Mafia: Basic

[The Wandering God]

Originally Posted by h4x.m4g3

Yeah, but I get the feeling he's not. Wether or not he was shadowing (learning how to be) the Doc, we may never know, unless newb says he manages to learn it independently or something. But really why would he make up a useless trait, when he could have easily just ran with your suspicion of him being the reporter?

Because the REAL reporter would almost certainly target them. Same with the Vig. And since that leaves the PO as the last possible useful role, I'd be more than willing to say he isn't.

The Wandering God

EDIT: Because I just HAVE to fricking acknowledge what CmP just said.

Originally Posted by CallmePrismatic

On catlover, I...wait a sec, deja vu...


So you didn't think Ogianres was dangerous, and you voted for him anyways? Do you think that absolves you of your actions, that you didn't mean it. Or is it because you're a confirmed townie so you feel that you don't have to take responsibility for your actions?

You contributed to the death of a townie as much as I did. Both of us did it unintentionally.

Also, a lesson and corrolarry from NPF Mafia the first: Lynching a mafiate doesn't mean all voters were non-mafiates. Lynching a townie doesn't mean that voters were all non-townies.

*buzzer sound*
Sorry, incorrect. You see, I wasn't the first person to vote for him. Nor did I post a list of convincing reasons that led to the town killing him. I was the LAST person to vote actually, and if I hadn't, it wouldn't have made a difference. And I stated my reason for voting in my lynch vote. I didn't just say "Going along with CmP".

And as to the last point... I WAS THE FIRST TO POINT IT OUT! How dare you throw that back in my face.

Especially when I pointed out that Twiddy could be mafiate.

And no, I don't buy the Catlover explanation at all.

The Wandering God EDIT OVER