Superhero Mafia

[Nayno]

Yeah. Well, don't get me wrong. Mesden's been pretty much at the top of my suspicious list since we lynched Red Fighter, but I'm willing to take her confirmation for what it is until we get rid of the unconfirmed players.

EDIT: On that note, I'd really like to get rid of Stomphoof unless we can get some kind of evidence to back up his role. Like, being mentioned in the night posts. At all.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Nayno

Yeah. Well, don't get me wrong. Mesden's been pretty much at the top of my suspicious list since we lynched Red Fighter, but I'm willing to take her confirmation for what it is until we get rid of the unconfirmed players.

EDIT: On that note, I'd really like to get rid of Stomphoof unless we can get some kind of evidence to back up his role. Like, being mentioned in the night posts. At all.

Getting rid of the unconfirmed players doesn't work. I don't think we've hit a single bad guy with it, although I may be wrong.

[Nayno]

You're not counting vig hits.

Besides, we would've gotten mafia if we had followed my lead and lynched Doppler12 instead of Red Fighter.

Regarding Stomphoof, he hasn't posted in this thread since #275. He might get ejected from the game? Maybe?

[Professor Smarmiarty]

Well it did seem very odd to me that Mesden would get a GM conformation as the Punisher. It's not like he's a very public superhero.
Suspicion up!
B_Real was checking out an unroleclaimed player right? I'll wait till he gets back to us.

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by Barrel-Hating Sycophant

Well it did seem very odd to me that Mesden would get a GM conformation as the Punisher. It's not like he's a very public superhero.

What? Yes he is.

What kind of Punisher are you talking about?

Suspicion up!

Who are you Johnny Blaze?

Also, like I said, I've stopped caring about this game a whole load. I guess I just chalk up Nikose's 'her her her' post to him being a hack writer, because even if I were Mystique, why would I not stay the punisher at night, when I'm vulnerable to junk?

but, that's just my stringent logic. If you guys wanna lynch me, have a hoot, because I've been oh so suspicious apparently.

Atleast, I am now as soon as 1 person brings up something mildly plausible.

I like how that works out, by the way.

Bandwagoning is a good hobby.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Mesden

Also, like I said, I've stopped caring about this game a whole load. I guess I just chalk up Nikose's 'her her her' post to him being a hack writer, because even if I were Mystique, why would I not stay the punisher at night, when I'm vulnerable to junk?

Or because you've been caught. Anyway, you realize that even if you're in the form of a guy, you're still a girl, right? Mystique never changes genders, just outward appearances.

but, that's just my stringent logic. If you guys wanna lynch me, have a hoot, because I've been oh so suspicious apparently.

Atleast, I am now as soon as 1 person brings up something mildly plausible.

I like how that works out, by the way.

Bandwagoning is a good hobby.

Well, she doesn't care. An apathy shield to make it seem like she's innocent. I see no better leads and "clearing up the inactives" seems unnecessary right now. I say leave that for tomorrow, because we can get a mafiate now.

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by FenrisWolf

Or because you've been caught.

You can use that hackney circular logic anywhere, Fennypoo.

Anyway, you realize that even if you're in the form of a guy, you're still a girl, right? Mystique never changes genders, just outward appearances.

Yes, because you can obviously tell the difference?

Now come on, Mystique is a shape shifter, dude. She changes *entirely*. She's a guy when she's a guy and a chipmunk when she's a chipmunk.

You guys are really bad at your superheroes.

Well, she doesn't care. An apathy shield to make it seem like she's innocent.

Everything's a shield. Humor, defending others, NOT defending others, being aggressive, being apathetic, being a bandwagoner.

All of these are things you can point at and yell "Guilty!"

Maybe, just maybe, I'm being apathetic because this game is really lopsided, what with the, what, 15 to 2 advantage?

I see no better leads and "clearing up the inactives" seems unnecessary right now. I say leave that for tomorrow, because we can get a mafiate now.

You know, dude, beyond all of this, explain one thing.

How did I catch Marius for the Green Ranger?

Seriously, if you can explain that Mystique is ALSO a singular PO in the Mafia, just maybe you can pin me for some lying, devious role claim power. But you're still just using circumstantial junk on me.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Mesden

You can use that hackney circular logic anywhere, Fennypoo.

I fail to see how it's circular logic. You cannot dismiss evidence by insulting the GO.

Yes, because you can obviously tell the difference?

Now come on, Mystique is a shape shifter, dude. She changes *entirely*. She's a guy when she's a guy and a chipmunk when she's a chipmunk.

You guys are really bad at your superheroes.

Again, you fail to address my point. The fact is, Nikose, being the all-knowing GO, will speak from his perspective, and to his perspective, you are Mystique, who is a girl by default.

Everything's a shield. Humor, defending others, NOT defending others, being aggressive, being apathetic, being a bandwagoner.

All of these are things you can point at and yell "Guilty!"

Maybe, just maybe, I'm being apathetic because this game is really lopsided, what with the, what, 15 to 2 advantage?

Many things are shields, but that was an attempt to look innocent by apathy. Which is a decent ploy, I must admit.

You know, dude, beyond all of this, explain one thing.

How did I catch Marius for the Green Ranger?

Lucky guess, I'd assume. He was giving out some hints to his role and you picked up on them.

Seriously, if you can explain that Mystique is ALSO a singular PO in the Mafia, just maybe you can pin me for some lying, devious role claim power. But you're still just using circumstantial junk on me.

Don't dismiss every thing thrown against you. You're basically saying in a roundabout way that I'm wrong and you're right. It's not circumstantial junk, it is a valid clue that you seem to be trying to downplay by calling the person writing the hints a talentless hack.

EDIT: Also, POS claimed Green Ranger early on and Marius replaced him, so... I'm sure you can fill in the blank as to how you got that particular bit of information.

[P-Sleazy]

Nikose still hasn't gotten back to me on the investigation, but I'm half tempted to change to mesden, but I'll trust her claim for now.

[Roy_D_Mylote]

Originally Posted by Mesden

Who are you Johnny Blaze?

Ahem.