Urban Mafia - Page 73

Professor Smarmiarty · 11-11-2007, 06:33 PM

It's not even about whether you are lying on LHN or not B_Real. You clearly have had access to some information.
What its about is your unknown role, your information hiding and your general shadiness.
The fact that you avoid this issue and are just like, Lynch LHN quickly and see if I'm correct, is pointing to you trying to lead us somewhere.

Death by Stabbing · 11-11-2007, 06:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Barrel-Hating Sycophant

It's not even about whether you are lying on LHN or not B_Real. You clearly have had access to some information.
What its about is your unknown role, your information hiding and your general shadiness.
The fact that you avoid this issue and are just like, Lynch LHN quickly and see if I'm correct, is pointing to you trying to lead us somewhere.

Well that makes about as much sense as anything...sure I'll vote for LHN...just to see where your crazy ideas take me!

Vote: LHN

Ape Boy · 11-11-2007, 07:10 PM

Here's my reasoning behind not Unvoting B-HS so far:

1) We have strong reason to believe B-HS is as scummy as B_real, only not dangling the Cake of Secret Information. If there does end up being Cake at the end of the B_real experiment, then it behooves us to not kill B_real at this point.

2) By lynching B-HS, we get to test whether or not there really is Cake. B_real has implicated B-HS as a Mafiate, B-HS has claimed a self-aligned Survivor role. If B-HS comes up Survivor, then we know B_real has already been lying to us, doesn't have the amount of information he claims, and stands to be lynched immediately.

3) The whole Replicator business.

Now, these are the faults with a B-HS lynch:

A) B_real is absolutely not being forthcoming with us and we've no idea all his win condition entails or what abilities he may have or gain.

B) If B-HS is the Survivor role he claims, he could be the last cog to B_real's proposed "Lucky Number Slevin" win condition. The Hated Townie would've been a red herring and some other stuff would have to fit, but it's entirely possible.

C) B_Real isn't dead. Could mean B_real was protected, but there was no flavor to support this. It could also mean B_real made a new mafioso partnership to keep himself alive for a later screwjob and both Mafia's tried to hit Tendronai.

There's probably a couple more arguments for and agaisnt, I just wanted to lay things out as I saw them at this point. I'm for lynching B-HS at this point, but I will weigh in further argument.

Professor Smarmiarty · 11-11-2007, 09:21 PM

Well here's how I see it.
There are two possibilities that you guys are weighing up:
I'm a survivor like I claim, then I'm not going to be winning anytime soon.
I'm mafia like others claim, then I'm also not going to be winning anytime soon and I can be roleblocked.
B_Real noone knows. Surely it makes sense to lynch him now, block me tonight and then lynch me tommorow if you still think I'm mafia.

Tendronai · 11-11-2007, 09:26 PM

You know, I've been thinking it over. Remember this?

Quote:

Originally Posted by B_Real

Also, just to make sure that I live through till tommorow, I'll give you guys the last 3 mafiates tommorow.

From here. So I guess what I'm saying is, live up to your half of the bargain, or I will decide to go along with everyone else and lynch you, recommend the vig target BHS, and block LHN myself.

P-Sleazy · 11-11-2007, 09:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pink Bunny

You weren't even going to give us LHN until I pressured you! You tried to just make people quick lynch BHS without giving us a name.

And also, you lie. Not that that's hardly surprising.

#703, I did unvote you.

The second post I had of the day was one where I gave you LHN. The only post I had that day was the one voting BHS since he was a given lynch for the day. And that was just a quick post since I had left till later.

Rygar · 11-12-2007, 11:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ape Boy

C) B_Real isn't dead. Could mean B_real was protected, but there was no flavor to support this. It could also mean B_real made a new mafioso partnership to keep himself alive for a later screwjob and both Mafia's tried to hit Tendronai.

Or maybe he's the Don of both Mafias.
Not voting yet because I'm still trying to decide whether B_Real is screwing us or just using us.

Ape Boy · 11-12-2007, 11:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rygar

Or maybe he's the Don of both Mafias.

