Soldiers of Light: Mafia

[Bailey]

And with that, I think I've got all the roles pegged.

I might be wrong, so I'm going to wait a bit longer, but I'm pretty sure I've got it all.

Incidentally, I think that TWG is the newest cult initiate, but since this just means he gets to talk to JudasPreistFan and is no longer allowed to win, I don't particularly care much.

[Ferix Stader]

Inbred Chocobo: I leave Opera open when I walk off. That way I don't need to bother logging back on again (trust NO cookies). Yes, my browser was at this thread - but it hadn't refreshed since about 6:00. I refreshed, saw all the posts before Mesden's, posted mine, saw hers (bad timing, irritatingly), but left it up (wasn't sure if she would want it deleted) until she PM'd me as such. Once I got the PM, I deleted it immediately.

Believe me, I see why it's suspicious. However, it's a habit I have (apparently one I need to break). I simply find it more convenient to be able to sit down and immediately click refresh, then be able to post (on a 56k, every second wasted is irritating), then to wait while it does the login song-and-dance.

Alright. The two people I have under suspicion for CmP's death are:

Ecurt
The SSB Intern

Ecurt believed that CmP was behaving suspiciously during Round 1, and voted for him during that round. However, he voted for only FenrisWolf during the second round, making no other notable action.

The SSB Intern voted for TWG during the second round, and was FoS'd by CmP for that. It is possible that either of these two wanted CmP dead because of the attention. Of course, it could be for some, completely unrelated reason, and these two are coincedental - but I'm still eyeing these two.

As for attacking FenrisWolf... ...Newb, if I didn't have you pegged as another Townie, I'd be slightly suspicious (would have to go back to find the post, but it doesn't matter). However, I'm 95% sure you're Town-aligned, so I'm looking at other possible threats.

The problem is, as said earlier, most everyone thought Fenris was a threat.

Thus, I'm filing this away for further study - I just don't feel we have enough yet to investigate him.

EDIT: IOWACJE: Once SK spotted that hint, I don't think anyone bothered defending him. Beforehand? I think everyone was either ambivalent on his part or accusing him of being Mafia. SK, the one person who clearly defended him (so far as I remember), was the one who spotted the clue and notified us. So I think she's safe.

[Mesden]

Due to lack of posting, Druidal is being replaced by Ole Dude with the face.

RedMageBlack has been removed from the game. He was a Townie, Town alligned.

[Truce]

In my defence, if I had killed CmP that would make me either a mafiate or the vigilante since Fenris' killer had to have been the imposter (the clues being that it wasn't Tayuumi that attacked, and that it was a singular person). I know I'm definately not a mafiate; if I were I wouldn't have tried to vote off DarthMauler64 (the only confirmed Mafiate) in the first round before I tried to vote off CmP. If I was the vigilante, the town wouldn't want to lynch me anyway, but I'm not that either since I wouldn't have gone after TWG in the first round if I were since I didn't find him suspicious.

Also, the reason I didn't change my vote from Fenris to DarthMauler64 is the same reason as TWG's for not doing it either, the same as Fenris voted for himself and the same reason I didn't change my vote to SSB Intern for when he just repeated the same stupidity that Fenris did. I thought he was already dead.

[The Wandering God]

Originally Posted by Newb

And with that, I think I've got all the roles pegged.

I might be wrong, so I'm going to wait a bit longer, but I'm pretty sure I've got it all.

Incidentally, I think that TWG is the newest cult initiate, but since this just means he gets to talk to JudasPreistFan and is no longer allowed to win, I don't particularly care much.

We don't know for sure if CmP would be allowed one last recruit. As it stands, I doubt he would have picked me as my time in this game is a miracle to me.

Lost a lot of townies though, due to various happenings.

Well, I must say, after I found out that DarthMauler was indeed a mafiate (like I had said from the beginning I might add), I tried to see who had the most involvement. And who did I find voting for GARUD to get him to unvote DarthMauler?

SecretSkull.

And who didn't vote for DarthMauler, and tried to argue his innocence?

SecretSkull

And who did he try to peg instead? Newb, who had him on his list as a mafiate.

For these reasons: Vote: SecretSkull

The Wandering God

[Major Blood]

Originally Posted by The_Wandering_God

We don't know for sure if CmP would be allowed one last recruit. As it stands, I doubt he would have picked me as my time in this game is a miracle to me.

Lost a lot of townies though, due to various happenings.

Well, I must say, after I found out that DarthMauler was indeed a mafiate (like I had said from the beginning I might add), I tried to see who had the most involvement. And who did I find voting for GARUD to get him to unvote DarthMauler?

SecretSkull.

And who didn't vote for DarthMauler, and tried to argue his innocence?

SecretSkull

And who did he try to peg instead? Newb, who had him on his list as a mafiate.

For these reasons: Vote: SecretSkull

The Wandering God

That may all be because CmP wanted to get Darthmauler into the cult. SO it stand to reason that Newb may also be in the cult and wanted to protect him so he would be inducted. But this is just pure speculation. I like your explanation better.

Vote: SecretSkull

[catlover20410]

Vote:SSB Intern

Trying to kill TWG is a no-no.

[Bailey]

Well, he's still on my list, so I'm going to Vote: SecretSkull as well.

As for your theory, MB, I couldn't even figure out what your theory was.

Care to reword it for us folks who have different methods of thought from all the rest of you?

Also, if ever my arguments go into convolution beyond comprehension, just ask me to rephrase it, and I'll explain best as I can.

[secretskull]

I admit, I defended DarthMauler, I felt that it was wrong to lynch him because of what I thought was a simple mistake. I was wrong. As for Newb he added me to his list only after I voted for him, apparently because I voted for him. This is all I can say in my defense; I hope it’s enough.

[Bailey]

No, that was a coincidence of timing.

When you bullied Garud into removing his vote on the first day that raised you a little, when you said that Arhra's actions were "totally unlike what a mafiate would do" that raised you a bit higher, and then when you tried to act as though there could possibly be any doubt that judaspreistfan started as a townie that raised you to just high enough to get onto my list. The fact that later in the same post you voted for somebody I knew to be town aligned (me) just helped matters along. It was by no means the deciding factor.

As I said, I've been keeping track of the whole game on a spreadsheet.

Also, Catlover, while SSB is certainly suspicious for trying to vote for somebody who can only possibly be the detective, an initiate, a townie, or a secret role, why don't you put him on the side for now and come back to him next round?

As I said before, when you're playing an RTS, do you have your units all attack the enemy group at random, or do you have them concentrate their fire on one enemy unit at a time?


EDIT:

Also, here's a list of how many times each person (or their slot, if they are a replacement) still playing has posted within the game, meaning pregame has been excluded from the count.

Newb 45
FenrisWolf 40
The Wandering God 40
Catlover 32
SillyKitty 28
Ferix Stader 14
TheSpacePope 14
B Real Shadows 12
IOWACJE 12
Major Blood 12
Secretskull 10
Ecurt 9
Garud 9
Kneumatic Pnight 9
sk3l3t0n 8
Icendius 7
Arhra 6
Inbred Chocobo 6
Rhiya Ravenwing 6
Raiden 4
SSB Intern 3
JudasPriestFan 1
Living Bobbeh 1
Ol Dude With The Face 0

Here's the breakdown for SS, first by page (counted in 40s) and then by day, so you guys can go analyze his words yourselves.

Page 1: 1 post
Page 3: 2 posts
Page 6: 2 posts
Page 8: 3 posts
Page 10: 1 post
Page 11: 1 post

Day 1: 3 posts
Day 2: 6 posts
Day 3: 1 post