Mafia: Goodfella's Edition

[P-Sleazy]

So, is Karanod dead or isn't he dead? TSP?

Edit: Clarification.

[Nikose Tyris]

did a little backtracking; back when it was Ecurt's vote-off, it was a tie between Ecurt and IHMN. what happened to IHMN that he stopped getting voted for? Just because Ecurt wanted to die, then we just kinda... forgot about IHMN?

And yeah, like I said, everyone go back and find people that may be suspicous from old posts.

I await IHMN's rebuttal.

And he's dead, TSP went offline on us all, and forgot to count his death.

[Elbodo]

Originally posted by Cephrir:
Elbodo really stands out to me. He was the one who initiated the vote for Ecurt, not counting the votes Ecurt asked for. I don't really like his reasoning against Ecurt, and I think someone pointed this out earlier, but he has a tendency to present a case, vote, and disappear. It's almost as if something that isn't lynching is a waste of time, because all he can do is slip up. True, I'm digging a ways back, but it's my only idea right now.
FoS: Elbodo

I'll make a couple of basic factual points before I proceed to the defense of my playing style:

1.) My vote for Ecurt was the my only vote in this game.

2.) If you look back a ways prior to my vote for Ecurt you'll notice that when I first called him out I just FOSed him. I only changed me FOS to a vote when he made another unhelpful post. After that I was offline while I went out to enjoy my Friday night. When I got back Saturday afternoon I read Ecurt's explanation and would have unvoted but he was already dead. (it was after the lynching but before Space Pope described the night roles) Sunday afternoon I went to (of all places) Karanod's house to play D&D and because his mom kept asking for my advice about her broken computer. I got back here last night and found that another day had gone by.

Anyway, as for my vote for Ecurt, I'll simply say that my reasoning was sound. He was the most suspicious person I could see at the time did nothing to allay that suspicion between the time I FOSed and the time I voted.

As for my playing style: Anything that isn't lynching is a waste of time. That's how the game is played. Daytime activity is about the town deciding who we should lynch; who is with us and who is not, accusation and defense. Anything else is pointless.

I try to make sure that when I post I have something to say. Fluff posts only confuse the issue and make room for the scum to manipulate and confuse us. It was, in fact, Ecurt's numerous fluff posts that caused me to suspect him.

[Nikose Tyris]

Hm. Looking at Cephir... I wanna hear his defense, although he did have a point on your style of play being, 'suspicious' seeming, Elbodo. I'm holding my votes till later in the game anyway, but I think we can reasonably find who we vote for next; so unless Fenris comes in and says, "Whoa, guys, I checked Elbodo/Cephrir/Jesus Murphy last night, Don't kill him!" I think we're truly are on our own.

[P-Sleazy]

Originally Posted by Elbodo

As for my playing style: Anything that isn't lynching is a waste of time. That's how the game is played. Daytime activity is about the town deciding who we should lynch; who is with us and who is not, accusation and defense. Anything else is pointless

Now this here is unsettling. Especially the bolded part.

Everything that isn't lynching is a waste of time? That's not true. Before you can lynch someone, you have to spend a little time with them fluff posts to spot the scum. It seems to have helped Fenris find Karanod.

Now if we were to all just lynch right off the bat each day, since anything else would be a waste of time, then we'd be more susceptible to mafia intervention then since we, as a town, aren't thinking things through enough to say "hey, you know, lynching (insert name here) seems a bit too hasty and the reasons against him are a bit weak" and poof, there goes a mafiate and we're 3 people closer to losing to the snitchs. (1 for the lynch, 1 Snitched, and one vigilante'ed[discounting SK since he's dead]).

You see what I'm getting at here?

VOTE ELBODO

For irresponsibility as explained above.

[Nikose Tyris]

You make a good point too; anyone else you would like to bring up right now, B_real? I'd like to see your side of "who's doin' what where and why it looks bad."

[P-Sleazy]

Eh? someone asking me for who to lynch? My god ITS FINALLY HAPPENED! Hell Froze over and the minions of satan have begun working thier horrendous deeds on Nikose.

Honestly, I just kinda read through peoples posts and if there's something that bothers me, I'll bring it up. Like the whole voting for Karanod thing yesterday. And Today there's Elbodo. As I find things, I'll bring it up.

[Nikose Tyris]

*Screams, grabs his bat, begins to beat at the minions* Not again! NOT AGAIN!!!

but seriously, That's a pretty fair point on Elbodo. So, without further adieu,
VOTE: ELBODO

EDIT: although I'd still like to see IHMN explain why he just suddenly stopped getting voted for, besides Ecurt being a more willing target.

[Roy_D_Mylote]

Well just hold on. Why shoud IHMN have to explain the actions of other people?

[Nikose Tyris]

he doesn't; I want to know what his defense was against Ecurt, other than, "hey, look at Ecurt!" from someone else, as he really didn't protect himself at all.