Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[OctoberRaven]

"It" as in the public post, or the PM that was supposedly sent by Darth?

[DarthMauler64]

*returns*

To clarify what I meant about h4x

Originally Posted by DarthMauler64

There is that possibility that we are wasting a lynch, but I feel that h4x is lying. I guess to be safe we could have someone else kill him at night and lynch someone else today.

I will keep my vote on h4x though in case the deadline hits and no one has voted yet thus even wasting confirming h4x.

EDIT(To Axl): Maybe. Ask Fenris. If it can and we do it then it can that prove your telling the truth too.

I didn't want to waste a night kill on h4x if we lynched him and he stopped it, I said that if we didn't want to risk lynching him we could lynch someone else and kill him at night instead.

I kept my vote on h4x because I didn't know when the deadline was and wanted to make sure that we lynched someone.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by OctoberRaven

"It" as in the public post, or the PM that was supposedly sent by Darth?

It as in the PM that was sent by Darth.

[OctoberRaven]

Hm. Had the mod simply said "the PM" I would have questioned whether Darth sent it, but that answers that then.

[Rygar]

Originally Posted by Moogle0119

Vote: Rygar Come on down! You're our next contestant!

Well trying to lynch me will have about the same effect as the current course of action (assuming h4x's roleclaim is true, which it mightn't be. Unlynchable Townie is a pretty good role to claim to try and deter an opposition that doesn't want to waste time) as I'm the Pacifist, Town Aligned and I can stop a lynch once (and yes, I do realise the same argument could be used for me lying as I just used).

My main reason for actually posting is I don't want to be an inactive anymore.
Or I want to try not to be, it's easier said than done for me.

Oh, what the hell, I probably have no idea what's really going on in this game anyway.

[h4x.m4g3]

Originally Posted by DarthMauler64

I am back!

I believe Jer's role somewhat, because he has the flavor text to back him up somewhat, because Doppler was found in a trashcan instead of dead somewhere. Also, I wasn't really suspicious of townies without powers, I was suspicious of townies with powers that don't help the town. But, since I belive you right now...

UnSlightFOS: Jer

Just curious, SS, how do you know for certain that one of the militia hasn't been culted?

The person I think has the highest chance of being the CL(besides the ones that haven't said anything) is h4x.
1) His role name is rather bland with all of these other names. He is possibly lying.

I deleted the pm with my role when I was cleaning out my inbox a while back, the game started over a month ago and I didn't think/consider/remember to uncheck it. I think my name was Commuter or some such, as I remember the description to be something about me leaving town before the lynch, thereby making me unlynchble, however scum could follow me leave. Note: That is paraphrased to the best of my memory.

2) His power doesn't help the town at all, it only helps himself.

When the cult has enough people to sway votes I'd beg to differ. It also lets me shoot from the hip without fear of the town lynching me. But I don't shoot from the hip, just lie in wait for someone to slip up then go after them.

3) He claims he has been watching the thread, but not posting much.

Which is true, and what I always do.

4) If he turns out to be unlynchable, we can be sure he is not the CL and we have another revealed townie to help us.

And the cult has another inductee to use against us. And with one mafia revealed I would like that not to happen.

Now if you guys would really like to waste a lynch on me go ahead, I know it won't kill me. But I'd like to point that after tonight if we don't hit at least a cultist the cult will be nearly 1/3 of the town.

[DarthMauler64]

Hmmmm....I guess I'll believe you for now, since you addressed all of my points well.

Unvote: h4x

However, I'm still very slightly suspicious about you.

So who should we look at next? I say banana.

Vote: banana

[bananarama]

*sigh* I really don't this turn of events. No I'm not referring to the votes against me (I am really surprised this hasn't happened sooner really). But all these roleclaims... All this is doing is giving people a chance to lie without even being put on pressure and also it allows for Cult and Mafia to know who and who not to cult/kill. Anyway, as I mentioned before I'm a Vanilla Townie so I really have no way to prove it. Also, the reason why I stopped posting here is the sheer amount of roleclaims is making my brain BLEED!

Anyway, I am holding suspicions about this whole massive "twist everybody's arm to roleclaim" game. Now I have a hypothesis (that's all I can do really ...). The survivors of Condatino Mafia are already culted. With that in hand, a Cult Leader can assume a role without anyone in the Mafia speaking against him. Then, he can easily say, "Hey we are already screwed so we want help you townies out." Them. he suddenly starts making accusations toward everyone on PB's list to get info on some of the remaining roles he doesn't know about while town is all "Gosh! Condatino family is so nice! Now let's all wander about aimlessly as we reveal our roles and get everyone else to roleclaim!" So great plan, huh? I am looking at you.... Moogle...

FOS: Moogle0119
FOS: DM64 (the fact that you so readily join in Moog's game to the point that you even named it first even though he is (supposedly) mafia and you're town, leads me to believe that you're either in cahoots with Moog (Read: culted) or extremely eager and gullible)

Also, I am not voting because I admit this is a really far-fetched idea so I'd really, really appreciate if a PO could investigate Moogs. Yes while this is a far-fetched, I'd like to think of this as a possibility until we have further confirmation from a PO.

[Ryanderman]

Originally Posted by bananarama

Also, I am not voting because I admit this is a really far-fetched idea so I'd really, really appreciate if a PO could investigate Moogs. Yes while this is a far-fetched, I'd like to think of this as a possibility until we have further confirmation from a PO.

I don't think it's far fetched at all. I've been worried about this since the second Condatino role claimed. I'm leaning towards voting for Moogle at the moment. Won't do it yet though.

[Moogle0119]

Right now bananarama I think you have far less credibility than you try to make yourself sound like you deserve. You have no evidence and no claims to back up and you're just merely pointing a finger at one of the 2 remaining mafias saying "Geez you guys are cult". I've already stated numerous times that I came out to stop both cults and luckily I managed to help take down one. Yeah I was on the verge of dying anyway, but if I had been culted why would I help reveal the rest of our mafia even after one of the cults were taken out? If we weren't scared of losing to a much BIGGER threat (the cults) why would I even bother with any of it and just let my sacrifice be as it is? Plus nobody has countered any of our roleclaims so that should be proof enough that we are all who we say we are.

I'm not pretending to be another sheep amongst the rest of the herd (town) I very much am scum but I am not culted scum. After tomorrow though all bets are off on who is and isn't culted. The CL could go for one of our mafia in hopes to control our night kills, or they could go after one of the POs to send out false reports on people and have them killed off. Hence the reasoning why we need roleclaims today to root people out and I find it very odd that you're just a plain old vanilla townie while everyone else has at least some flavor text to their role. My vote stays with bananarama for now.

Edit: Forgot I had voted for Rygar previously...

Unvote: Rygar
Vote: bananarama