My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[Sifright]

edit:

Originally Posted by Solid Snake

Nope!
(Someone remind me, do we have any reason whatsoever to believe that Karesh cannot be Nightkilled?)

Well Karesh claimed it I suppose that doesn't count for huge amounts as it could be a bluff.

[Revising Ocelot]

I agree that killing Sifright is a terrible idea. I'm uncertain about Julford - it's better than the alternative, but I'd like this to pan out a few more calendar days (not game days) before settling on him.

My other big concern is Nikose - from my (admittedly unexperienced) POV, he's trying to get himself lynched. And not in the "I DIE SO TOWN MAY WIN" Sifright way, but the Jester way. Hell, we've already got someone who can post in only GIFs, a Jester role would not be out of place here.

[Aldurin]

Originally Posted by Verifiedz

why vote me? only reason i wanna vote nik s cuz he makes fun of me.

I'm putting you on my "people to vote for later list" (everyone else, be sure to keep an eye on him if I die during the night). Not the same thing as voting.

[Solid Snake]

Originally Posted by Aldurin

I'm putting you on my "people to vote for later list" (everyone else, be sure to keep an eye on him if I die during the night). Not the same thing as voting.

Personally, I have a hard time believing Verified is scum.
(If only because his scummates would be privately messaging him all kinds of threats to throttle him about now.)

[Geminex]

Ima go to bed. I think we shouldn't get muddled down in this, it's getting to be very back-and-forth. We've established that some of us are suspicious, let's see where that takes us. I'll keep my vote for Sif up, just cause I think it's best at the moment, but I'll see what there is to see when I wake up.

Byes.

[Solid Snake]

I still want to hear much more from greed and Ryanderman, who have been far more inactive this game than in Homestuck. I know both are fairly serious Mafia players.

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by Geminex

Hmm. Sif. If you want us to vote for you, why are you saying you aren't mafia?

Edit: I mean, of course you get to defend yourself, but if you think it's best for town for you to die, you'd try to get their votes.

Because me claiming i'm mafia whilst voting for my self to die would litterally be fucking stupid and no one on town side is going to vote for me if i do that because it's obvious i'm doing to confirm a role besides which if that was the case there is an easy way around I could just cheat get my self GO killed and bam roll confirmed.

[Ryanderman]

Originally Posted by Revolving Ocelot

If all power roles submitted actions during the night then that rules out Julford as he wasn't active during the night.

Actually:

FoS: Snake

His "I'm going to powergame the fuck out of this" routine is really, really weird.

No, it's just Snake. I'd be suspicious if he didn't.


I was initially inclined to trust Nikose and think he had some sort of PO role, because of:

Originally Posted by Nikose

ITT: Everyone has their own ideas of what is a good opening gambit all around, and Smarty is probably the cult leader.

And so when he posted:

Alternatively I guess we could Lynch Snake since he's the Serial Killer but like, that's optional like I said.

I thought, "sweet! He must have investigated Snake during the night! Let's send Snake to the moon!

But then I remembered:

...You know just out of predictability I'm willing to wager that Snake is Pinkie Pie of the Mane 6 and probably has a special power.

Alduin was culted night 0.

RPG is serial Killer.

Snake is probably going to die by mafia kill night one.

Bob the merc is Cult leader.

And now I'm more inclined to think he's just throwing that stuff out there, seeing what sticks, and he got lucky. I don't know what his game is. A suicide role seems to fit, kinda. Maybe.

Alternatively, he could be trying to hide his PO power behind a veil of random crap. Get the information out there, without drawing fire. Which makes me inclined to be suspicious of Snake again. But discussing and disecting the possibility of a PO Nikose seems to be unwise, as we don't want the PO revealed to the mafia. So I don't particularly know how to act on my suspicion.

I think killing Sifright is a bad idea, as we're not even suspecting he's anything but town. It may confirm an un-night killable town role, but I can't get past the fact that we'd be intentionally lynching a townie.

I think the logic behind going for Juliford has some merit, though I'm going to reserve my vote for now.

[Ryanderman]

Originally Posted by Solid Snake

I still want to hear much more from greed and Ryanderman, who have been far more inactive this game than in Homestuck. I know both are fairly serious Mafia players.

Ha, that was funny timing.

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by Ryanderman

No, it's just Snake. I'd be suspicious if he didn't.


I was initially inclined to trust Nikose and think he had some sort of PO role, because of:



And so when he posted:



I thought, "sweet! He must have investigated Snake during the night! Let's send Snake to the moon!

But then I remembered:





And now I'm more inclined to think he's just throwing that stuff out there, seeing what sticks, and he got lucky. I don't know what his game is. A suicide role seems to fit, kinda. Maybe.

Alternatively, he could be trying to hide his PO power behind a veil of random crap. Get the information out there, without drawing fire. Which makes me inclined to be suspicious of Snake again. But discussing and disecting the possibility of a PO Nikose seems to be unwise, as we don't want the PO revealed to the mafia. So I don't particularly know how to act on my suspicion.

I think killing Sifright is a bad idea, as we're not even suspecting he's anything but town. It may confirm an un-night killable town role, but I can't get past the fact that we'd be intentionally lynching a townie.

I think the logic behind going for Juliford has some merit, though I'm going to reserve my vote for now.

Out of interest how did you think he pulled said actions off during D1 when presumably, he had no night actions during that time period?