Mafia: NPF edition

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by Spacepope, Lord of the Mixed Up

He's not a suspect, Confirmed mafia.
I was just lumping them all together.

This is more in here for finality, as it just restates your confusion of context.

Originally Posted by Spacepope, The Two Opposers

Okay, so removing the twiddy from my list.

We still have a Roleclaim for mafia, giving us other names for the mafia. so replace twiddy with Steel Shadow, "Halerthorn", Mafia aligned, and then re-think it.

Edit: I was confused becuase everyone was talking about last game. B-Real, are you talking about this game or basic?

Well, alright, let's replace it. Your list NOW has a confirmed, dead mafiate, a confirmed mafiate, the person who confirmed the mafiate and a townie.

Mmmmmmmhmmmmmmm...

Originally Posted by Spacepope, Return of the No Lynch

Ok, so B-real may be the only one that we can safely assume is mafia.

I am going out on a limb here and am going to Vote: NO Lynch, and if we all do that, the vig can kill b_real, hopefully without much recourse.

No Lynch=Bad. We could definitely have waited for the night to let B_Real die, but we STILL had time to get a mafiate during the day.

The only time I've ever seen no lynch work was...never. It's only been used by Scum to take away the town's most powerful weapon.

Originally Posted by Spacepope, The One Quote to End Them All(Literally!)

I'm about as mafia as you are.

You dead bastard.

Seriously though, He didn't give a reason why he thought so, so I have no defence.
Aside from calling him a bastard.

Which is pretty solid in some states.

Dead bastard.

Yeah, I see this one as complete humor, but, let's not disregard the fact that a Townie was against him. Not purely convincing, but it's there.

AND THAT IS EVERYTHING. I have NOT seen ONE SLIGHTLY redeeming post in your favor. Ecurt and You have the most against in my eyes and Ecurt is honestly just giving me the Psycho Mantis feeling.

Seriously, after going over the thread, you've got a bad track record and your excuse for...much activity and nearly everything you mess up on is your job or the sheer fact you're confused.

You just don't sit right with me.

[TheSpacePope]

Yes, he called the confirmed mafiate Scummy. How freaking awful. *Eye roll*

Because at the time fenris Knew he was mafia? Please.

All of your evidence is mostly out of context quotes. The long post was a looking at b-real's accusations and laying them out.
Made some mistakes. Granted in this game that can cost you your life, but i am not going to just harp on the fact that I made a mistake.
The only response that I have fo ryou is that B-real was a confirmed mafiate and he put the finger on you as a mafiate also.
So does that make me more suspect, or you? It turns out he was lying about catlover anyway so maybe he was lying about that too. But it still makes me wonder. However, unlike you, I am going to hold my vote until some better evidence than a "joke" as you yourself called it.

That wasn't defending. That was an abrasive joke between me and a dead friend and if you use THAT as any kind of evidence, so help me CmP will turn in his grave.

So you weren't defending me?
You didn't say that IC's post was against the rules?
Did these things just not happen?
All I am saying people is that Mesden is the only person still alive that was fingered by B-real as mafia.....
I think we need a bit of PO action here.
edit and for the record here is that "JOKE" post.

The hell is wrong with you?

Vote: Inbred Chocobo

I mean, the HELL is wrong with you? You didn't even GIVE A REASON and he's posted by now. Short of PM watching, the HELL is wrong with you?

Edit: Bold

Edit 2: Abrasive humor to counter his, mind you.
__________________

edit:

Originally Posted by mesden the total......

No Lynch=Bad. We could definitely have waited for the night to let B_Real die, but we STILL had time to get a mafiate during the day.

The only time I've ever seen no lynch work was...never. It's only been used by Scum to take away the town's most powerful weapon.

When someone roleclaims a secret power that could potentiall kill several townies, someone has to step up and say hey, lets pull back from the fire. and is't only in YOUR playing style that a no lynch is bad.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by TheSpacePope

Because at the time fenris Knew he was mafia? Please.

It was after he admitted to it, so yeah.

Originally Posted by TheSpacePope

I think we need a bit of PO action here.

No, we don't. This is day 3. It's not that far in the game. We don't need to reveal one of our strongest weapons.

[TheSpacePope]

No, we don't. This is day 3. It's not that far in the game. We don't need to reveal one of our strongest weapons.

You know, you are probably right there.
However, there is no reason that is not superficial, manufatured and out of context, to lynch me.

[Sithdarth]

When someone roleclaims a secret power that could potentiall kill several townies, someone has to step up and say hey, lets pull back from the fire.

