Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[Pink Bunny]

You tried to string me up on false information. Of course I'm not going to let it go. "Oh, you happened to be wrong about me? Thats OK."

You claimed I had an identical role to B_Real, which in itself is suspicious. B_Real could always vote and got snuffed at night, and I can't vote and I lived a night. Now you move onward to a misdirection theory. Personally, if I were in a faction that had any form of communication, I would have killed you for claiming to have any PO ability. And I knew I would have been safe for doing so. Why? Because I pressed people so hard to kill Cult leaders that there's no way people were going to think about you.

And if I were Cult, I would have culted you if I had a bodyguard available. Just pointing that out.

If people are still hell bent on lynching me or are going to keep bothering me about this, even though its so blatantly obvious I'm anti-scum, fine, do so. You're ruining a lynch for Town. Though I'm sure the most persuasive people pushing this won't regret that.

[DarthMauler64]

Sorry, I haven't been posting. I'll try to post more.

I just reread what I missed, and I guess for now I'll

FoS: RussianReversal

I'm not convinced enough for a vote yet. Also, for now I am going to trust Pink Bunny.

[P-Sleazy]

The gun B_Real I (EDIT: The First) had. He had no killing-esque role (Edit: according to October). Why did he have it?

The Pub, the Shed, and apperently outdoors. two of those times you said the story you seemed rather sure of yourself as to the location (and I'm talking about him being sure of the Pub, not the Shed. You can look back yourselves.) (EDIT: Disregard this for now, I've seen where I misread the Pub)

I'll post all three again.

Originally Posted by Newb

I camped out one street over from where I did last time... and apparently I found Nikose's stuff. He was the Police Officer. Unfortunately, his notes were no help at all, as the bastard was investigating ME! Can you believe the nerve of that guy? I guess he wasn't really interested in Ole Dude at all.

Serves him right that the only investigation he managed to get off was a dirty hobo.

Oh, also, there were two people having an argument in a shed, I think. I'm not entirely sure.

This is where you were unsure.

Originally Posted by Newb

I think I've just figured out one of the clues I got last night. I might be totally wrong, but I'm pretty sure that it was B_Real and Russian who were arguing, which suggests to me that they're working together in some capacity, probably a violent one, since they were arguing angrily, rather than discussing things calmly in a pub.

You seemed pretty certain there, but you did include that one phrase prior to it, I underlined it instead of bold.

Originally Posted by Newb

And B_Real, as I said, I may be misinterpreting, but I'm just going off of what I've got, and last night two people waving guns around were arguing near the scene of Nikose's death, and one of them was cloaked in shadows while the other was wearing a big poofy tall hat on his head upside-down.

Now, if you've got any suggestions for what that might mean other than you and Russian being mafiates together, I'd love to hear them.

Misinterpretations mean nothing when you're posting your word of the information you got. The information should have been unaltered and you should have been atleast sure that the information you're giving us is the correct information. And as this is the information you gave us, it mentions nothing of a building so where did the shed and pub come in for the first two stories? (EDIT: This part still holds together though.)

And finally, why is it that you knew that it was Ole Dude WTF on Night 1 when you were in the same location as him, but when you're in the same location as 2 other people the next night you suddenly don't know thier identities, but have a vague description instead? And this also extends to this just now occuring night.

EDIT: Nvm, I misread the part about the pub, so PART of the locations part of your story holds. Bolded part that I misread so others won't misread. The other arguements still hold though, including why there was a shed (building) mentioned earlier but not later.

[OctoberRaven]

Well, we got nothing better to go on.

Not going to vote until I see RR's defense, though.

[Brock Samson]

What kind of soup are you?

EDIT:

Holy cow, you guys go fast...

Pink Bunny, you are impervious to night kills and cannot vote, therefor it should be safe for you to reveal your role. There must be some serious counter balance to not being able to vote, and I can't see any reason not to share. Doing so will lay any controversy about you to rest.

[OctoberRaven]

Okay. Pink, for the last time.

I DID NOT CLAIM YOU WERE A PO. I NEVER DID. STOP TRYING TO PUT THAT SPIN ON WHAT I'VE BEEN SAYING.

I let you off the hook, but if you keep putting words in my mouth, I'm putting you back on it.

[Aerozord]

well Newb and RR both show suspicious behavior. For all we know they are both scum. Since one of the main people that pushed for RR was Newb I say we take the risk and vote for RR. If it turns out RR is scum that would give some validity to Newbs role claim. If not, then its proof he is scum and should be next on the chopping block.

Not fool proof, but I think its a good idea

[Bailey]

Okay, the locations thing has been cleared up SO many times it isn't even funny. Go reread my posts for today, and read the posts towards the end of yesterday.

And, if you can't find those posts, the shed was near where Nikose died. There was no pub. The pub was an example.

I haven't been posting exactly what I got because, well, we're not supposed to copy-paste PMs in mafia games.

And this past night the people shooting each other were a giant feathery thing with a scythe and somebody who matched the description of this guy pretty well.

Are you really going to claim that just because it's easier for a GM to give hints for some people than for other people I'm making all of this up?

[P-Sleazy]

Yes. Because Rygar doesn't have a game named after him.

EDIT: ok, so the game DOES exist. More to come!

DOUBLE EDIT: OK then, why not post us a map of the town then? Surely you'd be allowed to post a map cause that seems like something that'd be important for all the players. Further more, why don't we, as players, have addresses (atleast I don't and I'm not a homeless guy like you)? That seems like something reasonable for the GM to have done if there really is a map of the town. Finally, why do you not privide details of these shooters until AFTER you've found a convenient spot to mention it?

[Bailey]

...

He doesn't?