08-26-2010, 02:30 AM | #1 | |||||
Don't Hate Me 'Cause I'm Moe
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Harmonial Sanctum
Posts: 6,798
|
Pokemon Umbral Theatre 1: Where All the Lurkers...Ah...Lurk
To celebrate the change in titles for the discussion thread, I'll start doing two pictures. If I can. To begin with, something funny...
And then Dracorian's awesome dream given form... Right, then. Now that that's over, I'll start addressing all the class suggestions...at least the ones I noticed. Sorry if I missed one or six. Quote:
Proposal Two: No problem with this one, with one little issue. I...kinda don't know who can carry how many items aside from the Medic. Little help? Proposal Three: Pokebrid Accessories? Lovely idea. I am behind this. Let's have it available at Pokebrid level 3. Y'know, to offset the fact that I removed Paradigm Shift from there to put it at level 1. Proposal Four: I think this is a pretty good idea, but I'd like to shift Rage around and give each SyncTech its own Rage cost, based on usefulness. I'll do this for all the NPC Pokebrids and, if Dante doesn't want to mess with it, I could do it for his character as well. Proposal Five: This is also a good idea. Maybe at Pokebrid level 5? Then, Matthias could do something like use Toxic as a free action and the other has to be an attack. Next up is Dracorian...damn, no new adult games at funny-base. Quote:
Just like in other RPGs, when a character gains a new skill which is pretty much an upgrade to a previous skill, they tend to ignore the previous skill, even given things like the skill costing less SP or whatever. But we provide added effects to Focus and Sweep, like higher status affliction chances and whatnot, we could keep them attractive enough for an Overblade to consider using them despite how much better Double Attack is. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Anyways, I hope I've addressed everything. If I missed something, please repost it. I want to take care of addressing it tonight. Last edited by Astral Harmony; 08-26-2010 at 04:17 AM. |
|||||
08-26-2010, 03:55 AM | #2 | |
SOM3WH3R3
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 4,606
|
Dead internet connection. Very annoying. Not my fault.
That Comic Was Amusing! Because I Say So! And I Am The Leader! Though really, Impact isn't that stuck-up. He's more casual. And evil. And intelligent. I mean honestly, that wasn't Impact, that was an idiot whose world revolves around being lead-OOOOOH I SEE WHAT YOU DID THERE Also, guess what day it is today? Quote:
By the way, we never did get to make that deal, did we? Not that it really matters. Though I probably could have given you a pretty good one. In fact... >: ] H3Y, D4NT3. 4BOUT THOS3 MOT1V4T1ONS... As for those techniques, Drac. Ok. What. Seriously. Trainer attack did a minor amount of damage. Like, 10% of a pokemon's damage. Less, maybe. Even if that's not very useful now, and we decided to double it, to 20% (to compensate for the fact that enemies get stronger, thought that argument is extremely, extremely shaky, since I don't see us buffing any other techniques to compensate for enemies' growing strength, that's what level-ups are for) we wouldn't get anywhere near what you have now. I mean seriously dude, what the fuck. If AB approves that stuff, fine. His say. But in that case, I'd request that Pokebrids and Slayers get something similar. Cause what you have right now isn't a low-damage attack. It's 5 free signature techniques. And that's a lot. Hell, one weaker one would be acceptable, for anything more than that, there needs to be compensation. As for all those other suggestions I didn't actually see... First set: 1) Though I think Menarker's proposal involved that the Pokebrid would have to pay 20 rage at the start of every turn it's shifted, and for the duration of a battle, it can only stay shifted for three turns at max? Or did I misinterpret that? 2) Trainers and Snaggers carry three. Slayers and Brids carry six. And I'd leave it at that. 3) Cool. Though I think he meant less usable accessories, and more hold items. Also, I'm not sure if it's totally necessary, but very well. 4) Ok, what the fuck. This is a good idea. A great idea. In fact, I PROPOSED THIS IDEA FIVE THREADS AGO AND YOU REJECTED IT AND SAID IT MADE NO SENSE. SERIOUSLY, WHAT. Also, I combined this with signature techniques, and proposed that brids get new sync-techs instead of sig-techs. 5) I hadn't considered that. I think it'd work, though... See, I don't think pokebrids are all that underpowered. They might not be our best damage dealers, but they have a huge variety of techniques. And if they paradigm shift, they're suddenly damage dealers as well! I mean come on, how much damage has Matt done this turn using hyper beam. I'm mainly iffy about this entire thing because a) I don't really think they need all that much power once their paradigm shifts have been fixed (though I guess most of the above seems allright) and b) Menarker is making these proposals. Now, there's two possible motivations for this: 1) Menarker has suddenly become selfless and decided that the game's more fun when everybody has the same degree of power 2) Menarker wants to go pokebrid later and is getting a head start on overpowering that class I'm reaaaally not sure which it is. I mean, sure, man, maybe you've decided to stop being a competitive douche, but until you've made a post saying "I agree to all the Regulations.", I am not going to trust you. Dracorion's stuff, has that been accepted? Also, my suggestion for self-customization, did you actually accept that as well? |
|
08-26-2010, 04:19 AM | #3 |
Don't Hate Me 'Cause I'm Moe
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Harmonial Sanctum
Posts: 6,798
|
I did read about self-customization. So you tell me. What do you want to change about the levels you take?
