Dragonlance Mafia

[P-Sleazy]

Originally Posted by Akamaz

I dunno, looking over the voting, B-Real seems to be coming across as scummy. I mean, if we have any ideas of who is mafia, we should be pointing out these reasons and helping each other out.

Hey now. I said that cause I got exams (one left w00t!) to do so I can't spend god knows how many hours looking into this game for evidence to save someone whom I think is townie (and I may be mistaken aswell so theres less reason for me to be forceful about it) and has a rather weak case against him. If something jumped out at me, I mentioned it, but I don't have the time to pick out every little nuance. So thats why I told Petunia's to stop relying on me to save his hide and to do something about it, especially if things kept goin the way they were goin, he was going to die. And he's still fairly close, but I still think he needs to do something on his own to save himself.

I'm one of those people who play a game where if you don't atleast TRY to save yourself, you deserve to die. Up until his last post, I didn't really see him trying.

EDIT: Fixed typos in Bold

[Roy_D_Mylote]

He does actually have exams, his school's don't finish until Tuesday, I believe.

So.

[Captain Combustible]

I've read this over and I just noticed this about Nikose, he and Ecurts actions on day one seem strangely similar.Nikose Self vote, Ecurts response, Another seemingly pointless post, Ecurts self vote, A post at deadline. The last post he specifically only says Ecurt out of the 6 people who hadn't voted was going to be the tiebraker and seems to assume ecurt is town, he randomly chooses ecurt out of everyone to direct many of his day one posts. Most of his day one posts were just random useless stuff and I don't think Nikose is trying to add to the discussion.
HOS: Nikose

[Nikose Tyris]

And notice that Ecurt didn't listen whatsoever and utterly ignored me? there's no tie between myself and Ecurt. in fact, I was mostly testing the waters against Ecurt to see what he really was- And yeah, I noticed he acting similar to me too. My posts are never random though, CC- You know that. That's my silliness, yes, but if you're one of the people that chats with me regularly online, you'll see that I'm qouting the song "Knife Fight" in the fight to the death, and purposely making things silly to make sure nothing bad happens, like flaring tempers. I've been bad for being rude and bossy in Mafia games lately, and I'm attempting to rectify that now.

Also, after careful study, I don't see 42 as being scummy enough, DESPITE all the evidence that Newb has shown. In fact, 42 is a better player than he has been today, and I don't like that- something's up but I can't put my finger on it.

so, "UNVOTE: 42", and I'll keep watching for my final action.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Nikose Tyris

Also, after careful study, I don't see 42 as being scummy enough, DESPITE all the evidence that Newb has shown. In fact, 42 is a better player than he has been today, and I don't like that- something's up but I can't put my finger on it.

I'm a better player when I'm not a Mafiate than when I am a Mafiate.

Being a Mafiate makes it harder to be a ruthless bastard, although I still try. Look at the Themeless Mafia on TGC when I had to go look out for Roy.

[Nikose Tyris]

While you make a good point- He said: "I can't vote" And intallicized it. I think he was trying to convey a message about something.

"The Mentalist: The mentalist is one player who has absolute control over what another player does. The controlled player cannot post anything without the consent of the mentalist. The controled player will have no knowledge of who the mentalist is. The mentalist MUST change the player he/she controls every night. When the mentalist changes players, the GO will roll a d4. If the GO rolls a 1, the mentalist dies. If 2-4, the mentalist goes on to the next player. The mentalist wins when he, and the player he's controling are the only players left(note: the controled player at the end does NOT win)."

Is it possible he's being controlled? and if so, I don't want to vote him to discover if the mentalist kills whoever he was inhabiting as he leaves them.

[Lord of Joshelplex]

Man, being the mentalist's bitch must suck. He says he "cant" vote, he must be being controlled.

[P-Sleazy]

Its probably very likely that 42 is going to die tongiht if he's being controlled by the mentalist, considering the victory condition of the mentalist being him and the last person alive as opposed to just him alone being the last man standing, and the fact that theres a fairly good chance of the mentalist dieing himself when changing people. They could both go either way for deciding whether the mentalist kills or not.

So, Nikose does bring up a good point. If you leave 42 alive, and assuming the assumption that he's being controlled by the mentalist is correct, then we'll find out a little bit as to how the mentalist works as per whether he kills people when he changes.

[Moogle0119]

I'd rather get rid of the Mentalist since they seem to be self-aligned rather than town-aligned. The whole "I can't vote does seem to stand out now that I look at it and it does make sense as to why 42 has been acting differently today. I would also prefer to leave the Mentalist out of this since things can get really confusing with people suddenly acting and voting differently because they are being controlled. Even if all this is not true I still suspect 42 of being scum mainly through the evidence that Newb posted which really shed a lot of light on the matter

Vote: 42

[Bailey]

While I have my doubts that that's the exact role being used here, Nikose DOES bring up a good possibility.

I'm going to have to think about this. unvote: 42

As for other things which have caught my eye...

vote: Lord Josh because he posted what... twice before? And each was a one-line thing saying he was suspicious of Nikose without any content whatsoever. And now he posts without content again.

Anybody else think that if there IS a "Mother-may-I" role it's him, considering the significant lack of posting from both him and the person who stands the best chance of having been controlled yesterday?

EDIT: Oh hey, it probably would have helped to read the rules post. That IS the exact role being used here.