Homestuck Mafia Thread

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by rpgdemon

It is completely looking at the thing logically.

If a bulletproof comes out as being bulletproof, I will take it as conclusive, hatchet buried in the corpse evidence, that I am unsalvageably seen as scum. There's no way that a scum would lie about being bulletproof just to put me under the dagger a bit more, if I were innocent, as I'll be lynched within 48 hours without their intervention. The only people who would want to come out as bulletproof are those who themselves are town bulletproofs, and believe me to be scum, to prove that I'm scum. They have nothing to lose by doing so. The only reason -NOT- to come out as being a town bulletproof is if you know that I'm innocent, and don't want to make yourself look guilty.

1) Scum would totally lie about being bulletproof. They have a safe list, as you said.
2) Or Scum bulletproofs. Or scum in general.
3) I have no objections to other people coming out as bulletproof, except for the fact that scum then know who not to target.

And the whole horrible defense that I still need to take the time to dissect thing is irritating, too.