Mafia: NPF edition

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

As for the other two, I'm forced to assume Roy was taken out by the Serial Killer because he died. He wasn't banned. He died.

Originally Posted by GARUD

Lying on the floor outside the gate was Roy_D_Mylote, "The Wizard Who Did It", NPF aligned.. He had a very large lump on his forehead. He also looked like he had been put through fire. But what was most important was the fact that he was banned.

Do you read the posts? He was banned.

B_real, you've harped on him not being banned for a while, but you never went back to check?

EDIT: On an unrelated note, the SK's name is PyrosNine, I believe. He has a form called Asheth, with a large wooden mallet and a tendency to set people on fire.

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

Well sorry for pointing out my case in such a way that makes it what it is. It is pretty damn convincing ain't it? basically what you're doing now about me.

Your case is a point of conjecture that only goes through by killing MANY in the way. *Cough* SCUMMY *COUGH* That makes EVERY OUTCOME dangerous, should he live. It's not being convincing, it's presenting a bogus charge, seeing as you like to misread what I say.

Like right here...

Except, Why would I want to kill twiddy?

Do you even read what I type?

Originally Posted by THE POST YOU RESPONDED TO!

You kill Twiddy, knowing he was mafia from the last game. Then you kill SK. After that, you take the initiative to bring up a point that leads to a dangerous circular logic point, meaning the entire situation is dangerous, off of conjecture.

Heyo, THAT'S WHY!

Would you look at that! We agree! Hell, I even said that before you pointed it out.

I'm questioning why you voted for him. The only reason I can see to vote for someone is if you think they're mafia or to get an answer. His answer is purely pointless and your reason to think he's mafia is CONJECTURE. Notice that word. I use it a lot, huh?

Why yes, it does appear to be that way. But now, had I been a mafiate, I wouldn't be betting so much on this would I? Or could it be that I'm just trying to get him to say something thats actually...I don't know...GAME RELATED!

And here you state that you're trying to get a response out of him, so that throws any sense of LOGIC out the window. Allow me to quote this post.

I'm questioning why you voted for him. The only reason I can see to vote for someone is if you think they're mafia or to get an answer. His answer is purely pointless and your reason to think he's mafia is CONJECTURE. Notice that word. I use it a lot, huh?

Edit: Bah, misread...

[Truce]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

Also remember everyone, Assuming makes an ass out of you AND me.:p

You know, I just wanted to quote this because of the big assumption that he made recently. And let's face it, it's a big assumption.

Seriously though, catlover has made one, and just one post since he returned two days ago.

Originally Posted by catlover20410

I haven't been evicted from this, have I?

I find it hard to believe he's innocent, just from that one post. However, we do know he wasn't around during the start of the mafia game (assuming, yes, assuming his posts in the PA thread are truthful), so he probably didn't orchestrate the plan that B_Real said he did.

[P-Sleazy]

To Fenris:
hehe ^^. the way I understood it, was he was put through fire, and thus died along with his banning.

To Mesden: So you think I had this all planned out from night one? LOL! thats just crazy Mesden. If I was mafia, you'd be first to go. But you weren't. I'm going to go with the idea that we have Amateur mafiates doing this. Hell, I make a pretty convincing arguement (agaist Catlover), I probably wouldn't need to be the mafia don to control the mafia's whim. Just the same as you wouldn't need to be the don to control the mafia you were with.

Remember last game? You are capable of mistakes. We all are. never have I said I'm 100% sure that Catlover was the Mafia don EDIT: Or mafia for that matter But I'm extremely close to it.

Also, you keep rampaging on about me having this scenario set up with alot of deaths happening. Who else have I convicted of being suspicious other than Catlover. All I said was Fenris Wolf is probably the next victim. And yes, If I die tonight, then so be it. Town's not exactly losing anything killing off vanilla townies other than an extra member of the town. Whoopdeedo!