No, no we shouldn't. Now I want to be careful about who we lynch but losing townies to roles is basically unavoidable. Also, if they have that roll they are evil and have to go, almost to the extent that accepting the activation of a power that may unbalance the game. Further, there is little reason to even believe the person. If you do and do not act they win. That's never good.

[Fenris]

This may seem like a tangent, but where the hell has Newb been? He's in this game too.

[TheSpacePope]

And I kept trying to get catlover lynched cause he annoyed the rest of us (mafiates). We kept trying to get a hold of him since he was our don and he kept saying "later later" and finally he left. We sent the night kill without waiting for him. When he came back he still kept saying later later. So we again sent in the role for him. Except this time trying to frame him since we did have a convenient kill as our night 1 kill. So we killed Silly Kitty. And there you have it. I was willing to possibly sacrifice myself to get Catlover lynched so someone else could take the helm. EDIT FORGOT THIS:::Good luck mafiate. You will need it going solo. God knows Catlover isn't going to help you. And Mesden's one backstabbing !#%$@ of a mafiate too.

[/quote]

Just a couple of quotes that b_real fingers mesden as mafia in, I thought that they were pertinent to the case against me, which seems to be kind of out there at this point, seeing as it's coming from someone who provides no response to either of these claims in the next few posts.

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by TheSpacePope

Because at the time fenris Knew he was mafia? Please.

Yeah, him roleclaiming it WASN'T backing enough. *Eye roll*

All of your evidence is mostly out of context quotes.

Out of context? I went into extremes to KEEP it in context. I put in quotes within quotes to GUARANTEE it wasn't out of context.

The long post was a looking at b-real's accusations and laying them out.

Yes they were! I never said that wasn't the case. I was just pointing out all the subtleties and the perception I got from each of your posts, which is the only thing that matters to MY vote aside from someone else stating a REALLY good point.

Made some mistakes.

Noone's infalliable!

Granted in this game that can cost you your life, but i am not going to just harp on the fact that I made a mistake.

You made a few mistakes and added it all up into a horrible track record!

The only response that I have fo ryou is that B-real was a confirmed mafiate and he put the finger on you as a mafiate also.

Mmmmh, and he was confirmed BECAUSE OF ME. He'd only finger me if he was TRYING to drop mafia numbers like that, which he wasn't given Catlover's innocence. If he was really pointing out mafia, why wouldn't he have targetted two others?

Because that's not what he was doing as far as I can tell.

So does that make me more suspect, or you? It turns out he was lying about catlover anyway so maybe he was lying about that too. But it still makes me wonder. However, unlike you, I am going to hold my vote until some better evidence than a "joke" as you yourself called it.

Um, alright. Go get some. I've got about a BILLION posts to pick from. Go ahead. Find something. I did it with you.

So you weren't defending me?

Um, no.

You didn't say that IC's post was against the rules?

The first post wasn't against the rules, because he's allowe one fluff post. And I think abrasive humor counts as fluff.

So, being the person I am, I had a friendly joke by voting for someone who was a dead, confirmed townie for voting for you. I don't see HOW you can take voting for a dead, confirmed townie serious.

Did these things just not happen?

They happened alright!

All I am saying people is that Mesden is the only person still alive that was fingered by B-real as mafia.....

Yup! He fingered two! Which, the first ended up townie! So he wasn't trying to bring the rest of the mafia down with him, it SEEMS. I'm not using this to confirm me being townie, but to prove that's it's little more than conjecture on your part.

Now, let's go and look at the LAST accusation made on conjecture

I think we need a bit of PO action here.

That will, without a doubt, kill me. If the PO reveals himself, then the BG HAS to protect him. No other choice.

Now, if I'm Mafia OR town I die. Confirmed townies are bad for the mafia and sicne the BG will be busy with the PO, the mafia will kill me instantly.

And, if I am mafia, I die by lynch.

It's unfair to pull that on me, because it's the same situation on whether you should lynch me or not.

[TheSpacePope]

Now, if I'm Mafia OR town I die. Confirmed townies are bad for the mafia and sicne the BG will be busy with the PO, the mafia will kill me instantly.

And, if I am mafia, I die by lynch.

It's unfair to pull that on me, because it's the same situation on whether you should lynch me or not.

Same for me, now you know how trapped I feel.

That's Why I didn't FOS or vote for you.

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by TheSpacePope

Same for me, now you know how trapped I feel.

That's Why I didn't FOS or vote for you.

Wow, you take my statement out of context. I was referring ENTIRELY to being PO revealed, which I don't wish on anyone aside from Mafia. I only want the PO to reveal Mafia, which would be a game saver at this point.

Also, I think (THINK) the PO targetted me last night, seeing as the comotion I've made. But there's no way to be sure and I ONLY want the PO to come out to reveal Mafia.