Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[Zilla]

I say we lynch Demetrius to check out his roleclaim.

He says he hasn't lied all game but what basis is that for validation? That in itself could be a lie.

If we leave him to a nightkill, we won't know if he really was the serial killer, and if he is in actuality scum, that gives me quite a few ideas on who ELSE is scum.

[Bailey]

Originally Posted by Zilla

if he is in actuality scum, that gives me quite a few ideas on who ELSE is scum.

...

He says he's a serial killer. Serial killers WORK ALONE. That won't give you any hints.

And B_Real, as I said, I may be misinterpreting, but I'm just going off of what I've got, and last night two people waving guns around were arguing near the scene of Nikose's death, and one of them was cloaked in shadows while the other was wearing a big poofy tall hat on his head upside-down.

Now, if you've got any suggestions for what that might mean other than you and Russian being mafiates together, I'd love to hear them.

[P-Sleazy]

Originally Posted by Zilla

If we leave him to a nightkill, we won't know if he really was the serial killer, and if he is in actuality scum, that gives me quite a few ideas on who ELSE is scum.

Yea, we'll know he's the serial killer when you find me dead at night...or possibly narrowly escaping death cause of an intervention.

[Demetrius]

I actually honestly don't remember who I targeted... I don't think I got them though, which makes me wonder if Fenris was mean enough to make me a broken role, which would blow.

[P-Sleazy]

You targetted Pink Bunny on night one. YOu haven't said anything about night 2 yet.

EDIT: Also newb, I'm not ignoring your point about the shadows and hat, I'm just trying to figure it out right now too. Tophat came to mind about the hat but he's dead and russian reversal does make sense for why the poofy hat was upside down. As for the shadows, I'm thinking Masked Jedi because the shadows did mask his identity didn't they?

EDIT x2: Then I found this

Originally Posted by Fenris

Tophat is dead. He was crammed into a hat.

I beleive you witnessed an attack newb, and not an arguement. Which may explain why the hat was upside down.

[Demetrius]

Yeah, the reason I haven't said anything was because I can't remember who it was and I've had to empty my sent messages due to a full inbox.

[Giever]

Although all of the random Demetrius votes are kind of brain-hurty, I'm still going to have to

Vote: Demetrius

(for now, anyway) because of

Originally Posted by Zilla

I say we lynch Demetrius to check out his roleclaim.

He says he hasn't lied all game but what basis is that for validation? That in itself could be a lie.

If we leave him to a nightkill, we won't know if he really was the serial killer, and if he is in actuality scum, that gives me quite a few ideas on who ELSE is scum.

this.

[Ryanderman]

I don't like the argument that leaving the SK alive for a time will help the town. In my opinion it's in the SK's best interests to leave the killing roles alive as long as possible, to ensure that people die as quickly as possible. So if Dem really is the SK then,

Vote: Demetrius

[Roy_D_Mylote]

Tomorrow we should lynch Giever.

[Pink Bunny]

Lynching Demetrius to check his roleclaim is just so backwards. Okay, we found out that Demetrius is telling the truth. Congratulations! We're helping Cult get a head start by having less kills going on, thus allowing them to grow larger.

Saying you're an SK serves no purpose but to ensure that you will die. This is a unique game with unique circumstances. We rarely ever had to worry about two cults and three mafias. You really want to verify it so bad? Get a PO to get to work. Going "Oh, well, Demetrius is dead and he was telling the truth. Oops!" Isn't going to help us any right now.