Superhero Mafia

[Moogle0119]

Originally Posted by Barrel-Hating Sycophant

I did think Ecurt was batman all along but then we had a GM conformation that he was not Batman. Could be Bruce Wayne but he's nto really a super hero. He's seemingly unlynchable though.
The mafia could easily target him if he was some kind of cult leader or SK or something.
Moogle didn't question your pegging of his role so that part of your story fits. Maybe if you can do it again we'll be happy- it will be hard for the mafia to pull off a targeted kill with Dr Strange around.
Either that or some vigs could go after him.

Ahh but I've already said that because of Dr. Strange messing up all the roles at night is the reason he was given the wrong role in the first place. Had Dr. Strange not messed with all the roles during the night we wouldn't even have this problem in the first place with false investigations being given out.

Originally Posted by 42Petunias

We don't need to lynch Wizardcat though. We can have one of the vigs (Wolverine seems to be the only obvious vig, so let's use him) attack Wizardcat. If wizardcat is the real Dr. Strange, he'll use his power, and be safe for the night. If he isn't, then the real dr. strange shouldn't use his power, and wizardcat will die.

I entirely agree with this. What is upsetting though is that apparently Wolverine didn't act on Night 2 so I hope that it's not a relatively inactive player that got his role as Vig otherwise we could be out of luck entirely. Whoever Wolverine is definitely should target Dr. Strange tonight and Wizardcat (assuming you are Dr. Strange) should use your power to turn the kill into a BG protection. Otherwise if you're not Dr. Strange, whoever else IS Dr. Strange should let Wizardcat be lynched anyway for the false roleclaim.

The real question then is who do we lynch today to proceed into night? I do highly suspect there to be two Batmans of some sort. One seems to have jailed Ecurt in the middle of the last day. The other one was sneaking up on me.

Originally Posted by Nikose

In the night, Moogle suddenly realised he was being watched. Despite spinning around, he only caught the breifest glimpse of someone who looked like some 80's batman clone, who then ran off into the night.

This one that acted at night seemed like an 80's Batman clone. The other mention of Batman throwing Ecurt in jail did not have this description. Either there are two different Batmans OR I wasn't able to get a better look at who was sneaking up on me and only received a vague description of someone else.

[MariusTwilight]

Then at any rate, then by tomorrow, we will know if Wizardcat is lying or not.

If he is, then it is possible he is town aligned but being controlled by some source. Perhaps there are other people who can control people?

If he is telling the truth, then he will be able to activate his powers and anyone trying to kill him would protect him. But it someone goes to protect him, and no one tries to kill, then he dies of that night.

There are a few ways of getting to that point. If we all get together and lynch him, and he truns out to be who he is, then all night roles will start to work out normally. This could be bad, as the Mafia and the SK, if there is one, will start acting normally again. But it could be good as now people who are trying to protect end up killing people.

The second way is to go witha different voting path, and wait until the next night. If he dies, then it means he was lying, if he lives, that could mean a number of things. The first being that he is Dr. Strange. What could happen, though, is that the real Dr. Strange, if Wizard is lying, still activates his power. This means that the we would assume Wizard is Dr. Strange, and thus he lives longer, and we could loose a potential townie.

This would be bad as it means that Dr. Strange could be mafia aligned, but there is the chance that Wizard dies and is Mafia aligned. This means that Strange could be a Townie. Right now we only know that Dr. Strange reverses powers, and has used it every night.

The night possibility relies heavily on Dr.Strange actually using the power.

The day possibility relies on wether or not we lynch Wizard or someone else.

[P-Sleazy]

I say we lynch Wizardcat. I don't beleive that he's Dr. Strange because everything he told us about the role, we've already figured out ourselves. Its true. And he did it soon after I figured out how the PO's get messed up results because of Dr. Strange.

[Moogle0119]

If we lynch Wizardcat and he does end up being Dr. Strange we would have lost another town-aligned role (at least I am assuming, Dr. Strange was always a good guy from what I remember). Regardless though, having Dr. Strange alive means that the Mafia can never get anyone killed at night and the same holds true if there is a serial killer. These anti-town roles will never be able to kill off townies. As much as Dr. Strange is messing around with all of our roles I say we find out who he is by asking Wolverine to go after Wizardcat tonight. If Wizardcat is Dr. Strange he can just reverse everything so that he instead is protected.

Hell if we really wanted to (I'm not suggesting we do) we could just vote no lynch over and over and over and rely on Wolverine going after Dr. Strange which would end up having Wolverine protect him instead. Then the Mafia would lose their turn by protecting someone. Then it would be up to Daredevil to actually be killing people and so far he's killed one person and it was Roy.

[P-Sleazy]

The Shadow, according to wikipedia was always a protagonist but ended up being evil in this game. The same could, and probably does, hold true for Dr. Strange, who mind you, ISN'T wizardcat.

[Moogle0119]

Very true. I would assume normally Dr. Strange WOULD be a pro-town role but if The Shadow is Mafia then that does complicate things.

[P-Sleazy]

Thats not an IF statement Moogle. The Shadow WAS Mafia. He was killed, then revealed to us as mafia. So it DOES complicate things for the alignment of Dr. Strange, who again, ISN'T Wizardcat.

[Doppler12]

B_real why are you so insistant the Wizardcat is Dr. Strange when our current plan should prove him to Dr. Strange. So who should we lynch?
And to reiterate my vote
VOTE: B_real

[Moogle0119]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

Thats not an IF statement Moogle. The Shadow WAS Mafia. He was killed, then revealed to us as mafia. So it DOES complicate things for the alignment of Dr. Strange, who again, ISN'T Wizardcat.

I wasn't trying to make it seem like Roy being The Shadow which was Mafia aligned was up for debate. The Shadow = Mafia was clearly indicated.

Doppler, I believe B_real is trying to say IF Dr. Strange is Mafia then having Wolverine go after him at night will only protect a mafiate if this is the case.

[Rygar]

I say we go along with the if Wizardcat's Dr. Strange we have a non-messed up night.

The only thing is we need to get to night.

I say we lynch me Vote: Rygar