Mafia: NPF edition

[neyo the king]

Alright, B_real, I'ma gonna say this here to ya.

1) You're assumption is based on a past game. The chances that that game is affecting this one is slim, really.

2) You need to stop Role-Claiming Townie. Makes you look scummy everytime you do it.

3) Telling who you think is a special role isn't a very good idea, I think.

4) I don't think you're mafia.

Yes, that's right, I said it. I don't think that B_real is mafia. I think he is just a townie who thought of something, and decided to share. Yes, I think he is acting scummy, but I still don't think he's mafia. He's just floundering around trying his best to stay alive right now, which can be hard to do with the whole town on your back.

What can change my mind? Catlover's next post. If he doesn't post? If this situation doesn't change, then I will more than likely vote for B_real.

But, as of now, I shall let this situation unravel.

[Ogianres]

Originally Posted by SithDarth

Again there is no way of telling if the PO listened or not also this way we potentially sacrifice the PO for a townie. Not a very good trade.

Personally I think that Roy may have been our only PO. It isn't uncommon for a mafia game to have a crazy cop and no normal cops. It helps shift the balance in favor of scum, which is useful if there are lots of pro-town roles. And I'm going to assume that many of the secret roles are pro-town, and a crazy cop may have been necessary to balance out the game.
But in any case, we shouldn't ever have to rely on roles to get us through the game. We have to try as hard as we can to just be able to win without dependance on roles. So B_Real, I think that you should try and defend yourself in another way.

[GARUD]

And also, Mesden, If you could just tell me how you brought up that deleted post of Garud's I'd be more than glad to give you guys proof of that the SK was taken out. It was mentioned in one of the Deleted posts before the game started.

There is a Serial Killer. If I remember I took the imposter out. Why is it not in the first post? Because I just copy/pasted it from Mesden's game (I'm lazy).

Carry on people (and kneel at my feet while you are there).

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

Fenris is our most likely PO since he seems to know the game name of the SK.

No no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no.

If I was the PO, I'd tell you who the SK was. I wouldn't say the game name. I just brought up a little quirk I saw in a character, okay?

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by GARUD

There is a Serial Killer. If I remember I took the imposter out. Why is it not in the first post? Because I just copy/pasted it from Mesden's game (I'm lazy).

Carry on people (and kneel at my feet while you are there).

GASP! I'm right! Amazing! /sarcasm

Originally Posted by B_Real

heh, If I was a positive role, I'd have claimed it by now. Mostly because I would probably go rando killing time at whoever pisses me off and kill off a townie again like I did in //hack Mafia with my Magic mirror allowing me to mimic the PO, VIG, or BG. I killed CmP. I'd much gladly prefer we do a "hey town, lets get someone lynched and then night kill someone wiht my Vigilante roll. BG protect my ass!" Thats not the case so why bother bringing it up. I'm not even gonna TRY to fake a PO. Fenris is our most likely PO since he seems to know the game name of the SK.

Yeah, there's no point in faking any role, since I shot down how you could be any of them...I think you just agreed with me, but stated it your own way. Good job?

You know what? Howabout we get the PO investigate me. now here's the fun part. he can tell you guys if I'm mafia. If I'm not mafia, he'll stay shut and no PO revelation. AND I KNOW that the second part of this will happen in him staying shut about me.

Sith stated my sentiments exactly. And honestly, what's so special about you? Why not let him investigate ME since you're such an INFALLIABLE TOWNIE WHO IS AUTOMATICALLY RIGHT IN ALL ASSUMPTIONS(The hypocrisy is so tasteful here) THEY MAKE!

The PO would then find me to be mafia, because there's NO POSSIBLE WAY IN THE WORLD THAT I CAN BE TOWN ALLIGNED.

So, if the infalliable B_Real is right, this way we can cut our mafia numbers by two! Seeing as I'm OBVIOUSLY a mafia for pointing out a STUPID FREAKING CONJECTURE THAT WOULD'VE GOTTEN SOMEONE LYNCHED, WITHOuT A HINT OF REAL PROOF!

B_Real, you're just just being illogical at this point.

Its also amazing how the SK is not mentioned in the first post. EDIT: and how it's been mentioned in every other game except the very first game. In SOL: Mafia he was replaced with the Imposter.

And also, Mesden, If you could just tell me how you brought up that deleted post of Garud's I'd be more than glad to give you guys proof of that the SK was taken out. It was mentioned in one of the Deleted posts before the game started.

On noes! The mighty B_Real is wrong and mistaken in what he has seen! It's ONLY a one time thing, right? /sarcasm

Me, have a grudge? NAW! Its just that every time I see you in action as you are now, it always ends up in the death of a townie. EVERY DAMN TIME! So yes, everything you do, does seem like a trap to me.

Now you're just spouting lies. Here, let me GO FREAKING PULL UP MY POSTS IN OTHER GAMES WHERE I WASN'T MAFIA AND I VOTED FOR MAFIA AND STATED GREAT REASONS AGAINT THEM BECAUSE I'M CAPABLE OF IT!

