NPF Mafia: 8-Bit Edition SP

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by Pyros

First you said yourself if Jer is innocent that that puts you into suspicion, and as seen he is innocent.

Two you put Fos on me for saying a correct thing, though that was probaly a mistake.

Three, really newb the way you post is mostly it, I just get a bad feel from it. Though obviously thats not something you can vote one, which is why I only did Fos.

Well the whole jer thing meant that either me or him became instantly suspicious. I really don't think Newb is a bad guy here. He's acting aggresive like he did in game one. I still have doubts on him, but nothing serious.

[SpoonyBard]

Goddamn. We NEVER get anything suspicious to follow up on. The only possiblities are Neyo,and maybe Mestizio, and Newb. Neyo I believe is a non-mafia because he retracted his vote for jer when it was quite possible that Mestizio could have turned the tables around and could jer un-lynched. Mestizio seems a tad shady to me, and so is Newb, but they were AGAINST lynching jer, eliminating them as possiblities. Leaving us a nice, fat, zero.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by SpoonyBard

Goddamn. We NEVER get anything suspicious to follow up on. The only possiblities are Neyo,and maybe Mestizio, and Newb. Neyo I believe is a non-mafia because he retracted his vote for jer when it was quite possible that Mestizio could have turned the tables around and could jer un-lynched. Mestizio seems a tad shady to me, and so is Newb, but they were AGAINST lynching jer, eliminating them as possiblities. Leaving us a nice, fat, zero.

Well, there is always Neyo...

You do have a large point, though. We have very little to work on.

If Neyo's Innocent, These Are The Biggest Suspects
Mestizio
GARUD
FenrisWolf

Mestizio because she's basically leading the way against Neyo.
GARUD because he's claiming "I told you so", and actually voted for Neyo.
Me because I've been accused of trying to lynch Neyo, when I'm not. I am merely trying to find out who is mafiate and who is not.

[neyo the king]

Fenris, I'm not really sure how to react, except that it seems your basing your whole voting process on me. And that's not neccacerily (god, I'm butchering the English Language there...) a bad thing, as I'm the only one who seems to have done something suspicious so far in this game, and all you really have to go on is what happened and the way others reacted between me and jer. I'm just a little afraid that you keep bringing up my name, is all.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Neyo the King

Fenris, I'm not really sure how to react, except that it seems your basing your whole voting process on me. And that's not neccacerily (god, I'm butchering the English Language there...) a bad thing, as I'm the only one who seems to have done something suspicious so far in this game, and all you really have to go on is what happened and the way others reacted between me and jer. I'm just a little afraid that you keep bringing up my name, is all.

I understand, but who's name do you suggest I bring up?

You aren't the only one who's acting fishy to me. Druidal seemed awfully quick to declare his own innocence...

[GARUD]

well, you wanna know why I'm voting for Neyo? It's because he has not provided a single good reason as to why he is innocent. He has flown under the radar, very effectively, but still kept himself out in the open enough to bandwagon or accuse without raising suspicion. He also had something against jer, for him being free with his vote (jer seemed to be inexperienced rather than scummy).

The I told you so thing was just something extra I wanted to say, ever since seeing I-robot. But it was true though. I did tell you so and he was innocent.

Fenris, I believe your list of suspicion is kinda false. A mobster would bandwagon or lead a charge AGAINST an innocent. Not away from one. Look at it this way. Me and Mest both gave points about Jer's innocence. And you Fenris, well, I just plain and simply don't suspect you outright. You raise valid points for all sides of the argument, and go with the one you feel most likely is mafia. You are neither a leader, nor a bandwagoner. Thus, you are not mafia.

Now to throw one of everybody elses points back at them. We don't need a townie who will lead charges against innocents. Neyo also reminds me of psycho mantis and jer reminds me of Newb. Newb and jer were agressive, and caught too much attention. PS and Neyo used that against them, and we ended up lynching innocents. No matter what he is, Neyo is a nuisance. Evan as a BG or PO or VG is he a nuisance. I think he should be next anyway.

As you can see, I have relevant points against Neyo, whilst he has not one even giving himself a glimps of being a townie.

Think about who you vote for before you do anything.

[Bailey]

Originally Posted by Pyros

First you said yourself if Jer is innocent that that puts you into suspicion, and as seen he is innocent.

Two you put Fos on me for saying a correct thing, though that was probaly a mistake.

Three, really newb the way you post is mostly it, I just get a bad feel from it. Though obviously thats not something you can vote one, which is why I only did Fos.

1: Good, that's valid, you should have said that when you FoS'd me. You forget, however, that it was later mentioned that whether he was townie or mafiate he had to go. I'm willing to dismiss this as you not paying attention.

2: I put an FoS on you after you put one on me without any evidence. You cannot use situations arising from your own lack of evidence as evidence after the fact. This makes you seem more scummy.

3: So my writing style worries you. Yeah, you can use this as evidence as soon as the mafia kills somebody with an essay. This is more of a reason for you to keep an eye on me than for anyone else to do so. It's one thing to follow your own mad hunch, it's quite another to get other people in on the mad hunch as well. This makes you seem a little more scummy, but not much, and barely at all as compared to the second point.



I do find it suspicious that Neyo hasn't tried to fight off any of the arguments yet though, and has only posted (what seems to me) irrelevant things

[Incendius]

Not just writing style Newb, your tone (Yes I know there is no tone of voice on the internet) how you adress people, and else.

No jermiachan did NOT have to go, your forgetting that people have free will, even if he tried to lead people to do something, you and everyone else who doesn't believe that could have said with your much longer, and probaly better posts why no don't vote for that person. One less towny is never good, and they never have to go, unless they have been actually leading many many crusades against other townies.

I don't see jermiachan as doing that.


I'm talking about when I said that you can't post anything such as a list of mafia after you die, which was the correct ruling, and you jumped on me saying I was a mafia for it.


Right now the people that are on the top of my list are in no particular order, Newb, Fenris, Neyo, and Mestizio.



Edit: Right now I am just trying to lay the foundation of my arguments, and put each piece of evidence like brick by brick until I have a stable place for a good opinion.

[Bailey]

It did say quite clearly in the rules that you get a last words post before you die. Just because CmP changed his mind after posting the rules doesn't mean that it wasn't the original case. In my mind, the fact that you knew CmP had changed his mind before anybody else did makes you even more scummy, and causes me to think that the game is rigged, as it shows you have been in private communication with the GO.

[The SSB Intern]

Originally Posted by Pyros

I'm talking about when I said that you can't post anything such as a list of mafia after you die, which was the correct ruling, and you jumped on me saying I was a mafia for it.Right now the people that are on the top of my list are in no particular order, Newb, Fenris, Neyo, and Mestizio.

I think that announcing your enemies is probaly not a good idea. I'm gonna vote: no lynch until I can get some good solid evidence.