My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[Geminex]

Say Geminex, if you had to vote someone out D1 and only your vote would have counted, who'd you choose? Nik? Someone else? And why?

Hmm. Nik would've been an attractive target because of all the... well, stuff. He is disruptive. Most of his ideas and arguments, so far, seem to have been counterproductive, but I still get the feel that he wants us to lynch him. I might've done him the favor, but only if no better targets popped up.

I guess I was kinda suspicious of bookie, but he defended me against nikose which a mafiate wouldn't have done, so I don't think I would've gone for him.

Who else? I don't think I woulda lynched Sif, though the Dr. Whooves thing is still really suspicious. Particularly since he still hasn't posted his flavor text. What's up with taht, Sif?

Karesh is cool. You're cool, for now. Smarty? Seemed to be on our side, though I wasn't taken in.

I have a hunch that bard might be up to something, mostly since I'm almost certain he's lurking the thread.

But tbh, I prolly would've gone for Nikose, mostly cause nobody else was suspcious enough. Might still. Let's see how this day turns out.

Also, were you complimenting or insulting my intelligence back there?
Though if I have to ask, I should maybe assume the latter. :p

[Sifright]

I haven't posted the flavour text because it's against the rules.

[Sifright]

Would be nice for Fenris to confirm that for me

[Solid Snake]

Originally Posted by Geminex

Also, were you complimenting or insulting my intelligence back there?

Complimenting, actually. It was like "The thread was filled with dumb shit, and then Geminex, like a ray of sunshine, showed up and started saying smart things."

Also, let me put my vote to good use.

VOTE: Julford Hajime
Reasoning: He's inactive but Fenris hasn't looked for a replacement for him like he has others, which means he's scum.

[Verifiedz]

Originally Posted by Solid Snake

Complimenting, actually. It was like "The thread was filled with dumb shit, and then Geminex, like a ray of sunshine, showed up and started saying smart things."

Also, let me put my vote to good use.

VOTE: Julford Hajime
Reasoning: He's inactive but Fenris hasn't looked for a replacement for him like he has others, which means he's scum.

smart.... i have to stick with nik for now though.

[Nikose Tyris]

@Snake: That's the most logical thing I've read all day. Sway me a bit more for Julford?

[Geminex]

Hmm. Aren't there other inactives that have yet to be replaced?

And for that matter, why can't mafia be replaced?

[The Artist Formerly Known as Hawk]

Originally Posted by Nikose Tyris

Either we launch an attack with a 'suspicion' and risk missing, reducing Town's odds; We attack a roleclaim that verified a second roleclaim, negating the need for a PO stepup to cover anyone and get a confirmed un-nightkillable [Karesh]; Or someone stupidly comes forward, confesses PO and points, directing some accuracy to our hate tomorrow if he's lying or killing a mafiate today.

What's this "un-nightkillable" anyway? Who's said anything about that? Was there a memo I missed?

Hmm, I'm kinda unsure who I think is scum at this point. I have vague suspicions, but absolutely nothing concrete. I trust absolutely none of you.

[Oron]

Okay, after getting out of class and reading through everything... I don't know.

I bet Verifiedz was swapped in for a regular, inactive townie role. Fenris made the comment about people actually getting their roles in on time, so I'm inclined to believe that all players with roles are actually playing this game at this point in time.

The same logic could most likely be applied to RevOcelot.

Sif's claim and posts Day 1 were odd to me, but I still don't feel like lynching him because of that proposal he had to lynch him.

Given Snake's last post, should we target the inactive player? We've been going over whether an inactive player, town or scum, can really bring any harm to us. Although I did skim through that section of posts during class, so I could have missed parts of or misread that section. Weren't most of us against lynching the inactives for now?

[Oron]

By most I mean "three or so of the then actively posting players."

Also, it seems I have a knack for being very slow at posting.