You have also done and set up the EXACT same scenario here. Replace a few names, change the situation a little and there we go. I end up Mafia, you're seen as the town hero, and you probably won't get lynched. I end up innocent, its fairly obvious you're mafia trying to get townies lynched. Only difference is, you can save your own neck better than I can cause you're better at imposing your opinions on others.

Catlover can wait a day. We haven't gotten his side yet.

UNVOTE: CATLOVER
VOTE:MESDEN

EDIT:

To Ecurt. The game started Saturday morning soon after Mesden said she'd join here, which was VERY early in the morning. Twiddy's leaving post is here . The game probably started somewhere around noon since we can't be sure since Garud deleted the game startign post. We also don't know if the Mafia was the last to send in their vote. It could have very well been the PO or the BG role we were waiting for to start the game.

[Mesden]

B_Real, quote me when you answer, since it's a bit hard to get what you're replying to.

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

To Mesden: So you think I had this all planned out from night one? LOL! thats just crazy Mesden.

Yes, we all know it's IMPOSSIBLE to have a plan at the beginning of a mafia game. Wait, no, that's a load of bull.

If I was mafia, you'd be first to go. But you weren't.

And you'd kill me first? I'm touched, since that was the entire reason I was debating quitting mafia (People killing me off at first just because I'm me). But this is just your word, which may or may not be a lie. So that holds NO bearing here, buddy.

I'm going to go with the idea that we have Amateur mafiates doing this.

Amateur mafiates? How? You think Catlover is a mafiate and he is NO amateur, being in a few games already.

Hell, I make a pretty convincing arguement (agaist Catlover), I probably wouldn't need to be the mafia don to control the mafia's whim.

The argument isn't convincing to me (And IC, apparently). I stated why it's not. A whole lot. So saying you are is laugh worthy in my eyes right now.

You just haven't taken time to THINK about my posts and you're getting the wrong message, something I've stated already.

Just the same as you wouldn't need to be the don to control the mafia you were with.

Heck, that's just because people think I'm some uber mafiate! I don't need to be convincing, people would just follow what I say and not second guess it.

Remember last game? You are capable of mistakes. We all are. never have I said I'm 100% sure that Catlover was the Mafia don. But I'm extremely close to it.

...Which doesn't change the fact. You're not 100%, oh no. You're only 95%. That doesn't change ANYTHING I'VE SAID.

Also, you keep rampaging on about me having this scenario set up with alot of deaths happening. Who else have I convicted of being suspicious other than Catlover.

I'm tired of you not really reading my posts. I stated how it was a dangerous conjecture. If he's lynched, it'll lead to a plethora of possible townie deaths and misoccruences. It was stated earlier in the thread (I don't think the actual possibilities were stated by me, but ehy enforce what I meant.)

I NEVER said you casted doubt on anyone else and now you're putting words in my mouth. Ahem. Scum=That.

All I said was Fenris Wolf is probably the next victim. And yes, If I die tonight, then so be it. Town's not exactly losing anything killing off vanilla townies other than an extra member of the town. Whoopdeedo!

Vanilla Townie Roleclaim. Yeah, a bit overplayed and pointless. Stop trying to make lite of the situation.

Don't respond to my post with chopped up, hard to sort through and understand dribble. I want you to take my last post and put the points I had down, since I know you're missing a good bit. I'll not respond to the rest, as I don't know where you get it from.

Respond to me correctly so I can fully get what you're saying. Here, I'll even link my post for easy access.

Linky[

UNVOTE: CATLOVER
VOTE:MESDEN

I find this funny since you're so close to 100% sure he's a Mafiate, BTW.

[DarthMauler64]

I have a few things to say:

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

I'm going to go with the idea that we have Amateur mafiates doing this.

1) Not nessicarily. During Basic, the mafia killed grthwllms who hasn't played mafia before. Then in this game, the old mafia mentioned that their plan was to make it look like they wern't experienced mafia by killing him. This could be the mafia's plan again.

