Death Note Mafia

[OctoberRaven]

I doubt it's a mentalist, myself. I think B_Real is grasping for straws.

[Demonlink2]

Secret rules are crazy, but I agree with October. Mentalists would be fools to reveal themselves early, and I think B_Real the scummiest there is currently, unless Nayno maintains his insanity.

Vote: B_Real unless Nayno acts like a complete idiot.

[P-Sleazy]

You realize I'm gonna be laughing in my grave when it turns out that Nayno dies tonight. Cause the deathnote controls people's actions (in the case of mafia, their votes much like a mentalist!) and if Nayno can't reveal WHY he's voting then its only natural to assume that Kira wrote his name in the deathnote with a death date later on in the game and he's having him vote me today through the control he has with the deathnote.

[Aerozord]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

You realize I'm gonna be laughing in my grave when it turns out that Nayno dies tonight. Cause the deathnote controls people's actions (in the case of mafia, their votes much like a mentalist!) and if Nayno can't reveal WHY he's voting then its only natural to assume that Kira wrote his name in the deathnote with a death date later on in the game and he's having him vote me today through the control he has with the deathnote.

well if that is true, and kira is also town alligned, then that would mean kira views you as a threat to the town, thus you are still a viable target. Granted that would mean those against the town would like to keep you safe, but that doesn't seem too likely since if everyone is targetting you then they are safe for the day

Now I'm not saying that kira would be right, just saying there isn't a reason for kira to control someone in an attempt kill a townie. However I doubt that is whats happening since arguably if you were lynched then he would be taking you with him when he dies, and thats a no no.

[P-Sleazy]

argueably, He probably foresaw this happen too. As soon as I saw Rygar's vote on me, and then night followed right after I knew I would get screwed over by one or more people killing Rygar. And for Kira, his ultimate goal is to catch the detectives M and N from finding out who he is. And I think we can all agree that Kira=bad in the anime.

[Pink Bunny]

My goodness, here we have Town Supporters of Kira and you go and attempt to make town agree that he's bad. Shameless, B. Shameless.

[Captain Combustible]

FoS: B_real, the vanilla townies in this game are called supporters of Kira so I am guessing Kira is town. I won't place a vote because I don't know how many votes you currently have on you.

[Pink Bunny]

Actually as I just went up to episode 11 now I'm rethinking something I said prior. Yes, town are supporters of Kira, this is true. But in the anime they are as such. He has huge internet websites and such devoted to him and cheering him on; Light didn't call himself Kira, his supporters and fans, the Townspeople, invented this alias for him.

So regardless of Kira's actions or alignment, yeah, Town would still be Supporters. I'll give B_Real that.

[Death by Stabbing]

There's only one way to find out if some one is a mafiate or not...it's to lynch them. And if we're wrong then we try again...let's just pick some one

[OctoberRaven]

I agree DBS. Let's start with B_Real_Scum.

He's obviously anti-Kira, and, logically not a Kira supporter, and therefore a Mafiate.

Furthermore, the Death Note cannot control minds to do impossible actions. If Nayno says you're scum now it means he probably would say so even if he wasn't controlled. The "Secret Rule" thing can mean anything for all we know. Maybe he wins if he lynches L, and he thinks you are L.