Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[Ole' Dude With the Face]

Originally Posted by Me in post 77

You deserve to be voted for just for suggesting that.

Unvote
Vote: Masked Jedi

But yeah, thats neither here or there.

As for Sithdarth's posts, the first time I skimmed through them, paid very little attention, then went on as usual. As the debate about his math started, I went back and read through them, that way I knew what the hell we were talking about, at least to some degree.

And for trusting Sithdarth, I don't. His whole list could be contrived from people he knows is not his alignment, keeping his potential teammates off the chopping block. Or there is the logic that Newb came up with back here:

Originally Posted by Newb

Any time somebody in mafia presents a list of people "one of which is a mafiate, I dont know which" there is an 87% chance that they are themselves a mafiate who is trying to buy time by saying "well it must be the next guy". You mentioned 27 because your original math included that number, but you glossed over 27 as soon as you could. It therefor follows, in my mind, that Cephrir, number 27, is aligned with you.

So, there is two possible ways that he could use his math to his advantage. But, for now, I find the case against BHS more compelling. Am I going to believe anything Sithdarth says? No. Will I look to see if it makes some sense and can potentially helpful? Yes.

Edit: It should be noted that I feel that way (bolded) about everyone in Mafia games. Not just Sithdarth.