|
08-26-2010, 04:38 AM | #4 |
SOM3WH3R3
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 4,606
|
Well, primarily I want to clear up the whole mishy-mashy chaos of "who acts as which class how do we combine the classes I am so confused I do not know what is going on BLUH BLUH" thing. From now on, there is just a collection of abilities. Up until now, those abilities have been clearly defined and have belonged to a certain class. I think it'd make everyone's life a lot easier if we just said "classes don't matter, pick your own abilities, but keep it balanced". I'll take care of that last bit.
What I want specifically, I was thinking that Impact could get Tactical Actions, with which he can use Tactical abilities. These would be a selection of minor, not-all-that-powerful abilities, but he could use quite a few per turn. Each'd influence the battle differently. Sorta like trainer actions, only, y'know, I'm not getting them for free. Every ability I've mentioned so far would probably start appearing as tactical actions (though, while the standard cost would be just one action per ability, depending on the strength, there might be some more than that). Impact would basically become this kickass manipulator, who can make tons of shit happen in battle without even needing to attack. What's your take on trainer actions, by the way? |
08-26-2010, 05:04 AM | #5 |
Don't Hate Me 'Cause I'm Moe
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Harmonial Sanctum
Posts: 6,798
|
Can't do the first bit. Nothing against Dante, but it'd be very difficult to have him do anything like creating his own abilities or choosing his own ranks when he's barely here.
And Dante's not the primary issue. Let's face it. We can't keep it balanced. If we could get it balanced in the first place, then we probably wouldn't even need Tactical Actions sounds like a sequel thing. In fact, it is a sequel thing. You're not getting it until the sequel. The blue-haired bimbo has spoken. Besides, you said you weren't getting them for free, but you didn't indicate the price you were going to pay for them. And some examples couldn't hurt, either. 'Cause I didn't see shit. My take on Trainer Actions is pretty cut and dry. Total of five, generally as effective as the Trainer Attack is. Once Menarker and Dracorian have ironed out whatever Pierce gets to do, then I'm plopping those in my document and leaving it at that. |
08-26-2010, 05:35 AM | #6 | |
SOM3WH3R3
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 4,606
|
See it as a way to encourage dante to participate more.
You think self-customization makes a difference here? It's gonna be imbalanced no matter what we do, and this way at least the system will be logical. Quote:
What price am I going to pay for them? I was thinking they were, y'know, gonna be my fucking demon upgrades. As for examples... Let's go for a strong one. "Massive Manipulation (name's gonna get revised" Takes 3 Actions and 25 rage Impact dominates one opponent Weaker one: Redirect! 1 Action Retroactively redirect 1 enemy attack from last round, to hit a different target (the whole "retroactive" thing cause I can't use this in real-time). Sorry, but going "Nope you can't have that cause I say so" while giving Trainers and Snaggers 5 extra signature techniques is complete and utter bullshit. |
|
08-26-2010, 07:38 AM | #7 | |||||||||
Moves Like Jagger, Kupo!
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: To the south, a little to the left... Or to the right.
Posts: 4,910
|
Wait a minute.
