John Dies at the End Mafia

[Fenris]

?

[P-Sleazy]

Originally Posted by Demonlink2

I have just presented a summary of today. I now reveal my plans, barring something ABSOLUTELY CRAZY.

Voting Demetrius gets us the most information. Multiple pieces of information rest on Who Dem is, namely, if Ecurt has an ounce of trust, and whether BHS/Smarty McBarrelpants is claiming the truth or just a mafiate covering for another by throwing out a random claim.g

If Dem is Mafia, BHS/S McBarrel is CRIMINAL SCUM.
If Dem is standard Vanilla Townie, Ecurt and the ring of gossips cannot be trusted.
If Dem is something entirely different, For instance Cult or one of the crazy roles from the front page, we cannot trust either BHS or Ecurt.

As such, I keep my vote on Demetrius. If I have gotten anything wrong in my summary, please correct me, as I am only human and miss things sometimes.

Problem I see with this is that it still risks us losing a townie, which, we could use every one we can get, regardless of how much it helps us. But we know the Gossiper's aren't town-aligned, we already have 2 of them outed (and a possibility for a third one), so I'm thinking if we Lynch them, I can get back to you guys on Day 4 as to whether or not we should trust Smarty, gossipers, or neither of them.

[Truce]

Originally Posted by FenrisWolf

?

I just want to find out if my role is broken or not.

I mean, I believe BHS really is an investigator and all, but I also saw Demetrius kill Tophat the first night with a group of people.

So, it'd kinda help figure out if you were doing something to him. Since he didn't die, and since the bodyguard should have been protecting B_real, there's only so many other roles that you could be.

[The Argent Lord]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

Actually, 2 of them. We know Ecurt's and Moogle's. We still don't know Demetrius'. And I'm thinking if we kill Demetrius, we'll find out which of the two groups (Gossipers or Smarty) is telling the truth about him, let alone whether the Gossiper's get correct information when investigating or not. Then we'll also get confirmation on Smarty's role aswell.

Yay for being unclear! I meant the Gossipers and you. Obviously Dem is still an unknown.

Of course, I could just investigate one of them (Smarty or Dem) and let you all know how it goes from there while we kill one of the Gossipers today. Which seems to be the safest option available at the moment.

Works for me.
Unvote
Vote: Ecurt

[Fenris]

I wasn't doing anything to Rygar last night. What does your role say I was doing to Rygar last night?

[Truce]

Visit his house with a briefcase in hand.

[Fenris]

Could be an impersonator role? I don't have a night role.

[Demonlink2]

That makes some sense, I guess. As long as we have a PO confident he won't be offed, we can focus on the non-town.

Unvote: Demetrius
Vote: Ecurt

Though this new Fenris/Rygar conversation intrigues me. Continue.

[P-Sleazy]

Its making it VERY difficult to decide who to investigate tonight. Do I go the Smarty/Demetrius Route, or the Fenris/Rygar route? Hmm...the list just keeps building!

Tell you guys what, since we have supposedly two investigators, I'll investigate Demetrius, thus confirming Smarty, and Smarty can investigate Fenris, thus giving us insight on him and Rygar's activities.

This way, we can figure out up to 4 people in one night. :p

[Griever]

Situation's got a lot more complicated I see. Some of you make good points so I'm just going to

Unvote: Demetrius
Vote:Ecurt

A guaranteed anti town lynch is certainly a good thing and with B_real investigating we'll find out about the rest tomorrow anyways.