Mafia: Basic

[The Wandering God]

Originally Posted by h4x.m4g3

Yeah, but I get the feeling he's not. Wether or not he was shadowing (learning how to be) the Doc, we may never know, unless newb says he manages to learn it independently or something. But really why would he make up a useless trait, when he could have easily just ran with your suspicion of him being the reporter?

Because the REAL reporter would almost certainly target them. Same with the Vig. And since that leaves the PO as the last possible useful role, I'd be more than willing to say he isn't.

The Wandering God

EDIT: Because I just HAVE to fricking acknowledge what CmP just said.

Originally Posted by CallmePrismatic

On catlover, I...wait a sec, deja vu...


So you didn't think Ogianres was dangerous, and you voted for him anyways? Do you think that absolves you of your actions, that you didn't mean it. Or is it because you're a confirmed townie so you feel that you don't have to take responsibility for your actions?

You contributed to the death of a townie as much as I did. Both of us did it unintentionally.

Also, a lesson and corrolarry from NPF Mafia the first: Lynching a mafiate doesn't mean all voters were non-mafiates. Lynching a townie doesn't mean that voters were all non-townies.

*buzzer sound*
Sorry, incorrect. You see, I wasn't the first person to vote for him. Nor did I post a list of convincing reasons that led to the town killing him. I was the LAST person to vote actually, and if I hadn't, it wouldn't have made a difference. And I stated my reason for voting in my lynch vote. I didn't just say "Going along with CmP".

And as to the last point... I WAS THE FIRST TO POINT IT OUT! How dare you throw that back in my face.

Especially when I pointed out that Twiddy could be mafiate.

And no, I don't buy the Catlover explanation at all.

The Wandering God EDIT OVER

[CallmePrismatic]

You see, I wasn't the first person to vote for him. Nor did I post a list of convincing reasons that led to the town killing him.

You're right, I posted a list of convincing reasons against Ogianres. No, wait, something in both of our sentences doesn't seem right...

Oh yeah, CONVINCING REASONS. I didn't wish this stuff out of thin air, he had done it, I brought it into the light, people agreed. His actions belied scum, and since I'm not a mind reader I could only base my opinion of him by what I saw him do.

[secretskull]

First of all I'd like to apologize for more or less starting the band wagoning of Ogianres (If anybody actually noticed it). Something that I find odd is that the votes for Ogianres piled up very quickly, before he (or I for that matter) had a chance to react. Normally the person being lynched has at least one chance to defend himself, Ogianres was denied that, I think we should at least look carefully at the people who voted for him:

CallMePrismatic
Thunder God Cid
B real Shadows
Silly Kitty
H4x.m4g3
The Wizard Who Did It
The Wandering God

Now for a few slight changes:

CallMePrismatic
Thunder God Cid
B real Shadows
Silly Kitty
H4x.m4g3
The Wizard Who Did It
The Wandering God

People who have been suspected in the past are orange, confirmed townies have been crossed out.

[Bailey]

the vig role could only be asked for by a civilian, somebody who did not already have a role.


had somebody with a role asked for it, and then won the roll, I would have asked them if they were willing to trade and then re-rolled.

this would have landed their old role in the lost and found.

Also, the Talkative Civilian MajorBlood has decided to drop.

Originally Posted by Major_Blood

Can you drop me from the game? I've lost my internet connection for a while, and besides that i have Provincial exams to study for. Also, when you post to say i'm gone could you say the reason? Thanks.

[Thundergod Cid]

Originally Posted by secretskull

CallMePrismatic
Thunder God Cid
B real Shadows
Silly Kitty
H4x.m4g3
The Wizard Who Did It
The Wandering God

People who have been suspected in the past are orange, confirmed townies have been crossed out.

B_real was confirmed as townie as well, when he was nightkilled.

[The Wizard Who Did It]

Originally Posted by The_Wandering_God

First.

In which Twiddy votes for Catlover (good thing, however, also the last vote when it was pretty much a given that Catlover would swing. Also, the 5th (me) and 6th (Ogianres) are now both townies. To me, having a mafiate sneak in a vote here only makes them look good if you realize it really doesn't affect anything.) and says a whole lot of hot air.

How very true. It is suspicious.

However, I made my vote as I saw fit. Funny enough I found that my main reason for voting him (he's a veteran, he shouldn't be making these mistakes) wasn't completely true. But it worked out in the end. … Should probably have done my research first…

Second.

In which Twiddy suggests that Mesden is a Mason.

Just trying to help. And I knew that it wouldn't take that much effort to make that post. I'm very, very lazy.

Third.

In which Twiddy votes for Ogianres (a townie I might add) (and FoS's) CmP.

A lot of people other than me did so.

Also, a very interesting point to me, is that these posts all take place around the time that a lynching has taken place. (Comparatively speaking.)

I'm a procrastinator. I wait for the last second to do something. The one time here when I have broken that rule, the second time, was because it took me only 30 seconds to make the post, as previously explained.

Now, I know Twiddy acknowledged he wasn't being very active, but with 2 of his 3 posts containing votes.

I may just be brain dead right now, but what does this prove?

And if any of this seems half assed, it's mainly because I want to hear your responses before I make any more arguments. I'm not going to start jumping out at shadows like Mesden did earlier, as that just caused a lot of controversy.

[h4x.m4g3]

Originally Posted by secretskull

First of all I'd like to apologize for more or less starting the band wagoning of Ogianres (If anybody actually noticed it). Something that I find odd is that the votes for Ogianres piled up very quickly, before he (or I for that matter) had a chance to react. Normally the person being lynched has at least one chance to defend himself, Ogianres was denied that, I think we should at least look carefully at the people who voted for him:

Actually i beleive someone stated earlier that Orgianres had been online (wether or not he checked the thread we do not know) after CMP's post putting suspicion on him, and said nothing in his defense.

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by The Wizard Who Did It

And if any of this seems half assed, it's mainly because I want to hear your responses before I make any more arguments. I'm not going to start jumping out at shadows like Mesden did earlier, as that just caused a lot of controversy.

You say that like it’s a bad thing.

Originally Posted by The_Wandering_God

What do you guys make of this? (Specifically, Mesden)

Eh. Track records aren’t everything. Remember if you will B_Real. His track record had to be the worst of all. He was a townie. (If you want clarification on this, I can try to give it to what I have in immediate knowledge.)

Anyhow, as far as Twid goes, I KNOW he’s a procrastinator. I KNOW he’s lazy. Also, I KNOW that this doesn’t mean BS. Catlover SAID he was just a stupid townie and Twid says he’s just been lazy and slacking on this game. I personally find his record negative and his procrastinating lifestyle a flimsy excuse.

Honestly, I’m worried about Lurkers right now more than anything. My eye be on them, CmP and Twid.

[CallmePrismatic]

Also, the Talkative Civilian MajorBlood has decided to drop.

Great, go ahead and shit on my Eeevil Mason theory.

What does that leave, 13 people? Who's currently lurking?

[Mesden]

1
2
3
4 The_Wandering_God-very active
5 DarthMauler64-lurker
6 Mesden-very active
7
8 h4x.m4g3-fairly active
9 Thundergod_Cid-Fairly active
10 POS_Industries-Little internet access
11
12 CallmePrismatic-Very active
13 FenrisWolf-away
14
15 CrazyBen-lurker
16
17
18
19
20 Silly Kitty-Fairly active
21 The Wizard Who Did It-Recently fairly active
22
23 secretskull-Fairly active
24
25 Big Mac-luker