NPF Mafia: 8-Bit Edition SP - Page 54

Incendius · 02-24-2006, 02:14 PM

How Do We Positively Know That The Vigilante Is IHMN? The Answer Is We Don't It's Only Suspected, And He Could Be Lying

Bailey · 02-24-2006, 02:26 PM

I know I said I wouldn't be posting here anymore, but that is such a flawed argument that I feel compelled to post anyway.

The entire reason that people are trying to kill IHMN is because they think he's the vig. Pointing out that he might not be the vig only adds more reason to leave him well enough alone.

If he isn't the vig, why are we voting for him?

Incendius · 02-24-2006, 02:31 PM

Because if he's not the vig, he's the mafia.

Bailey · 02-24-2006, 02:34 PM

Whatever, I really am going to stop posting now.

If that's the way that you people think logic works, then frankly we deserve to lose.

CMP, is it an option to leave the town and become a hermit?

MasterOfMagic · 02-24-2006, 03:46 PM

What the hell? Why is he (addressing everyone else, since someone who doesn't post can't respond..) not going to post anymore? An arguement?

Silly, as that's the whole point of this game. Arguing. EDIT: If you're getting heated enough to want to quit, you need to start remembering that its a game. FUN. Not angry. FUN. Even if we lose.

Mondt · 02-24-2006, 05:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Incendius

That is the worst case scenerio, but with IHMN DECIDING RANDOMLY, it is much more prone to to happen then if he looked at it rationally.

I don't think you realize how random random actually is. There are odds and likelyhoods, but no facts. Like I said, we are pretty much like him. He just bases his kill, if he is a vig, more on luck than we do.

Quote:

Because if he's not the vig, he's the mafia.

Or not. Possibly a townie looking to stir things up and make them move faster. Or a townie thinking that his innocence is more assured in the roleclaim of a vig instead of a normal townie. Probably one or two more I can't think of. But if he is mafia, it would just be a huge risk to take to try to prove your innocence, especially after saying, "Let's kill randomly! All the cool kids are doing it!"

I'm not trying to specifically defend IHMN here, I just think that our suspicions lie in wrong places. If he was mafia, then the mafia would be hating him right now. That just might make things really bad on the threa, more likely in PMs, but possibly in the thread. If he is just another SK, then hey! 1/3 of a chance to hit mafia really isn't all that bad, considering.

GARUD · 02-24-2006, 10:07 PM

All I know is, IHMN should be killed. Now, the way you guys have spoken it, proves that IHMN is a mafia. He may be cultist aligned at the same time too. I'm urging you to get rid of him now, cause no matter what he is, he's a menace. Also, at this stage of the game, we need to be sure about who we kill.

neyo the king · 02-24-2006, 10:16 PM

Man, seems alot can happen when your gone for about 2 days.

So, anyway, looking at the facts, I have drawn the conclusion of keeping IHMN my vote. Incendius has brought up points, I tried to, but he did it in a not-so-subtle way. I admire that. He also brought up the current day-by-day situation, and I think it makes perfect sense.

So, in a nutshell, read Incendius' posts, and learn.

And also know that if IHMN is actually the vig, I'm basiclly screwed, accourding to Newb.

Good night folks.

Trepie · 02-25-2006, 09:32 AM

Oh fine, you win:

I will vote to lynch you next round, newb.

Reasons:
1) You posted about how much you rawk'd for electing to sacrifice yourself. Any real townie in your position would just say that you elect to sacrifice yourself and let them decide how much you rock.

2) I can tell you for free that your mafia list is wrong. :p I'm thinking you know Neyo is Mafia and you're trying to get people to kill him. Once he is revealed to be maifa we'll all be like "newb you rock, we will follow you blindly now". And then they lynch all those non-mafia you just selected to be on that list, giving you mafia at least a one for one trade off.

However another interesting take on this could be that your mafia list is not completely inaccurate. You could have put another mafia member on it so that we lynch 2 mafia. You are still left with 2 and we will be completely at your command. you being so l33t at finding out mafias. We lose We lose 4 townies to 2 mafia and even then there is a possibiliy that once we hit a townie under your orders we'll still follow your list. Everyone makes a few mistakes, right? Once we are 6 townies down people might begin to realise but by then it is too late. We are pwnt.

3) You've been obsessed with Masons all game. I'm thinking you are afraid of them and you're trying to get one to reveal themself so you can take them out. I don't know how many masons there are but I always thought only 2. If 1 dies then the other becomes much like any other townie.