This took me about an hour and a half to pull up, By the way! Hope you have fun being wrong. Again.

Here's me casting light on a mafiate for the first time in this game. I DID cast light on a townie as well, but I'm not infalliable. Just to show, this post dropped into a major mafiate v. townie thing which I was winning at the end.

Here, let me go pull up ANOTHER one from that game.

OHMYGOD, I voted for a mafiate first after being the first to cast suspicion on him! Z'OH MY GOD!

Oh no, here's me voting for another mafiate, while still stating that another

Oh, and not only that game. OH NO! Let me go to Mafia SP...

Here's one of the MANY times I defended Jeremiahcron. Ahem, a townie.

Yeah, that's SO anti townie. *Eye roll*

I've got more, you know!

Here's me trying to CONVINCE people NOT to vote for a townie and to look at a MAFIATE!

Here's me defending the Vig.

Here's my first vote of the entire game. It was against a mafia after I deciphered his reasons through my own eye. Sound familiar, huh?

Oh, and here, I unvote a mafiate...and vote for another mafiate with good reason.

The ONLY two people I voted for in that game were mafia. Even THOUGH I was anti town, I still did EVERYTHING in favor for the town.

So, what lie are you going to bring up next?


Edit: For a messed up link

[P-Sleazy]

K!

Originally Posted by Neyo

What can change my mind? Catlover's next post. If he doesn't post? If this situation doesn't change, then I will more than likely vote for B_real.

So all catlover has to do is stay shut up today and I'm a goner to you? That makes sense, in a very twisted way, but still makes sense.

NINJA'd By Mesden: ALright, Mesden. I give up. I'm just gonna go with you're right and I'm wrong. This is becoming to much of a strain on my mind. I'm just gonna sit and see where the town goes from here.

UNVOTE: MESDEN
VOTE: B_REAL:p

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

NINJA'd By Mesden: ALright, Mesden. I give up. I'm just gonna go with you're right and I'm wrong. This is becoming to much of a strain on my mind. I'm just gonna sit and see where the town goes from here.

UNVOTE: MESDEN
VOTE: B_REAL:p

How come, everytime I bring a logical case against you, you just give up? To make me look bad?

Honestly, if you can't defend yourself, then you were mafia bait from the beginning and I feel almost sorry for you, had you not been leading a lynch charge gainst someone off horrible conjecture and against me when all you did was address the more convenient points of my post and lied.

Lied a lot. A whole lot. I called you out on everything and all you can do is give up? Bull.

[P-Sleazy]

I did the best I could defending myself agaisnt you. My first game of Mafia was SOL: Mafia. So I did not know of your history prior to that. And quite frankly, the only time I recall after that of you voting mafia in all dem posts was CmP in Mafia: Basic. Since the game didn't end and he wasn't lynched, that didn't register in my head as you voting mafia.

Finally, I am just getting MUCH too tired argueing. I'm not a very arguementive guy usually. I tend to stray away from them. You can see why. My tiny little brain needs some rest now. So, lets leave it as is, with you having the final arguement and see how the town takes it k?

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

I did the best I could defending myself agaisnt you. My first game of Mafia was SOL: Mafia. So I did not know of your history prior to that. And quite frankly, the only time I recall after that of you voting mafia in all dem posts was CmP in Mafia: Basic. Since the game didn't end and he wasn't lynched, that didn't register in my head as you voting mafia.

Finally, I am just getting MUCH too tired argueing. I'm not a very arguementive guy usually. I tend to stray away from them. You can see why. My tiny little brain needs some rest now. So, lets leave it as is, with you having the final arguement and see how the town takes it k?

God, I don't know how to take this.

A townie just not caring anymore since they feel convicted, or a mafia setting that up as a last ditch effort.

If someone else can make some good of what B_Real has done, I might remove my vote. These last ditch things always grind my nerves and regarding them is pointless, thus defeating how I play and going to gut feeling, which I don't trust my gut feeling because it isn't stated with facts...

Confusion is here.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

K!

So all catlover has to do is stay shut up today and I'm a goner to you? That makes sense, in a very twisted way, but still makes sense.

NINJA'd By Mesden: ALright, Mesden. I give up. I'm just gonna go with you're right and I'm wrong. This is becoming to much of a strain on my mind. I'm just gonna sit and see where the town goes from here.

UNVOTE: MESDEN
VOTE: B_REAL:p

Are you fucking serious?

You're giving up because she caught you in your own argument?

I mean, pardon my language, but if you give up that easily, you obviously don't want to play that much. If you can't handle somebody evaluating your posts in a game where that's the main objective, maybe you shouldn't be playing. I'm going to quit this now, because this is quickly degenerating into a flame.

I apologize for any offense, but are you serious with that? I mean, come on! If you're not guilty, prove it. Show your defense, answer all points presented to you (instead of the ones that are convenient) and don't give up because you think you can't win.

EDIT: You completely blew off this post. Now answer it.