Mafia: Bleach

[Truce]

Originally Posted by GARUD

Well, when you go after someone like you did, you could get multiple results from going after that person, usually depending on the result. Now, the reason that I say that, is because the person who replaced Mesden turns out to not be any mafia member. So that could mean two things. You are a misguided townie, or Mafia. Plus, you would know that Mesden and Sithdarth are quite a deadly combination as townies, so you had one killed in the first night, and it was attempted to be pinned on the other during the day. That night also, Ol' Dude almost got killed, and, surprise surprise, you were one of the two people who voted for her.

Now, I know I did vote for her, but honestly, I was going on a gut feeling. I had no real solid evidence, so I was ready to take off my vote if something counter-suspicious arose. Hope it cleared things up. I still suspect you though so my vote remains.

Now, this assumes a lot GARUD. First, you're assuming that I considered both Mesden and Sithdarth powerful townies. I can assure you this, I've only considered SK to be a powerful player, because she has an amazing record of finding roles. Sithdarth in particular has done nothing spectacular aside from making a big post and using statistics; neither really led to anything, as far as I can remember.

Second, it assumes that I would go through all that trouble trying to lynch someone, only to just kill them at night and immediately put me in the spotlight. It'd have been much better to leave Ole Dude alive, after all-why wouldn't the Mafia try to kill off a role? Because it was one of them. It was even hinted that the role might be Mafia.

That's what I would have done, especially since it wouldn't leave a trail towards me.

Third, it assumes that I tried to pin Sithdarth's death on Mesden. I never tried any such thing; in fact, it was you that did that here.

Also, if you ask me, "gut feelings" are much more suspicious than giving out reasons. For you, it would be a veil to hide behind as you tried to lynch a "powerful townie."

And now...you're my biggest suspect. Vote: GARUD

[Roy_D_Mylote]

As much as it goes against my gut feeling, having re-read the thread, I'm gonna unvote: Arhra because 1. He claims something bad will happen if he's lynched and 2. It is POSSIBLE, I suppose, to skip over some posts or just forget. Even though I'm still sore at him for voting for me for no reason. But who to vote for? Newb seems to be a prime runner, although I suspect Ole Dude is mafia. But the mafia targetted him, you say? Well, I think maybe the Mafia actually targetted Fenris, who happened to be imitating Ole dude.

It's a stretch, I know, but like I said, I'm not voting for them.

[Ryanderman]

Just addressing this:

Originally Posted by Roy_D_Mylote

I suspect Ole Dude is mafia. But the mafia targetted him, you say? Well, I think maybe the Mafia actually targetted Fenris, who happened to be imitating Ole dude.

with

Originally Posted by Fenris

Okie, I just'll tell y'all this.

Since I imitated somebody at night, I couldn't die if targetted. But, they targetted who I imitated, so, I go "Blarg."

*Returns to going "Blarg"*

The Mafia definitely targeted Ole dude.

[Major Blood]

Originally Posted by Roy_D_Mylote

Well, I think maybe the Mafia actually targetted Fenris, who happened to be imitating Ole dude.

I agree. It's entirely possible that the mafia targeted Fenris, who was imitating Ole dude. Though it is still more likely that the mafia targeted Ole Dude because he had a secret role(or not, we don't know if Mesden was lying or not) and got Fenris instead.

[Roy_D_Mylote]

Originally Posted by Ryanderman

The Mafia definitely targeted Ole dude.

Uh, no? The Vig targetted Ole dude, in my scenario, and killed his imposter. The mafia didn't kill him.

[Ryanderman]

Originally Posted by Silly Kitty

It was a quiet night, as Fenris: Shihouin Yoruichi, "The imitator" Shinigami-Aligned walked along. He kept his clothes in an unusual fashion, which gave the impression he was Ole' Dude With the Face. As he walked along, he could hear whispers from coming from 5 people. "Kill him." One came from behind. "Rip out his entrails." Another said. That was all Fenris needed to hear as he took off running, trying to get away.

He turned a corner, he could hear himself gaining distance away from the voices. He took a second to look back behind him, not seeing a blade whip out in front of him. Letting Fenris' frantic speed do the cutting, Fenris' head was taken out with a clean cut. Their target dead, everyone retreated back into hiding, as dawn slowly broke out over the land.

Don't see what's so hard about this. Both the Mafia and the Vig targeted Ole Dude. Since Fenris was imitating him, he took the hit from both. In my previous post, I quoted Fenris as saying that he could not be targeted as himself when imitating someone else, meaning that if the mafia had targeted him, they wouldn't have factored in this way into the story, as they wouldn't have been able to find him.

EDIT to add a bit more clarification, edited part in italics

[Roy_D_Mylote]

Fenris could be targetted. He just couldn't be killed if so.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Roy_D_Mylote

Fenris could be targetted. He just couldn't be killed if so.

Yeah.


Ryan: I was targetted by the Mafia, Ole Dude by the vig.

"Blarg."

[Ryanderman]

Originally Posted by FenrisWolf

Yeah.


Ryan: I was targetted by the Mafia, Ole Dude by the vig.

"Blarg."

Really? Huh, I and I was so sure the death story had some relavence and ruled that out. My mistake, I withdraw all objections to Roy's theory.

EDIT: ok, I guess the death story could also be read the way it happened. I just read it incorrectly.

[Silly Kitty]

Vote Count

Ecurt(1)
Garud

Arhra(5)
Newb
Demonlink
Ole' Dude With The Face
Elbodo
IHMN

IHMN(1)
IC

Newb(7)
Arhra
B_Real_Shadows
Ryanderman
Cephrir
Hax mage
Mr. G
Nikose

12 TO LYNCH. NO DEADLINE YET.