Soldiers of Light: Mafia

[Bailey]

Well IOWACJE, I'm tempted to just post it right before the deadline is up, but I don't know if it'll really be ready by then.
14 12 29 19 9
I guess I'll just have to hope the mafia has fish that they think are bigger to fry.

EDIT: grammatical

[TheSpacePope]

So it may be iowa, Newbs spreadsheet might make him a target, however the mafia knows that we are ALL keeping track, so would that make Newb more dangerous than any of us that are paying attention?
that's kind of fishy that you'd plant that thought there.
Not fingering (giggle) you just wondering why you think that Newb is the main target, spreadsheet aside.

[Mondt]

Originally Posted by TheSpacePope

What I can't figure out is why everyone thinks that it was a joke is a great excuse. It's not.
This is not a vote, I just want to hear why you guys think that "it was a joke" is a great defense.

*shakes with rage*

Simply put, that wasn't part of the game itself. I'm using my common sense to try to tell everyone that it was a joke. I could say, "Hey, you don't want yo vote for me. You know why? Because I'm sk3L3t0n! That's why." and it would obviously be a joke with the only relation to the real game being the reference of a vote. That's it.

It's not suppsoed to be a defense, rather a declaration that it shouldn't be used as a reason to vote for Ahrha, as IHMN accusing the GO of cheating wasn't either.

[TheSpacePope]

I haven't voted for anyone, I just want to know why you thinkn that it WAS in fact an offhanded comment, I know you said it was common sense, and I believe you, so I lift my FoS on you, however Ahra has still not come out and explained the "joke" so I am really suspicious. And TWG I am putting my eye on silly kitty, just for the sake that you seem to think like I do, so you must have seen something that I am missing.

[Silly Kitty]

Originally Posted by The_Wandering_God

As CmP would point out, a No Lynch vote is very bad. Also... look at the second sentence. There is no way to know how or why the Mafia hit MoM. She directly implies that it is people from the last game. And what does this do? Starts an argument that doesn't actually lead anywhere. It also confuses the new people.

I did not start that argument. That was CMP who first stated this. CMP or Fenris.

And yet, didn't unvote your No Lynch yet. Possible reason: leaving it up so others skimming for votes would see that and vote no lynch too. And how did SK say there were no leads when she said it was "probably people from the last mafia"?

As Fenris stated later in the game, I forgot to do that. And when I said there were no leads I realized none of the mafia people from last game are playing this game.

Now she shifts into DarthMauler defense mode.

I believed and still believe in his innocence.

Now she FoS's me. Important note: This is after I unvoted for the person that she had been defending. I smell something rotten. Oh, and she finally unvotes the No Lynch after someone else notices it.

I didn't notice I didn't unvote. I thought you were acting suspicious. Obviously others thought this two because you got hit three times(twice by two townies).

But I had already unvoted him? Bad feeling with nothing to go on? Wow, lobbing an accusation based on a feeling that you already can't back up?

I just don't trust you. That is all I have to say.

Defending another person. And, of course, now she won't need to vote for IHMN, because I'm sure he had pissed off enough townies to where the mafia didn't need to do much about it.

I never intended to vote for IHMN. Just because he called the GO a cheater is not a reason to lynch him. I guess I do defend people too much...

Or not. What happened? Well, at 7:24am Rhiya Ravenwing, made the first mention of me being the CL. Your post above "Wow, I fell really...." was at 4:24 in the pm. Then, this latest post was at 6:41. Well over 2 hours later. What happened? I think the mafia wanted to start a ball of suspicion rolling so that the BG would doubt protecting me in the next round, making for an easy kill. And even if they didn't do it, the imposter might.

I had not read Rhiya's post before I made this post. I read the night post and posted my first comment. After awhile I went back and read all the posts and I thought Rhiya had a good point. I'm never called you the CL I just said it was a possibility.

That's exactly what you are doing. Trying to cast doubt on me so the BG won't protect me again. Oh, who else wants to tell the BG what to do? Newb.

I am not trying to get you killed. I was just trying to point out that as a town we cannot totally rule you out. I'm sorry if I'm wrong but I think we have to look at all possibilities.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by The_Wandering_God

That's exactly what you are doing. Trying to cast doubt on me so the BG won't protect me again. Oh, who else wants to tell the BG what to do? Newb.

