NPF Mafia: Berserk Edition

[Major Blood]

Well, i guess lynching IHMN can't work against our favor. If he is a townie, then we will be able to get rid of a thread next day(or the vig will take care of CmP). And since i've never had a reason to not trust CmP...

Vote: IHMN

[CallmePrismatic]

I've decided to not automatically point out the townies. It took me a second to realize that if I kept revealing confirmed townies, the Mafia would basically be given a list of people to kill each Night since they would have no chance of organizing a bandwagon lynch.

My new policy concerning investigated townies is to remain silent, and only reveal a townies identity if he or she is dangerously close to being wrongfully lynched. So each new Day, if I don't automatically vote someone, presume I found a townie.

[MasterOfMagic]

Originally Posted by Thundergod Cid

Am I the only one who finds it extremely suspicious that IHMN is complaining about the bodyguard being overpowered?

Probably not, but maybe you should be...

Wanting the game to be balanced isn't really that scummy a thing. And really, if someone role claimed PO and pointed at you, wouldn't you argue the same way? Maybe not, but its at least understandable.

Not that I'm saying IHMN's is innocent. Lord, CMP's voting for him is all we really need, isn't it?

[Inbred Chocobo]

The problem is is that how is CmP going to decide who to investigate. He can just go random like he is doing, or we can start lynching people, which would bring out how people would defend themselves, and bring suspects into the light. If we don't, then in the end, CmP has as much chance as finding the last mafia as the mafia has of hitting the BG.

Though the problem with just waiting for CmP is that if we wait on him, what the hell is the vig going to do? He can wait, just like us, but he will more than likely start hitting other people too. He could hit the mafia, but he could also hit the BG, or cult, or just a townie.

And then throw in the fact that the SK can hit the BG possibly, the BG has a decent chance to die.

Hell even if we do start lynching, we also have a slim chance of hitting the BG.

[mrchaos]

Well, this course of action beats randomly voting. Besides, IHMN hasn't put up anything that resembles a defense, so I guess we can trust CMP.

Vote: IHMN

[Incendius]

Votes!

IHMN
1. CallmePrismatic
2. B_Real_Shadows
3. Darthmauler64
4. MasterofMagic
5. Ogianres
6. Crotchknocker
7. Thundergod Cid
8. Inbred Chocobo
9. Major_Blood
10. mrchaos

*15 to lynch, no deadline yet!*

[Mesden]

Wow, I do agree with the BG's new found power. A bodyguard by normal means in real life protects you from harm. Not switching sides.

But it is Cindy's game and we are none to argue it.

Vote:IHateMakingNames

[Sithdarth]

Well hell I guess there just isn't anything else to do in this situation then to Vote: IHMN

Personally I feel with all the potential ways to lose the body guard at random and the, essentially, random way CmP has to go about investigating keeps the game fairly balanced.

[Major Blood]

Originally Posted by mrchaos

Well, this course of action beats randomly voting. Besides, IHMN hasn't put up anything that resembles a defense, so I guess we can trust CMP.

Vote: IHMN

To be fair, we haven't really given him a chance to defend himself yet. Also, what has he got to defend himself with? CmP's word that he's the PO and investigated him? How is he supposed to defend himself against that? CmP's word is too trusted. I'm not saying don't trust CmP or unvote IHMN its just that if you are going to vote for someone, don't do it for a reason like "He hasn't put up a good defense" without looking at the circumstances.

[Incendius]

Alright we can have a vote if everyone wants, if over half the people want the bodyguard to not hvae the power, he won't, I am not responsible for any implications from said vote if we decide to do it.