2) Even though CatLover might not have much to defend himself with, I still want to hear what he has to say about the revenge thing. I probally won't vote him soley on the revenge theory though.

3) Hopefully I can post more soon. The construction workers plus summerschool cuts into my internet time.

[Daisuke]

Originally Posted by FenrisWolf

On an unrelated note, the SK's name is PyrosNine, I believe. He has a form called Asheth, with a large wooden mallet and a tendency to set people on fire.

How do you know that? Did I miss the memo or something? Also wouldn't that mean that burn marks would point to him? I'm kind of confused by what you're saying.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Daisuke

How do you know that? Did I miss the memo or something? Also wouldn't that mean that burn marks would point to him? I'm kind of confused by what you're saying.

It bears little relevancy. The role of the Serial Killer is assigned to a name, much like my name was unlynchable. And I don't know for sure, but I'm guessing.

[P-Sleazy]

you want it cut up. ok. here you go.

Originally Posted by Me

To Mesden: So you think I had this all planned out from night one? LOL! thats just crazy Mesden. If I was mafia, you'd be first to go. But you weren't. I'm going to go with the idea that we have Amateur mafiates doing this. Hell, I make a pretty convincing arguement (agaist Catlover), I probably wouldn't need to be the mafia don to control the mafia's whim. Just the same as you wouldn't need to be the don to control the mafia you were with.

Remember last game? You are capable of mistakes. We all are. never have I said I'm 100% sure that Catlover was the Mafia don EDIT: Or mafia for that matter But I'm extremely close to it.

Also, you keep rampaging on about me having this scenario set up with alot of deaths happening. Who else have I convicted of being suspicious other than Catlover. All I said was Fenris Wolf is probably the next victim. And yes, If I die tonight, then so be it. Town's not exactly losing anything killing off vanilla townies other than an extra member of the town. Whoopdeedo!

You have also done and set up the EXACT same scenario here. Replace a few names, change the situation a little and there we go. I end up Mafia, you're seen as the town hero, and you probably won't get lynched. I end up innocent, its fairly obvious you're mafia trying to get townies lynched. Only difference is, you can save your own neck better than I can cause you're better at imposing your opinions on others.

Catlover can wait a day. We haven't gotten his side yet.

UNVOTE: CATLOVER
VOTE:MESDEN

Happy? well, you better be. I prefer to reply to posts as a whole and go from there, thank you very much.

Originally Posted by Mesden

I find this funny since you're so close to 100% sure he's a Mafiate, BTW.

hmmm...maybe because I'm as far as I know, My Catlover Accusations are a longshot. My accusations against you on the otherhand are FAR more likely. Trying to get the first townie to notice the Catlover guilt and get him ousted for the very reasons you have set up. Yes, you may be Uber Mafiate and I don't put ANYTHING past you. Just seems like a brand new strategy of yours to get people lynched without drawing suspicion to yourself. Kinda like in the first mafia you had mafiates vote for another mafiate, and have the town beleive that mafiates wouldn't vote for other mafiates. Now we know they do that, and we're more careful.

What I see you doing now is having the mafia set up a scenario so perfect to set someone or people up that it WILL lead to MASSIVE amounts of deaths.

Lets have at it Mesden.

EDIT: Pyrosnine is probably very likely since Pyro means fire and the victim was burned in fire. Pyro=fire=Serial Killer=Townie killer. Lets have a round of applause shall we

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

What I see you doing now is having the mafia set up a scenario so perfect to set someone or people up that it WILL lead to MASSIVE amounts of deaths.

I hate to interrupt, but what the fuck?! You're the one who started this whole fiasco, and you're blaming it on Mesden!?

That is just ridiculous. You started the post with "the former mafiates who scorned catlover will die", and then when Mesden says that "No, that might not be the case, it might be your idea", you go and blame it on her?

Could you bring some common sense into this? That's like saying 2+2=Ice cream.