Soldiers of Light: Mafia

[catlover20410]

It's a FoS. It's not a vote. He isn't gonna die from FoSes.


Which, come to think of it, makes me wonder what the hell the purpose of an FoS is anyway.

[GARUD]

Catlover, I am very suspicious of you, but the thing is I cannot tell if this is inexperience or mafianess. One way or the other though, I'm gonna watch you like a hawk.

As suspicious as you are, I have no defintive evidence. So, I'm holding my vote until I feel you are worthy of prosecution.

[TheSpacePope]

I'd say that that may have been a mistake, or a clue to identity.
We could be talking about a town aligned role as well.
I am not sure, I am holding out on my FoS and My vote, but a list as to how everyone is voting AND FoS'ing would be nice. Hey God, I pray for a list....

*edited to update counts/
so far i think we got
1 vote catlover
1 vote newb (see post below)
1 fos silly kitty
2 fos Ahra
1 fos Darthmauler

and in my opinion, there is too much suspicious activity by Ahra, Rhyia(who may have cleared herself with the last post, i have to re read it again), and Skeleton, for his weak defense of ahra, look man, if you are going to help someone, you might want to have something more concrete than, "it was a joke" We all know that jokes are freudian, so Ahra is telling us something there, I am just not sure what.

[secretskull]

Newb, you’re looking very suspicious to me. You have just voted for Arhra for a reason little better then the one IHMN was lynched for. A joke .

In addition:

Originally Posted by Newb

Okay, from this, Mesden, I assume that you sent out PM's asking people why they weren't posting. A slight logical leap brings us to the theory that this was the first PM he got about the game, meaning that he received no role. So I'm fairly certain that JudasPreistFan started as a regular plain vanilla townie.

This isn't a "slight logical" leap it's a rather big jump of imagination, if anything. Had this been the reason for not posting he would have simply joined the game, not quit. The only thing we can say is that Crotchknocker had problems in Life (As Mesden said), and couldn't post, so he was replaced. That is it.

Originally Posted by Newb

The other possibility here is that there were no PM’s sent out asking about the absence of posting just yet, but Crotchknocker nevertheless did get a PM. A cult initiation PM. He then replied to it in confusion, and thus we have him out.

This theory is little better then the last one, with you ignoring what Mesden said about his reason for leaving yet again. It seems to me that you are trying to breed confusion here. This leads me to Vote: Newb .

[P-Sleazy]

Except that his reasoning about Crotchknocker and Judaspriestfan isnt all that wrong. I naturally assumed that as well as he would have replied earlier to Mesden what the hell that role meant and why he got it if he was unaware he had signed up for the Mafia game. Thusly, I beleive JudasPriestfan to have assumed Crotchknockers townie/monk role.

[TheSpacePope]

So here are my FoS's for this round

1. ahra
2. secretskull
3 skeleton
4. and catlover (seperate from top three)

catlover is in a group all by the lonesome, just acting suspicious.

why those other three? Simple, In my mind Ahra made a mistake in letting something go about his identity with a "JOKE" now two people have come out and said that it was a joke, meaning< possible that there was a PM conversation about the slipup. What I can't figure out is why everyone thinks that it was a joke is a great excuse. It's not. It doesn't hold water with me. this may be why the wandering god wants no one defending him, because that shit is weak and we havent even heard from ahra to verify his own joke. How am I supposed to take that seriously?

This is not a vote, I just want to hear why you guys think that "it was a joke" is a great defense. And TWG what do you think about what I have here.

[The Wandering God]

When I FoS, Silly Kitty, that was partially to see how she would react, and to remind myself to look back through her posts and ponder on what she said so far. So, now I'm going to quote everything she said. No posts have been edited.

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

Sucks losing MoM. It was probably people from the last mafia.

Edit: To get things moving Vote: No Lynch

As CmP would point out, a No Lynch vote is very bad. Also... look at the second sentence. There is no way to know how or why the Mafia hit MoM. She directly implies that it is people from the last game. And what does this do? Starts an argument that doesn't actually lead anywhere. It also confuses the new people.

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

Okay, I see what you mean.

I was just trying to get the game moving, which is what I did. With no leads, what are we suppose to do?

And yet, didn't unvote your No Lynch yet. Possible reason: leaving it up so others skimming for votes would see that and vote no lynch too. And how did SK say there were no leads when she said it was "probably people from the last mafia"?

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

DarthMauler hasn't been around for very long. I think a miscount is just an honest mistake and has absolutely nothing to do with the game, other than it being a miscount about the game.

Now she shifts into DarthMauler defense mode.

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

Now now, we are not gonna lynch someone just to get something done.

What do we know about Darthmauler other than he miscounted the mafia? Let's just wait for better clues.

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

I honestly believe Darthmauler made a silly mistake. If I'm wrong about that, oh well.

TWG, I just get a very bad feeling when I read your posts. You seem very suspicious to me. I know that isn't much to go on so I'm not voting for you. But, Fos: The Wandering God

Ecurt: But they are very yummy! Unvote: No lynch

Now she FoS's me. Important note: This is after I unvoted for the person that she had been defending. I smell something rotten. Oh, and she finally unvotes the No Lynch after someone else notices it.