CallmePrismatic · 02-25-2006, 11:07 AM

Vote Update:

IHateMakingNames (5)
Neyo the King
GARUD
Deathosaurus Wrecks
Incendius
Trepie

Neyo the King (3)
MasterofMagic
Inbred Chocobo
IHateMakingNames

sk3l3t0n (1)
Baalirock

Newb (1)
Newb

8 to Lynch, No Deadline Set Yet

@Newb: If you want to quit the game, PM me, there are people waiting in the reserve list. Otherwise, since there is no Canada in this game, you do not have the running away option.

02-24-2006, 02:14 PM	#531
Incendius Magikoopa Join Date: Jan 2005 Posts: 1,937	How Do We Positively Know That The Vigilante Is IHMN? The Answer Is We Don't It's Only Suspected, And He Could Be Lying __________________ If you know the enemy and know yourself, your victory will not stand in doubt; if you know Heaven and know Earth, you may make your victory complete. - Sun Tzu The art of war

02-24-2006, 02:31 PM	#533
Incendius Magikoopa Join Date: Jan 2005 Posts: 1,937	Because if he's not the vig, he's the mafia. __________________ If you know the enemy and know yourself, your victory will not stand in doubt; if you know Heaven and know Earth, you may make your victory complete. - Sun Tzu The art of war

02-24-2006, 10:07 PM	#537
GARUD Demon Slayer and Ass Kicker Join Date: May 2005 Location: Hell... and demons are my bitches Posts: 1,460	All I know is, IHMN should be killed. Now, the way you guys have spoken it, proves that IHMN is a mafia. He may be cultist aligned at the same time too. I'm urging you to get rid of him now, cause no matter what he is, he's a menace. Also, at this stage of the game, we need to be sure about who we kill. __________________ Just a post made by your neighborhood ~~friendly DEMON SLAYER~~ jerk PSYCHO KILLER! ~Awesome Avatar by Mauve.

02-24-2006, 10:16 PM	#538
neyo the king Dr. Ivo Robotnik Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Mobius Posts: 674	Man, seems alot can happen when your gone for about 2 days. So, anyway, looking at the facts, I have drawn the conclusion of keeping IHMN my vote. Incendius has brought up points, I tried to, but he did it in a not-so-subtle way. I admire that. He also brought up the current day-by-day situation, and I think it makes perfect sense. So, in a nutshell, read Incendius' posts, and learn. And also know that if IHMN is actually the vig, I'm basiclly screwed, accourding to Newb. Good night folks. __________________ I am Doctor Ivo Robotnik, the greatest scientific genius in the universe! ~"Where There's Smoke, They Pinch Back."~

02-25-2006, 09:32 AM	#539
Trepie Yay for the Fan Art thread! Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: In a field of purple flowers Posts: 123	Oh fine, you win: I will vote to lynch you next round, newb. Reasons: 1) You posted about how much you rawk'd for electing to sacrifice yourself. Any real townie in your position would just say that you elect to sacrifice yourself and let them decide how much you rock. 2) I can tell you for free that your mafia list is wrong. :p I'm thinking you know Neyo is Mafia and you're trying to get people to kill him. Once he is revealed to be maifa we'll all be like "newb you rock, we will follow you blindly now". And then they lynch all those non-mafia you just selected to be on that list, giving you mafia at least a one for one trade off. However another interesting take on this could be that your mafia list is not completely inaccurate. You could have put another mafia member on it so that we lynch 2 mafia. You are still left with 2 and we will be completely at your command. you being so l33t at finding out mafias. We lose We lose 4 townies to 2 mafia and even then there is a possibiliy that once we hit a townie under your orders we'll still follow your list. Everyone makes a few mistakes, right? Once we are 6 townies down people might begin to realise but by then it is too late. We are pwnt. 3) You've been obsessed with Masons all game. I'm thinking you are afraid of them and you're trying to get one to reveal themself so you can take them out. I don't know how many masons there are but I always thought only 2. If 1 dies then the other becomes much like any other townie. __________________ The greatest line in 8-bit history: :thief: No I wasn't, besides, what kind of ninja wears bright red? I came back because of Celebren's artwork.

02-24-2006, 03:46 PM	#535
MasterOfMagic ahahah Join Date: Mar 2004 Posts: 3,456	What the hell? Why is he (addressing everyone else, since someone who doesn't post can't respond..) not going to post anymore? An arguement? Silly, as that's the whole point of this game. Arguing. EDIT: If you're getting heated enough to want to quit, you need to start remembering that its a game. FUN. Not angry. FUN. Even if we lose.