use from the investigations.

Third, it just occurred to me that the doctor voting for himself is very odd. So this my final theory is that the remaining mafia may very well be RO, Sifright and Karesh. Sifright was daring people to vote him out to prove Karesh as the bulletproof, gutsy move but stupid if you're a doctor. That would shake suspicion off of them. Then later RO could claim to be the cop (especially if they offed the actual cop) in order to fully support Sifright's claim and then brand Oron and greed as definite scum (not too hard since we've been suspecting greed) with their inactivity working in the advantage of the claim.

What I'm saying is that I'm very cautious of this massive claim, partially because the mafia leader would probably have an ability to make himself show up as "innocent".

[Aldurin]

Also, Sifright agreeing to vote Oron and supporting the idea that the mafia leader isn't unscannable makes this even more suspicious for me.

[Revising Ocelot]

Sifright already said he wasn't a proper doctor right from the start.

Obviously if there actually is a working doctor still it'd be nice if could be saved tonight, but I doubt it.

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by rpgdemon

Also, I think the mafia were the nightmarish mare that visited Zacora, then got chased away.

Zacora seems like she was a bulletproof role, but then got killed off because of a second attack, which is exactly how my bulletproof role worked last game. It even implied that she wouldn't have been killed by the SK, had she not been so distracted, since she would have been able to will herself back from stone.

I don't know how likely it is that we have two bulletproofs, but having one who has unlimited immunity to everything, and one who has only a single kill block doesn't seem right. I'm really suspicious of Karesh right now.

based on this I think Rpgdemon is the SK, so i'm undecided on whether we should kill RPGDEMON now and remove a kill each night or go ahead and lynch Oron. Which presumably doesn't change the state of the game.

Gregness could you roleblock RPGdemon and test it out during the night? That way he loses the ability to SK kill during the night if it's him. I know people are saying "Oh but the SK just wont kill" Well if the SK does that it's fine because we have a second mafia player to target afterwards.

Edit: and the SK will start targeting townies now that the mafia are in such a perilous state, as the SK can't afford to not kill people role blocking RPGdemon publicly won't be a bad idea.

[Aldurin]

Originally Posted by Revolving Ocelot

Sifright already said he wasn't a proper doctor right from the start.

Obviously if there actually is a working doctor still it'd be nice if could be saved tonight, but I doubt it.

Originally Posted by Revolving Ocelot

Night 1: I investigated Sifright. He's Doctor Whooves, the Doctor, town-aligned. By extension that confirms Karesh is Town, too.

That sounds pretty Doctor to me, can you link the post where Sifright first makes the doctor claim?

For reference:

HoS: Revolving Ocelot
HoS: Sifright
HoS: Karesh

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by Aldurin

Whoa, shocking developments.

First of all, you're an idiot Sifright, don't try to get yourself lynched when you're the doctor.

Second, this is very useful information we could use from the investigations.

Third, it just occurred to me that the doctor voting for himself is very odd. So this my final theory is that the remaining mafia may very well be RO, Sifright and Karesh. Sifright was daring people to vote him out to prove Karesh as the bulletproof, gutsy move but stupid if you're a doctor. That would shake suspicion off of them. Then later RO could claim to be the cop (especially if they offed the actual cop) in order to fully support Sifright's claim and then brand Oron and greed as definite scum (not too hard since we've been suspecting greed) with their inactivity working in the advantage of the claim.

What I'm saying is that I'm very cautious of this massive claim, partially because the mafia leader would probably have an ability to make himself show up as "innocent".

I'm not the ACTUAL town doctor i'm just titled the doctor as in 'The doctor' from doctor who. The pony fandom turned this one characters appeareance into a giant doctor who reference, See youtube embed below





Also Aldurin for the purposes of alleviating your concern.

Originally Posted by Sifright

I'm the town vanilla doctor, I don't have any powers basically I'm supposed to be senile according to my role and the only person i could remember was karesh as fluttershy

Edit persumably the only townies with powers will be the ones are elements of harmony.

Originally Posted by Sifright

Well I presumed I was going to be mod killed, and I was going to quit because one of the reasons i don't normally partake in mafia games is because how easy it for things to be taken to far from insinuations in the game to be taken personally.

Out of interest what other things aren't adding up prehaps I can help explain what they are, if you are genuinely town discussing things with me so that I can try and explain my position should logically be exactly what you want as lynching a townie even when it's a vanilla role now they my information is out there is pretty harmful.

Full Role name is "Doctor Whooves, The Doctor, town-aligned" Also i've been alive 900 years apparently.

Edit: Also http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Doctor_Whooves

Blah Youtube embed doesn't work linking to said video instead

First: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3qS0odekuU

Second:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PHUjY...eature=related

Notice the Cutie mark is a egg timer.

[Aldurin]

Ok, that alleviates my suspicious, but I will go for you if Oron isn't scum.

Unvote: greed

Vote: Oron

Also to fix the youtube embedding you have to remove everything but the random series of characters from the link.

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by Aldurin

Whoa, shocking developments.

First of all, you're an idiot Sifright, don't try to get yourself lynched when you're the doctor.

Second, this is very useful information we could use from the investigations.

Third, it just occurred to me that the doctor voting for himself is very odd. So this my final theory is that the remaining mafia may very well be RO, Sifright and Karesh. Sifright was daring people to vote him out to prove Karesh as the bulletproof, gutsy move but stupid if you're a doctor. That would shake suspicion off of them. Then later RO could claim to be the cop (especially if they offed the actual cop) in order to fully support Sifright's claim and then brand Oron and greed as definite scum (not too hard since we've been suspecting greed) with their inactivity working in the advantage of the claim.

What I'm saying is that I'm very cautious of this massive claim, partially because the mafia leader would probably have an ability to make himself show up as "innocent".

I don't really appreciate being called an Idiot and if I was the actual town doctor I wouldn't draw attention to my self at all if i could help it. Go to page 4/5 At 80 posts per page and look at my posts I'm a vanilla townie that started with knowledge of Karesh as fluttershy.