That's a little selfish of you. Maybe somebody else might need protection more than you.

[The Wandering God]

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

I did not start that argument. That was CMP who first stated this. CMP or Fenris.

As Fenris stated later in the game, I forgot to do that. And when I said there were no leads I realized none of the mafia people from last game are playing this game.

I believed and still believe in his innocence.

I didn't notice I didn't unvote. I thought you were acting suspicious. Obviously others thought this two because you got hit three times(twice by two townies).
I just don't trust you. That is all I have to say.

I never intended to vote for IHMN. Just because he called the GO a cheater is not a reason to lynch him. I guess I do defend people too much...

I had not read Rhiya's post before I made this post. I read the night post and posted my first comment. After awhile I went back and read all the posts and I thought Rhiya had a good point. I'm never called you the CL I just said it was a possibility.

I am not trying to get you killed. I was just trying to point out that as a town we cannot totally rule you out. I'm sorry if I'm wrong but I think we have to look at all possibilities.

First off, I apologize about who said it first.

Second, how can you be so convinced of DarthMauler's innocence, but not mine?

Third, explain this please, "Obviously others thought this two because you got hit three times (twice by two townies).

Fourth, I didn't vote for IHMN names either.

Fifth, suggesting that I could be the CL is as good as calling me that. Specifically, you said, "may in fact be the CL." You still haven't answered my arguments against it. Namely the fact that if I was the CL, drawing as much attention as I obviously did would be really stupid. There is such a thing as the common sense defence. I acknowledged in my very first post I'd be drawing attention to myself with my FoS. So noone could later point it out as "suspcious behavior". It's hardly suspicious to announce my activites to the temple at large.

Moving on

Originally Posted by FenrisWolf

That's a little selfish of you. Maybe somebody else might need protection more than you.

Like the PO or Vig right? Okay, since it's quite obvious who they are, no problem, right? Right?

As of right now, I'm the only person in this town who is known not to be either a mafiate or the imposter. And as much as certain elements would like you to believe otherwise, I'm not the CL either.

The mafia and imposter see me as a threat. Can you think of anyone else who would need that protection more right now?

The Wandering God

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by The_Wandering_God

The mafia and imposter see me as a threat. Can you think of anyone else who would need that protection more right now?

Yes, like the PO or the Vig, which you clearly are not either. And you are not known to be a mafiate. For all we know, the Mafia ordered a hit on a member.

Maybe you pissed off your don.

Maybe you're a cultist. You seem waaaaay too focused on SK to be keeping your options open, which is much more useful than focusing on one person, unless you are 100% sure of their guilt.

And I, based on past events, believe you're guilty.

Vote: The_Wandering_God

[Bailey]

Actually, I can. I'm not going to say who because that would be anti-helpful to the town, but so far as I can see, you aren't the only important recognizable person.

EDIT: Fenris, the hell are you doing?

Do you have any idea how supremely self-defeating that would be for the Don to order a hit on a mafiate?

I mean really, I've heard some weird arguments, but this?

And can we get back to focusing on Arhra now?

Darn people drawing the focus away from Arhra, our likeliest candidate for mafiahood thus far.

[Silly Kitty]

Second, how can you be so convinced of DarthMauler's innocence, but not mine?

Because, Darth mauler made a simple innocent mistake and I did something similar so I just felt a better connection with that.

Third, explain this please, "Obviously others thought this two because you got hit three times (twice by two townies).

The vig and the imposter.

Fifth, suggesting that I could be the CL is as good as calling me that. Specifically, you said, "may in fact be the CL." You still haven't answered my arguments against it. Namely the fact that if I was the CL, drawing as much attention as I obviously did would be really stupid. There is such a thing as the common sense defence. I acknowledged in my very first post I'd be drawing attention to myself with my FoS. So noone could later point it out as "suspcious behavior". It's hardly suspicious to announce my activites to the temple at large.

Some people have hidden in day light before. I'm sorry for suggesting you could be the CL. I just didn't want everyone to completely rule you out because you could be the CL. I could be the CL. Anyone could be the CL.