NPF Mafia: 8-Bit Edition SP - Page 31

IHateMakingNames · 01-30-2006, 10:44 PM

Well, clearly the random thing wouldn't work every time. But it probably has a better chance of success than trying to decipher people's posts and persuading everyone else that X is in the mafia.

Well, I'm the current scape-goat, so I guess that's the end of me. At least I got to get rid of the serial killer before being lynched. Role claim, vigilante. I guess I should have stuck with the "don't post often and simply vote for the person everyone is against" strategy.

Of course, now that I may or may not be the vigilante, you might want to lynch me anyway. What with my "kill random people" strategy, which most people seem to be against, and the fact that the cult leader can now recruit me, or the mafia can kill me (Though, I might just help them).

Deathosaurus Wrecks · 01-30-2006, 11:01 PM

I thought i said no crazy-going while i was out?

Unvote: Fenriswolf; Vote: IHateMakingNames

not that i'm not suspicious of FW, but i'm voting for IHMN for the exact same reason that i voted for Jer: that sort of attitude is too dangerous to have in this game.

a strategic roleclaim indeed, but i dont belive it. and if he is the Vig, i don't want him running around killing whomever he feels like. thats not a vigilante, thats a serial killer.

MasterOfMagic · 01-30-2006, 11:34 PM

Vote: IHateMakingNames

Random killing isn't all that good an idea in my book. Especcially if he's the vig. Two random deaths instead of just one. Guess this explains why the vig killed every night...

EDIT: Then agian...do we really want to waste a lynch on someone who we know isn't in the mafia? And he did get the SK...I might change later on.

Mondt · 01-30-2006, 11:40 PM

I'm pretty sure role-claiming isn't for sure completely positive truth. Also, don and sk and everything are luck I'm guessing. The smaller the numbers in enemies get, the greater chance for him to kill us.

MasterOfMagic · 01-30-2006, 11:42 PM

Well, I know its not proof positive, but his philosophy certainly matches up, doesn't it?

The SSB Intern · 01-31-2006, 12:45 AM

You know, killing the Sk wasn't all that great. All he killed was the mafia don and Secretskull (who doesn't do much anyway). I don't see how you could really use that fact to defend yourself.

Mesden · 01-31-2006, 02:31 AM

The way the vig killed someone on night one with no evidence seems to match IHMN's style. I asked for the vig to not kill anyone on night one as chancese were he would hit a townie. He did it anyway and low and behold he hit a townie. To me he actually is acting in sync with his night role. He's more like an SK, but he won't kill anyone he is sure is township. I think that if he is the vig we are screwed as our only source of mafia killing is gone. This roleclaim of his just seems to fit him so I don't want to vote for him. Serial killing vig or not. He has basically done the same thing as jer and I just don't want a quick repeat in history. Especially if he has any special townie role.

Deathosaurus Wrecks · 01-31-2006, 02:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mestizio

The way the vig killed someone on night one with no evidence seems to match IHMN's style. I asked for the vig to not kill anyone on night one as chancese were he would hit a townie. He did it anyway and low and behold he hit a townie. To me he actually is acting in sync with his night role. He's more like an SK, but he won't kill anyone he is sure is township. I think that if he is the vig we are screwed as our only source of mafia killing is gone. This roleclaim of his just seems to fit him so I don't want to vote for him. Serial killing vig or not. He has basically done the same thing as jer and I just don't want a quick repeat in history. Especially if he has any special townie role.

ok, lets assume for a moment that IHMN is indeed the Vig. this is very, very bad. the Vig is now on par with the SK (espeicaly when you take into consideration the fact that both of them have done as much to help the town as hurt it), and not the blessed hand of vengance as he should be. furthermore: as he has now roleclaimed, who do you think the cult is going to recruit tonight? assuming the mafia doesn't get him first?

Mesden · 01-31-2006, 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Deathosaurus Wrecks

ok, lets assume for a moment that IHMN is indeed the Vig. this is very, very bad. the Vig is now on par with the SK (espeicaly when you take into consideration the fact that both of them have done as much to help the town as hurt it), and not the blessed hand of vengance as he should be. furthermore: as he has now roleclaimed, who do you think the cult is going to recruit tonight? assuming the mafia doesn't get him first?

