Homesuck: Vriska Rising

[Aldurin]

Snake, he'll explain it in his formspring or in an update.

And debating wacky/reasonable hypotheticals is perfectly okay.

[Art of Hilt]

...Yeah, you're all doing a fine job reaching for purely hypothetical circumstances in which Kanaya would reasonably attack Gamzee first, but this still doesn't change the fact that it's an author's responsibility to communicate enough information to the readers so that we're not debating wacky hypotheticals.

I guess you could just wait for more updates?
I mean you're talking about communication when the thing being communicated is something inherently incomplete.
It's not even the last update in the day. It's the first update in the day, put up early, with more to follow.

I mean what I'm seeing is basically someone criticizing unnecessary focus on the bunny in the early acts.

[Locke cole]

Originally Posted by Solid Snake

...Yeah, you're all doing a fine job reaching for purely hypothetical circumstances in which Kanaya would reasonably attack Gamzee first, but this still doesn't change the fact that it's an author's responsibility to communicate enough information to the readers so that we're not debating wacky hypotheticals.

That's really kind of a slippery slope.

So, what, Hussie has failed because we're arguing against your arguments?

[Bard The 5th LW]

Originally Posted by Solid Snake

...Yeah, you're all doing a fine job reaching for purely hypothetical circumstances in which Kanaya would reasonably attack Gamzee first, but this still doesn't change the fact that it's an author's responsibility to communicate enough information to the readers so that we're not debating wacky hypotheticals.

These aren't whacky in the least. All of them have information to hold up. We have given several reasons that will probably be revealed as true in a amtter of panels.

[Aldurin]

Here Snake, let Hussie answer your whole issue with not getting all of the information ever at the same time.

[Archbio]

I think Snake is right about the "Gamzee was the biggest threat" explanation. If that was the intent it was badly conveyed. However, he obviously looks like he's been up to no good and hasn't been covering up his track and one thing that's been properly established (I mean, it happens sometimes even in Homestuck) is that Gamzee is just plain between Kanaya and Eridan.

She's just going to kick all of their asses and started with the first one in the way.

[Solid Snake]

Man, I keep forgetting how the whole serialized, ongoing nature of Homestuck completely absolves Andrew of any and all criticism until his work is completed.

...I'll just sit my sorry ass down and sing his unconditional praises like a good boy until he's done, then.

[Bard The 5th LW]

We get it Snake, you don't like Homestuck. No one is making you stay.

[Solid Snake]

Originally Posted by BardTheFifthLightWarrior

We get it Snake, you don't like Homestuck. No one is making you stay.

Yes I absolutely despise this all time favorite webcomic of mine, in fact I purchased three troll t-shirts and two kid t-shirts because I just despise the crap out of Homestuck, also I hate Kanaya so much I spent $30 on a plushie of her that's currently being shipped to me, and I hate it so much that I just spent $4 on the newest "Strife" album.

...Yes, that is me, hater of all things Homestuck.

...This is exactly what I hated about the MSPA forums and it's weird that it happens here at NPF too, of all places. Don't you guys realize that criticism of a webcomic does not equivocate to hatred of said work, and it is really absolutely annoying for anyone who criticizes to immediately be bitch-slapped for daring to say anything negative about their beloved author?

It's not like there are two choices, you either love everything Andrew Hussie writes or despise it. Homestuck has been and will likely continue to be the best webcomic on the interwebs. It just doesn't mean it's perfect.

[Art of Hilt]

Originally Posted by Solid Snake

...I'll just sit my sorry ass down and sing his unconditional praises like a good boy until he's done, then.

god fine i'll summon up some form of criticism since it is needed
how is kanaya walking if she got shot through her spine?