Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[Ape Boy]

I rebuke this "Vote for Demetrius" notion.

VOTE: russianreversal

Because of the odd voting situation with ODWTF to start the day and his subsequent responses.

Also, because Newb is a friend of the Apes.

[wasoe]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

And thats my arguement on Demetrius. Stated thrice. In three fairly similar ways.

These three arguments were all based off of a tongue-in-cheek comment made during the decision for the tongue-in-cheek first day lynch. These are arguments that have not convinced me of Dem's guilt. I need more evidence other than he voted for Pink Bunny on the first day when PB was not in the game and that he agreed with Nayno. This was all first-day screwing around, and it's a shame that you're basing your arguments off of this. It's like basing a whole persuasive speech based around an article from the Onion.

[Moogle0119]

Wow....never seen a roleclaim SK before and fairly early in the bandwagoning process too. As others have already pointed out there's no point in lynching Demetrius as long as he's working with the town (which I would assume he would do so) and I'll explain why. We've got 3 mafias out there, and an unknown amount of one-shot killers, vigilantes, and serial killers (this is also assuming they haven't died during the night however). Strategically it's best for the town to leave Demetrius alive since it would be stupid for any of the mafias/killers to not place a hit against him tonight. Why would scum leave alive a confirmed killer who says that they're helping out the town? I don't blame Demetrius for getting upset over stupid votes with no reasoning, that's how the game gets lost usually because people are busy goofing around and not looking at things properly.

With all that said there were quite a few votes placed against Demetrius for no real reason prior to his roleclaim. Admittedly I would have had to go through the entire thread again to find them all but it seems Pink Bunny already pointed them out. I find that deathpigeon's vote was probably the worst in my eyes. At least STATE what idea you liked so much or why you're placing the vote (even if it is a reason already stated at least you're showing where you stand on the issue and why). You're a new player to mafia, but unfortunately for you it doesn't give you an immunity pass to place your votes so carelessly which seems like you're just trying to hop on a bandwagon for no real reason other than to get a quick lynch. And everyone knows scum loves to do that if they think they can get away with it.

Vote: deathpigeon

[Pink Bunny]

Personally Moogle, if we could do two lynches within a day I'd want both of them lynched. However, of the two I feel RR is more dangerous. He already placed a big, real vote on ODWTF and was entirely willing to blindly relocate it on a bandwagon that had no real presentable reason for both starting, as well as lack of reasoning behind relocating that vote.

It was totally non-committal and seemed like a great way to go "Oh, well, it wasn't my idea."

Pigeon's apathy isn't nearly as scary as what RR tried to pull when I think about it.

[Demetrius]

Aerozord, do you read all of the posts? I said the reason I was not as active was due to the fact that I was not posting while drinking...

[Axl]

Well I'd like VOTE: RUSSIANREVERSAL.

Why? Because I didn't vote last time and it made me sad inside.

[P-Sleazy]

Originally Posted by wasoe

These three arguments were all based off of a tongue-in-cheek comment made during the decision for the tongue-in-cheek first day lynch. These are arguments that have not convinced me of Dem's guilt. I need more evidence other than he voted for Pink Bunny on the first day when PB was not in the game and that he agreed with Nayno. This was all first-day screwing around, and it's a shame that you're basing your arguments off of this. It's like basing a whole persuasive speech based around an article from the Onion.

...Did you read the part where he roleclaimed SK? Cause that seems like a good reason to vote him now.

Anyways, since all the big wigs are making a big deal about leaving demetrius alone now, I think I should make a point here.

Leaving Demetrius alive is like making a deal with the devil. You have no idea what you're getting into, and the only thing you can reasonably expect to happen is that he won't die tonight since there's probably a mafia BG who'll protect him. Why? Because keeping an extra killer around helps them whittle down our numbers too. Especially one who's around to send in his kill. EDIT: Especially since he doesn't know 100% who's in the mafias.

So in the interest of slowing the death rate my vote stays until further notice.

[Demetrius]

That and you know where my kill is going out of sheer spite tonight...

[Bailey]

I think I've just figured out one of the clues I got last night. I might be totally wrong, but I'm pretty sure that it was B_Real and Russian who were arguing, which suggests to me that they're working together in some capacity, probably a violent one, since they were arguing angrily, rather than discussing things calmly in a pub.

[P-Sleazy]

How the hell does that point to me? Cause I haven't had any disputes with Russian at all this game. And if it was an arguement that could have been overheard, I highly doubt that it would have been about killing someone since no one would argue something like that out loud.

Plus, it wasn't me cause I didn't do anything last night.