Could be if he got promoted. Fenris and Moogle were the Don's.

Sheb · 11-12-2007, 11:46 AM

Apparently I'm still alive in this. Had it confused with Village, they're kind of similar. Just read through 20 or so pages to catch up. B_real seems incredibly scummy to me. He's really just stringing us along until he gets his win condition, which seems to be either survival to the end or something more sinister. If it's survival to the end, it'd be much easier and less scummy seeming to just drop all the names of the mafia he knows and ask for some BG loving. This makes me think it's something more sinister. Either way, I feel like keeping B_real around is just risking too much.

Vote: B_real

Pink Bunny · 11-12-2007, 12:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

The second post I had of the day was one where I gave you LHN. The only post I had that day was the one voting BHS since he was a given lynch for the day. And that was just a quick post since I had left till later.

I can't help but notice you ignored Tendronai's beautiful ultimatum that links to your lies. Holding up your end of the bargain my ass. You've yet to do it.

11-11-2007, 07:10 PM	#723
Ape Boy This was a triumph Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Lowry Park Zoo, 3rd cage from the back Posts: 183	Here's my reasoning behind not Unvoting B-HS so far: 1) We have strong reason to believe B-HS is as scummy as B_real, only not dangling the Cake of Secret Information. If there does end up being Cake at the end of the B_real experiment, then it behooves us to not kill B_real at this point. 2) By lynching B-HS, we get to test whether or not there really is Cake. B_real has implicated B-HS as a Mafiate, B-HS has claimed a self-aligned Survivor role. If B-HS comes up Survivor, then we know B_real has already been lying to us, doesn't have the amount of information he claims, and stands to be lynched immediately. 3) The whole Replicator business. Now, these are the faults with a B-HS lynch: A) B_real is absolutely not being forthcoming with us and we've no idea all his win condition entails or what abilities he may have or gain. B) If B-HS is the Survivor role he claims, he could be the last cog to B_real's proposed "Lucky Number Slevin" win condition. The Hated Townie would've been a red herring and some other stuff would have to fit, but it's entirely possible. C) B_Real isn't dead. Could mean B_real was protected, but there was no flavor to support this. It could also mean B_real made a new mafioso partnership to keep himself alive for a later screwjob and both Mafia's tried to hit Tendronai. There's probably a couple more arguments for and agaisnt, I just wanted to lay things out as I saw them at this point. I'm for lynching B-HS at this point, but I will weigh in further argument. __________________ Nothing to see here. ...Seriously. So stop looking. Pervert.

11-12-2007, 11:46 AM	#729
Sheb Goomba Join Date: Oct 2006 Posts: 2	Apparently I'm still alive in this. Had it confused with Village, they're kind of similar. Just read through 20 or so pages to catch up. B_real seems incredibly scummy to me. He's really just stringing us along until he gets his win condition, which seems to be either survival to the end or something more sinister. If it's survival to the end, it'd be much easier and less scummy seeming to just drop all the names of the mafia he knows and ask for some BG loving. This makes me think it's something more sinister. Either way, I feel like keeping B_real around is just risking too much. Vote: B_real __________________ It just occurred to me that I have no signature. And now I do.

11-11-2007, 06:33 PM	#721
Professor Smarmiarty Sent to the cornfield Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: K-space Posts: 9,758	It's not even about whether you are lying on LHN or not B_Real. You clearly have had access to some information. What its about is your unknown role, your information hiding and your general shadiness. The fact that you avoid this issue and are just like, Lynch LHN quickly and see if I'm correct, is pointing to you trying to lead us somewhere.

11-11-2007, 09:21 PM	#724
Professor Smarmiarty Sent to the cornfield Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: K-space Posts: 9,758	Well here's how I see it. There are two possibilities that you guys are weighing up: I'm a survivor like I claim, then I'm not going to be winning anytime soon. I'm mafia like others claim, then I'm also not going to be winning anytime soon and I can be roleblocked. B_Real noone knows. Surely it makes sense to lynch him now, block me tonight and then lynch me tommorow if you still think I'm mafia.