You were born? I could've sworn some mad scientist grew you in a barn. Oh well, congrats. Quote:
Quote:
Hell, the reason I didn't take these straight to AB was so we could discuss them and reach an agreement! If you're just going to reject them straight off the bat, there's not much point to proposing stuff so we can discuss them, is there? Out of curiosity, did you read Menarker's and my discussion on them or just my original suggestions because of time constraints? Quote:
If the Pokebrid has to pay 20 Rage each for three turns of Paradigm Shift up front, that's exactly like it is now! Quote:
Though I dunno if your proposal was like what AB decided to do in the end. Quote:
Also, name me one Sync-Tech Matt has used this mission and I'll show you hateful lies, because I'm fairly certain he hasn't gotten anywhere near 100 Rage. Quote:
Just run your critical eye over the proposals and approve them if you think they're good and Menarker can't abuse them in any way. You can make note that you reserve the right to change your mind, just in case it turns out later that they are broken and OMG MENARKER TRICKED YOU BWA HA HA. My opinion? I think Menarker is serving his own interests. However, that doesn't mean he's not right. I mean hell, when you proposed buffs for Slayer, and when I proposed buffs for Trainer we were both serving our own interests, but that didn't instantly make us wrong. Nope. I haven't put it in orange for AB because I knew you were going to whine about it. Quote:
Which is exactly what you tried to do when you proposed your support system. In which case, -2 points for disguising your proposal as a different one. Bad Geminex, BAD! Don't do that anymore! Keep in mind that your support system idea wasn't actually rejected. I went and proposed a perfectly reasonable compromise, remember? Quote:
A) I'm fairly certain he's already told you more about the sequel than he should, and B) it's his right as the GM not to tell you sequel stuff if he doesn't want you. Quote:
I PROPOSED A TRAINER ACTION THAT'S EXACTLY LIKE THIS. EXCEPT IT'S NOT RETROACTIVE, SO YOU CAN'T USE IT TO TAKE AWAY AN ATTACK YOU REALLY REALLY DON'T LIKE. AND Y'KNOW WHAT? IT DOESN'T COST RAGE EITHER LIKE THIS ONE. BETTER YET, IT EVEN ONLY REDIRECTS ONE ATTACK SPECIFICALLY AT ONE OF PIERCE'S POKEMON, NOT JUST ANY ALLY. OH WOW. Dick. Technically, he's the GM. It's his right, nay, his duty, to reject anything and everything.
__________________
Dracorion's dumbass color is Royal Blue. If you see that color, you better run the fuck away. |
|||||||||
08-26-2010, 09:30 AM | #8 | ||||||||
SOM3WH3R3
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 4,606
|
And yes, it is my birthday. Your souls will do as presents.
Quote:
PCHOOOO ... AH, HERE WE GO. Quote:
That Pokebrids don't need to be paradigm-shifted to use their techniques That their techniques be stronger when they do use them while shifted I proposed That Pokebrids don't need to be paradigm-shifted to use techniques That their techniques be stronger when they do use them while shifted (AND) That techniques be stronger, and have variable rage costs (like signature techniques) That they, in fact, replace signature techniques, meaning pokebrids can choose one at level... 4, 8 and 13 (?) Note that this would make the whole "redesign paradigm shift" thing unnecessary. ... WOW WILL YOU LOOK AT THAT. SOUNDS EXACTLY LIKE WHAT MENARKER PROPOSED. ONLY MORE COMPREHENSIVE. AND MORE AWESOME. DO YOU THINK YOU SHOULD HAVE MADE SURE THAT WASN'T THE CASE BEFORE ATTEMPTING TO CALL ME OUT ON THAT? Quote:
Quote:
Seriously. That's the second time that I propose something for Impact and then you ask for it for one of your characters. Cease thine Plagiarism, foul non-demon. Quote:
The system I mean is the "Customize your own character growth" system. As opposed to the "Be limited to 4 non-customizable classes and one hugely customizable class" system. The former is better, and more logical. I prefer it. Which do you prefer? Quote:
Or even know what he told me. H3H3H3H3H3 And yeah. Of course. He doesn't have to tell me anything. But I haven't been pestering him for information about the sequel. I have asked him a single question about it and my character's role in it. Am I somehow abusing my right to speak to AB? Does our great and august GM suffer so through my endless (EEEENDLEEEEEE---------ES) questions that he needs you to tell me to shut up? Have I ever implied that it's not his right not to tell me stuff? No? Then how about I tuck you in bed with a big, warm glass of Shut The Fuck Up. Seriously, don't do that. I don't like you when you're a presumptuous dick. Oh, wait, turns out I've never really liked you. Do you think there might be a correlation? Quote:
Quote:
And no, I haven't seen the revised versions of your utterly, utterly overpowered techniques. I you repost them I will be sure to give them an unbiased look. Yes. Last edited by Geminex; 08-26-2010 at 09:34 AM. |
||||||||
08-26-2010, 10:19 AM | #9 | ||||||
OMG! WHAT SHOULD I DO NOW?
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 3,802
|
Well, happy birthday Gem.
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
On a similar note, I did say that Drac's techniques even when edited might be too strong to get all at once. That Drac might have to forgo a few of them just on the basis that having 2 or 3 of them might be ok, but all five would border on too diverse. I didn't get the chance to edit my Cheerful Backup and make the 5 rage gain part into a second move, since that'll make it more natural to explain and such. Quote:
Quote:
Last edited by Menarker; 08-26-2010 at 11:54 AM. |
||||||
08-26-2010, 12:00 PM | #10 |
Birdy Bard
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Japanland
Posts: 501
|
I'm actually here more often than not. I'm just a lazy bastard who needs to post more in game. I don't post here often because I usually don't have much to contribute to the discussion. I leave all the crazyness (see: Balancing) to the people who want to put the time and effort behind it.
I'll take a look into putzing with my Sync Techs. I'll keep you guys apprised. |
|
|