Basic Roles Mafia

[Nikose Tyris]

Almost, except for one thing.

It's B_real_shadows. He dies night 1. It's pretty much like a rule.

[Skyshot]

Vote: Fifthfiend

Because he's expressed disgust with the game and he's suddenly playing anyways.

Skyshot, you can't play. You're not on the list.

Such a discriminatory group of people, you discriminating discrimators advocating discrimination.

[42PETUNIAS]

Skyshot, you can't play. You're not on the list.
C'mon Fenris, I know you're reading this, let's see some serious mod action here

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by 42PETUNIAS

C'mon Fenris, I know you're reading this, let's see some serious mod action here

It was funny and I have a sense of humor.

[Nique]

Oh oh I'm late to the par-tay!

I've played 100s of live Mafia games guys, and I'm telling you that it is in the townies best interest to vote 'no lynch' the first round. That way, we avoid dwindling our numbers right away, or also guilt over killing one of our own, and the inevitable murder will give us clues to preform some hard-core lynching after this round.

Vote: No lynch

[Captain Combustible]

and heres a vote count:

Mr.Bookworm-5(42PETUNIAS,B_real,fifthfiend,majorblood,sheb)

b_real-2(Ogianres,Nikose)

MajorBlood-1(Mr.Bookworm)

Nikose-1(Ecurt)

No Lynch-1(Nique)

not voting-Lost Prophet, Death By Stabbing

edit: the town is discussing who is scummy when you see skyshot run in, you all gather in a mob and beat him to a pulp, Skyshot, Corpse Aligned Corpse is now dead. it is still day one, 7 to lynch

edit2: yes, even though skyshot was never in this game he is dead now.

[Fifthfiend]

So what's up now, we're required to get seven votes one way or another before the day can proceed?

yes, even though skyshot was never in this game he is dead now.

That's what I call problem-solving.

[Captain Combustible]

Originally Posted by fifthfiend

So what's up now, we're required to get seven votes one way or another before the day can proceed?



That's what I call problem-solving.

day will end when either a majority is reached and whoever has most votes is lynched (or in case of no lynch night will begin without a death) or a deadline is reached and whoever has the most votes is lynched. It is still day one 7 to lynch, There is no deadline yet.

edit: I am going to have to PM DBS and LostProphet if they don't post soon and replace them if they don't show up at all

[Truce]

No Lynch does not get us anywhere, Nique.

There are 3 mafia members out of a total of 12 players. Should we lynch someone, we have a 1/4 chance of getting a mafia member. It doesn't seem that high, but it's a lot better than no chance at all; which is what happens if we don't lynch someone.

It's true that we'll have more people tomorrow if we don't lynch someone, but the mafia is still closer to their goal. The clue we may get may turn out to be a red herring; or worse, we might misread it at all. We're taking a chance now at killing someone without any idea who it is, but we're taking a chance every time we vote to lynch someone anyway.

That said, and I've thought about it for a while, the case against Mr. Bookworm is the strongest right now. Voting for fifthfiend aside, asking the PO to investigate you isn't something that most townies would want. Whether or not he's a mafia member, drawing out the PO so soon would help the mafia more than it would help us.

It could also be a ploy. If we don't lynch him, and another person shows up saying he's not mafia, there's a chance that both of them are mafia members, with the other person pretending to be the PO. With no way of verifying the truth ourselves, we'd either have to lynch Mr. Bookworm anyway to be sure, or or just trust them completely; something that isn't easy to do.

If nobody does show up, then Bookworm could use that as an excuse to say that the PO didn't show up, so he isn't mafia. Not the strongest of arguments, but if we do lynch him to be sure we'd just have wasted a day.

Even if he is a townie, continuing in the game will just leave him under suspicion.

Unvote: Nikose
FOS: Nikose
Vote: Mr. Bookworm

[Nique]

It's true that we'll have more people tomorrow if we don't lynch someone, but the mafia is still closer to their goal.

Look, if we lynch now, we almost definatly loose two townies immediatly. It is 3/4 chance of voting out one of our own, as you said. It may not "get us anywhere" now, but if we keep townie numbers high, we have longer to figure out who is in the mafia. Right now we're shooting in the dark.

I'm not willing to let two people go that easily. Lynchings are a double-eged sword becuase the Mafia can use them too. So until we get a clue, I say we don't let the mafia gain any ground by possibly preforming an erronious lynch.