Mafia: Basic - Page 14

DarthMauler64 · 05-31-2006, 11:03 PM

From what I remember about Newb's first post about the inactive roles was that he mentioned there were two roles that hadn't sent anything in. One was the Neyo the Vig because Neyo forgot he signed up or something. My opinion is the Mafia Don was the other, but I am not sure.

Also, Newb, can you highlight the players the appropriate colors on the players list on the front page?

secretskull · 06-01-2006, 10:32 AM

Explain why you think it's the Mafia Don. It could have easily been any other role.
CP the mafia has no reason to waste a kill on a known townie. Sure, they can't convince the town to lynch him, but they can just convince the town to lynch someone else. The Mafia's nights are better spent on narrowing down suspects for the town aligned roles. As are the nights of the SK (and the Reporter for that matter).
Anyway right now we should be concentrating on putting pressure on those people who haven't posted much, but have been on. That way a Mafia member can't hide there.

DarthMauler64 · 06-01-2006, 10:57 AM

My reason is Grthwllms hasn't played this game before. If I were the mafia I would have killed someone with some experience or that I knew that their death would stir up trouble. Then again the mafia might have killed him because then we would be confused, but I still think the first sentence.

Well, I have class and stuff now. Be back at 3:00ish or something.

CallmePrismatic · 06-01-2006, 11:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by secretskull

Explain why you think it's the Mafia Don. It could have easily been any other role.
CP the mafia has no reason to waste a kill on a known townie. Sure, they can't convince the town to lynch him, but they can just convince the town to lynch someone else. The Mafia's nights are better spent on narrowing down suspects for the town aligned roles. As are the nights of the SK (and the Reporter for that matter).

I'm sorry, maybe I missed something, but why are a few of you so sure that the mafia would pass up the perfect Nightkill to 'narrow down suspects'? FYI, every time the Mafia kills a person it's bad. The mafia care only about numbers, and the less townies there are the better off they are. Known townies are the mafia's worst enemies because the town automatically trusts them, so the mafia will then hit them when they have the power, Night.

Having vanilla townies known is only in the best interest of the mafia.

Supreme Edgemaster · 06-01-2006, 11:09 AM

My first post In a mafia game!!! YAY!!! Now. To business. I don't trust the vets. So...
VOTE: Mesden

The Wandering God · 06-01-2006, 11:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Supreme Edgemaster

My first post In a mafia game!!! YAY!!! Now. To business. I don't trust the vets. So...
VOTE: Mesden

Well then you better vote for just about everyone here, since most of us are vets.

And now I have a crazy idea.

FoS: CmP Why?

His steadfast refusal to acknowledge the SK's interest in the whole "known townie" debate. All he said was

Quote:

Originally Posted by CmP

The SK is unaccountable for since (s)he just wants everyone dead.

Wrong. So very wrong to say the SK shouldn't be accounted for.

I even pointed out after that why the SK wouldn't want known townies alive (less places to hide), but even after that, he refused to acknowledge that.

Hmmmmmm.

The Wandering God

***Fenris*** · 06-01-2006, 11:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Supreme Edgemaster

My first post In a mafia game!!! YAY!!! Now. To business. I don't trust the vets. So...
VOTE: Mesden

Wow, how deliciously absurd. You're voting for somebody on the basis that they've played before?

That's like saying "You know what you're doing more than me. You must be guilty."

FoS: Supreme Edgemaster

C'mon, give a reason at least.

Mesden · 06-01-2006, 12:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Supreme Edgemaster

My first post In a mafia game!!! YAY!!! Now. To business. I don't trust the vets. So...
VOTE: Mesden

Darn, I have played the game before! I MUST be killed for this act! /sarcasm

Yeeeeeeah, um, did you just vote me for having the MOST posts? That's...so...so flawed...It's perfect!

Wait...No it isn't. Also, if you want a vet, I'd go for CmP, since I'm sure the bringer has more veteran prestige than me, only a player on NPF.

I'll go ahead and agree with Fenris. FOS: SupremeEdge Master

CallmePrismatic · 06-01-2006, 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Supreme Edgemaster

My first post In a mafia game!!! YAY!!! Now. To business. I don't trust the vets. So...
VOTE: Mesden

...Can I buy some pot from you? Although this is partly my fault, I'll start Inexperienced Mafia at some point...in fact I better get on that...

TWG: I guess I didn't respond because, me being egotistical me, didn't see you were talking to me (for future reference, I'm like Beetlejuice except you only have to say my name once). Even then, I guess I usually don't think about the SK because I've never been an SK, while I have been mafia in past games and know how they think. In my game experience the SK usually falls to a random Nightkill (or in one memorable game, quit in disgust because he hated playing the SK). Nevertheless, known townies are bad news for the townie, which is why I never released the names of the people I investigated as PO in Berserk: Mafia.

Supreme Edgemaster · 06-01-2006, 12:45 PM

Ok. I guess that is kind of a stupid way to vote.

UNVOTE: Mesden

I just don't know what to base my vote on. Who I hate in the forums or just the way people act? Any help would...well...help.

05-31-2006, 11:03 PM	#131
DarthMauler64 Doppleganger!!! Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: Pomona, CA Posts: 122	From what I remember about Newb's first post about the inactive roles was that he mentioned there were two roles that hadn't sent anything in. One was the Neyo the Vig because Neyo forgot he signed up or something. My opinion is the Mafia Don was the other, but I am not sure. Also, Newb, can you highlight the players the appropriate colors on the players list on the front page? __________________ I like pie. GENERATION 11: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social experiment.

06-01-2006, 10:32 AM	#132
secretskull SMARTASS Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Israel Posts: 1,297	Explain why you think it's the Mafia Don. It could have easily been any other role. CP the mafia has no reason to waste a kill on a known townie. Sure, they can't convince the town to lynch him, but they can just convince the town to lynch someone else. The Mafia's nights are better spent on narrowing down suspects for the town aligned roles. As are the nights of the SK (and the Reporter for that matter). Anyway right now we should be concentrating on putting pressure on those people who haven't posted much, but have been on. That way a Mafia member can't hide there. __________________ Do geese see god? Everyone is an asshole. Including me. Especially including the double asshole who read this and nodded smugly.

06-01-2006, 10:57 AM	#133
DarthMauler64 Doppleganger!!! Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: Pomona, CA Posts: 122	My reason is Grthwllms hasn't played this game before. If I were the mafia I would have killed someone with some experience or that I knew that their death would stir up trouble. Then again the mafia might have killed him because then we would be confused, but I still think the first sentence. Well, I have class and stuff now. Be back at 3:00ish or something. __________________ I like pie. GENERATION 11: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social experiment.