Mafia: Basic

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by Supreme Edgemaster

Ok. I guess that is kind of a stupid way to vote.

UNVOTE: Mesden

I just don't know what to base my vote on. Who I hate in the forums or just the way people act? Any help would...well...help.

Yeah, personal differences...NOT the way to go. The way people act seems to be the popular opinion.

From what we saw, you didn't mention anything about HOW I acted, just about how much experience I have doing it.

[Thundergod Cid]

Originally Posted by Supreme Edgemaster

I just don't know what to base my vote on. Who I hate in the forums or just the way people act? Any help would...well...help.

The way people act in this topic. Basing votes on who you dislike in the forums isn't a good idea, since it's a random number generator and not people's personalities that determines who gets what role. Roleclaims, suspicious behavior, and the results of the Reporter and Detective's investigations (Detective only once they've been revealed, of course) are typical things that votes are based off of in this game.

Though, we don't really have much to go on right now. Hence, why many people are saying "Wow, I have no idea who to vote for."

[Silly Kitty]

Well, why don't you go over this game a bit. Read back through the posts. I don't think you are mafia but please try harder.

Also, CMP, I'm gonna FOS you because you seem to be defending the mafia a lot. Not a vote because I have no reason other than that.

[Supreme Edgemaster]

Originally Posted by Mesden HERSELF FOR GOD'S SAKE
EDIT: wow, Sith's right, actually... I haven't done shit for the town...Ever...

That is a reason to suspect you as mafia. But I will hold my vote for later. For now I'll just wait it out and...

FOS: Mesden

I want to know why you never did anything for a town aligned role up to this point.

[Silly Kitty]

Because she has never been a townie.

That is not her fault and is not a reason to FOS her. Sorry if I'm defending you Mes. I'm just answering a question.

[Supreme Edgemaster]

Well seeing as I have no basis to vote for anyone...

VOTE: No Lynch

I hope I see the darker side of some people next vote so that I can actually hit someone.

[P-Sleazy]

you won't see a darker side. the most you'll be able to make out of anyone is a marble cake (meaning, you can't tell whether their good, bad, smart, idiots, etc). no one will ever appear black or white unless revealed to us by the detective, Reporter, GO's hints (if any are given in death posts), or the mafia just messes up HORRIBLY.

also no lynch is a bad thing. I'll work out the probabilities for killing evil roles later tonight if we dont lynch.

And if I were to go on the whole personal differences thing...I'd probably vote myself a million times over. God I hate myself!

[Silly Kitty]

Originally Posted by CallMePrismatic

First, it's never good to no lynch, not on the first day, not ever. We shouldn't look at it like a "Well, we've got nothing to go on so let's do nothing", it's rings more loudly like "I don't want to upset anybody so I'm going to give the Night-Killers a free pass".

Voting No Lynch doesn't allow us to fast forward in an effort to find clues, because Night doesn't provide more clues, just more corpses. You want to know the odds that someone will die at the mafiates or SK's hands tonight if we lynch someone. 1:1. If we don't lynch? 1:1. We'll only have better odds because more people will have died (and hopefully the Vig won't be so trigger happy toNight).

Maybe you should try and read up on what has happened so far.

[Ogianres]

Small FOS: Supreme Edgemaster
I don't think you are neccesarily scum, so much as you are just inexperienced.
And by the way, voting no lynch will never help us in this game.

[Supreme Edgemaster]

I know voting No Lynch will help no one but I have no basis to vote for anyone. So I don't have a remote hope in the world of picking someone to vote for "With Reason" so I have no choice.