The way it seems to me, the cult won't get a chance to recruit him if he is the vig because his imminent death. He is playing the way he thinks is best. If you killed me for deciphering people actions then it would make no sense to me, but that's because we do similar things. His way is completely different and it seems most effective to him, so why kill him for that reason? If all of you were like him and I stayed thhe same you would do what you are doing to him right now to me. I am not agreeing with his actions, but I think it's far off to kill him for it. He would be a good SK though. He's not on par with the SK though. I'm sure, no matter how much he wants to kill someone, he won't go off and kill someone who he is sure is township. If you noticed, the vig kills were against people who didn't have much activity. That I agree with. He hasn't killed someone who has contributed yet, has he? That is his positive points. He also seems to agreeing with his death the same way SillyKitty was with her near lynching and she was a townie. This could all be one ploy, but I doubt it. As I stated in jer's case, one less townie is a bad thing. Even if he might kill a townie again he is probably going to kill someone with little to no contribution like he did last time. I agree with this. And if his kills against less active members all seem to be townies then we know contributers are mostly mafiate. If you prove all that I have stated wrong then we will see my vote change.

Deathosaurus Wrecks · 01-31-2006, 01:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mestizio

As I stated in jer's case, one less townie is a bad thing. Even if he might kill a townie again he is probably going to kill someone with little to no contribution like he did last time. I agree with this. And if his kills against less active members all seem to be townies then we know contributers are mostly mafiate. If you prove all that I have stated wrong then we will see my vote change.

you contradict yourself Mestizio. you say one less townie is bad, then you go on to say one less townie is okay when they're not posting very much. again, assuming he's the Vig, he will kill again, and theres a good chance that his next target will be a townie. so if you want to stick to your claim of wanting to save as many townies as possible, why arn't you voting for IHMN?

01-30-2006, 10:44 PM	#301
IHateMakingNames Awwwwh Join Date: Dec 2003 Posts: 12,119	Well, clearly the random thing wouldn't work every time. But it probably has a better chance of success than trying to decipher people's posts and persuading everyone else that X is in the mafia. Well, I'm the current scape-goat, so I guess that's the end of me. At least I got to get rid of the serial killer before being lynched. Role claim, vigilante. I guess I should have stuck with the "don't post often and simply vote for the person everyone is against" strategy. Of course, now that I may or may not be the vigilante, you might want to lynch me anyway. What with my "kill random people" strategy, which most people seem to be against, and the fact that the cult leader can now recruit me, or the mafia can kill me (Though, I might just help them). __________________ "If I'm reincarnated, I want to be Musashi again!" - Musashi, Brave Fencer Musashi Last edited by IHateMakingNames; 01-30-2006 at 10:53 PM.

01-30-2006, 11:01 PM	#302
Deathosaurus Wrecks Underachiever Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Chicago Posts: 1,996	I thought i said no crazy-going while i was out? Unvote: Fenriswolf; Vote: IHateMakingNames not that i'm not suspicious of FW, but i'm voting for IHMN for the exact same reason that i voted for Jer: that sort of attitude is too dangerous to have in this game. a strategic roleclaim indeed, but i dont belive it. and if he is the Vig, i don't want him running around killing whomever he feels like. thats not a vigilante, thats a serial killer. __________________ "There was another, who came before you he was a hero and your brother and my son he fought the darkenss, the darkness won" -The Protomen "Unrest in the House of Light"

01-30-2006, 11:34 PM	#303
MasterOfMagic ahahah Join Date: Mar 2004 Posts: 3,456	Vote: IHateMakingNames Random killing isn't all that good an idea in my book. Especcially if he's the vig. Two random deaths instead of just one. Guess this explains why the vig killed every night... EDIT: Then agian...do we really want to waste a lynch on someone who we know isn't in the mafia? And he did get the SK...I might change later on. Last edited by MasterOfMagic; 01-30-2006 at 11:39 PM.

01-31-2006, 12:45 AM	#306
The SSB Intern We'll have to do this the hard way. Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Behind it all. Posts: 1,009	You know, killing the Sk wasn't all that great. All he killed was the mafia don and Secretskull (who doesn't do much anyway). I don't see how you could really use that fact to defend yourself. __________________ You know who never sleeps? My gun.

01-31-2006, 02:31 AM	#307
Mesden There is no Toph, only Melon Lord! Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Inside of a box inside of a smaller box Posts: 4,310	The way the vig killed someone on night one with no evidence seems to match IHMN's style. I asked for the vig to not kill anyone on night one as chancese were he would hit a townie. He did it anyway and low and behold he hit a townie. To me he actually is acting in sync with his night role. He's more like an SK, but he won't kill anyone he is sure is township. I think that if he is the vig we are screwed as our only source of mafia killing is gone. This roleclaim of his just seems to fit him so I don't want to vote for him. Serial killing vig or not. He has basically done the same thing as jer and I just don't want a quick repeat in history. Especially if he has any special townie role. __________________ I can tell you're lying.

01-30-2006, 11:42 PM	#305
MasterOfMagic ahahah Join Date: Mar 2004 Posts: 3,456	Well, I know its not proof positive, but his philosophy certainly matches up, doesn't it?