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

I understand that you voted for Darthmauler to move the game along, but I think the forgetting to count yourself thing is a little weak. I know it was all we had to go on but I don't feel it was a very good choice. Plus, I just get a bad feeling about you that I have nothing to go on. This is why I'm not voting for you and just keeping an eye on you.

I also feel that Darthmauler just made a silly mistake like I did in the first game. Our mistakes were different but I think they are similar.

But I had already unvoted him? Bad feeling with nothing to go on? Wow, lobbing an accusation based on a feeling that you already can't back up?

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

I know that Raiden was on last night, in chat8bit anyway. He was on and didn't make any posts. Maybe because he didn't know it was day? If we were to get someone off who didn't contribute he would be my fist vote(so hurry up and post Raiden!).

Note: I hope Raiden's okay. Nothing particulary incriminating or anything to gives any doubt to her guilt either.

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

Are you calling the GO a cheater?

Very delicate right here. But she was the first person to respond to IHMN (who wasn't very cool, but townie nonetheless), and, of course, this started the landslide that eventually resulted in him getting lynched. Of course, 90% of that is his fault.

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

I'm not quite sure IHMN is mafia. I think IHMN might just be a regular old townie. That is just the vibe I get from him. Besides, why would you complain about cheating if you had a role you liked, and I'm sure IHMN would like being in the mafia.

As for me seeming kinda eager to kill, I guess I got caught up in the bandwagon, but you will notice that I haven't voted for anyone yet.

No you haven't. But you have been very clever. As a matter of fact, you seem to know a lot about everybody. My (supposed) guilt, DarthMauler's innocence, and IHMN's innocene. Of course, if IHMN names does turn up to be innocent... Well, won't that be nice for you?

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

He doesn't have much time on the computer, Newb. IC was gone for most of the day yesterday and will be gone for most of the day today.

I guess we will just wait and see if IHMN is mafia for now. I doubt anyone would switch their vote in the last two hours.

Defending another person. And, of course, now she won't need to vote for IHMN, because I'm sure he had pissed off enough townies to where the mafia didn't need to do much about it.

Night passes. The bodyguard saves me from 3 separate hits.

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

Wow, I fell really dumb TWG. I guess I wasn't alone in my feeling though. I apologize. But hey, I was right about IHMN not being mafia.

Edit: 300th post! Woo!

No, you were exactly right about IHMN not being mafia. Though you did seem pretty sure of it even before that. Oh, and thanks for that vote of confidence.

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

I'm not going to agree with you on the bodyguard convert part because the CL hadn't had a chance to convert anyone yet. I do agree with you that TWG may in fact be the CL. Let's keep out eyes open and not rule him out just yet.

Or not. What happened? Well, at 7:24am Rhiya Ravenwing, made the first mention of me being the CL. Your post above "Wow, I fell really...." was at 4:24 in the pm. Then, this latest post was at 6:41. Well over 2 hours later. What happened? I think the mafia wanted to start a ball of suspicion rolling so that the BG would doubt protecting me in the next round, making for an easy kill. And even if they didn't do it, the imposter might.

And her last post so far

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

TWG, I'm just saying we can't totally rule you out. You may just be a townie or you may be the CL. I'm not FoSing you anymore, I'm just saying it COULD be you. I'm not saying it is. Wouldn't a CL wanna take down the mafia and imposter anyway?

That's exactly what you are doing. Trying to cast doubt on me so the BG won't protect me again. Oh, who else wants to tell the BG what to do? Newb.

I'm going to
Vote: Silly Kitty
Reasons: all stated in my post.

Now, I have some good news and some bad news.

If I am right: Well, we lose a mafia member. And there are several ties and people she defended, thus giving us an ample list of suspects.

If I am wrong: We have a much better idea of who is innocent. DarthMauler for one.

The Wandering God

[Bailey]

I'm not telling the bodygaurd to do anything.

I'm just saying what I would do if I were in that role.

I mean, last game I said what I would do if I were the CL, but did that make me the CL, or even somebody telling the CL what to do?



But yeah, I can see how it might have been interpreted that way, if I weren't me. This is a major reason in my opinion for looking at previous games. By looking at the way people play even as a townie one can tell whether behavior is suspicious or typical.

[IOWACJE]

Originally Posted by Newb

I'm keeping track of this entire game using an excel spreadsheet. It's the same thing I did last game, and so far three of my four mafiate guesses have turned out right over there.

I'll post my list when I feel that enough time has passed for the list to be accurate.

I wouldn't be surprised if you became a target of the mafia now. The mafia might be nervous about an organized list.

[Mesden]

I am about to PM KBM, RMB and Druidal about inactivity.

Newb, you know Druidal in real life, so I won't mind if you tell him he needs to get back in the game. Or, you know, actually get in the game in the first place.

EXPECT A DEADLINE SOMETIME SATURDAY NIGHT!