Stargate SG1 Mafia

Moogle0119 · 10-05-2006, 09:19 AM

Cephrir I'm sorry I ignored your comment but I was defending myself against Roy who voted for me because he had defended me (?) and I forgot to address your post earlier. While I'm not the most knowledgable when it comes to the SG1 series, if the ascended beings role makes sense for SK being scum then I agree with it as well. The reason I've been trying to go after IHMN for a while now is because of all of his posts are exactly like the one he posted above. He starts off with a vote against someone, who has already been voted for by others, and leaves a little quip at the end and never seems to address the fact that he's been voted against.

I understand that some people are just lurkers because thats their game style but this is a mafia game. I don't know why people would willingly sign up for this game and then refuse to participate at least somewhat frequently with posting who they think the town should lynch as well as defending themselves whenever they get votes against them. If that's someone's play style that's perfectly fine (they CAN do whatever they want) however it's not usually beneficial to the town to stay quiet and lurk for the entire game. This is my entire "I hate lurkers" thing that everyone keeps addressing. I don't even hate lurkers it's just that if you never post anything then there's no way to judge whether or not you're scummy and prevents us from being able to judge you. It's fine if that's your tactic and all, but if you start getting called out you should at least address it (in my opinion). To each his own though.

Anyway before I got off on that little tangent there, I still think and believe IHMN is particularily scummy for never once addressing the fact he's been voted against and every vote he's made has been a blatant bandwagon vote (as Mesden has pointed out in an earlier post). If there is sufficient evidence that we NEED to vote Silly Kitty then I'll change my vote to her then, but until then I'm keeping my vote on IHMN and keeping a watch on that lurker.

10-05-2006, 09:19 AM	#11
Moogle0119 The REAL Lord of the Dance Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Narshe Caves Posts: 397	Cephrir I'm sorry I ignored your comment but I was defending myself against Roy who voted for me because he had defended me (?) and I forgot to address your post earlier. While I'm not the most knowledgable when it comes to the SG1 series, if the ascended beings role makes sense for SK being scum then I agree with it as well. The reason I've been trying to go after IHMN for a while now is because of all of his posts are exactly like the one he posted above. He starts off with a vote against someone, who has already been voted for by others, and leaves a little quip at the end and never seems to address the fact that he's been voted against. I understand that some people are just lurkers because thats their game style but this is a mafia game. I don't know why people would willingly sign up for this game and then refuse to participate at least somewhat frequently with posting who they think the town should lynch as well as defending themselves whenever they get votes against them. If that's someone's play style that's perfectly fine (they CAN do whatever they want) however it's not usually beneficial to the town to stay quiet and lurk for the entire game. This is my entire "I hate lurkers" thing that everyone keeps addressing. I don't even hate lurkers it's just that if you never post anything then there's no way to judge whether or not you're scummy and prevents us from being able to judge you. It's fine if that's your tactic and all, but if you start getting called out you should at least address it (in my opinion). To each his own though. Anyway before I got off on that little tangent there, I still think and believe IHMN is particularily scummy for never once addressing the fact he's been voted against and every vote he's made has been a blatant bandwagon vote (as Mesden has pointed out in an earlier post). If there is sufficient evidence that we NEED to vote Silly Kitty then I'll change my vote to her then, but until then I'm keeping my vote on IHMN and keeping a watch on that lurker.