Mafia: NPF edition - Page 58

Mesden · 07-07-2006, 08:55 PM

Honestly, there's only a few things I can go off in the thread.

Ecurt and Spacepope.

Spacepope for being quiet through mostof the game and doing VERY little along the lines of production and Ecurt...well...Yeaaaaaaah.

I'm going to Vote: Spacepope because aside from the circular logic of a setup via the Mafia to frame him by Killing Inbred, there was no apparent reason.

neyo the king · 07-08-2006, 12:39 AM

Ok, I'll bite the bullet for Ecurt.

Ecurt was defending B_real on a gut feeling. Back then we were all just basicly going on gut feelings, really, and if everyone who's gut feeling was wrong was suspicious, a good majority of us would be FoS'd.

Even though I do find it slightly odd that he was willing to sacrifice himself for B_real, I seriously don't believe that he is mafia.

And on Spacepope, I'm not to sure about him, really. Can't really remember what he has posted, so... yeah...

Bailey · 07-08-2006, 01:20 AM

Okay, I'll admit that I only skimmed since I last posted, since I was trying to catch up on, what, 13 pages? Of 40 posts each?

But Spacepope doesn't look that suspicious from what I saw.

Maybe you can point at stuff that you think might convince me?

catlover20410 · 07-08-2006, 01:28 AM

Garud, I just read the thread yesterday, and I haven't checked my PMs.

I just glanced at the first page to see if I was still in or not, saw that my name was still white, and assumed I was still in because those things are usually updated.

IT TAKES FIVE FUCKING SECONDS. DO IT WHEN YOU MAKE THE DEATH/BOOT POSTS. JESUS.

neyo the king · 07-08-2006, 01:32 AM

Catlover, that's a bit harsh, you know? Maybe he forgot, or something.

You need to calm down, it's not that big a deal.

GARUD · 07-08-2006, 01:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by catlover20410

IT TAKES FIVE FUCKING SECONDS. DO IT WHEN YOU MAKE THE DEATH/BOOT POSTS. JESUS.

Yelling at the GO is not going to get you unbooted. Although, if you do start abusing me, well... things can get very ugly.

Quote:

Garud, I just read the thread yesterday, and I haven't checked my PMs.

Quote:

I just glanced at the first page to see if I was still in or not, saw that my name was still white, and assumed I was still in because those things are usually updated.

You contradict yourself here. I booted you a week ago. If you read the thread yesterday, you would have known that.

One more thing. Catlover, I don't want you to post in the thread anymore because of your booting. If you do, well, concequences will be much more dire than you expect. Since you have been kicked, anything you post will be considered "Spam".

Also: I'm bringing back the cookie system. Neyo gets one for defending the GO

Truce · 07-08-2006, 03:46 AM

I will admit that I am evil. Just not in this particular game.

Other than that, it really looks bad for me, ne?

Ho~hum. What exactly am I supposed to say? My actions are on the table, so feel free to decide for yourself what I am.

dojindog · 07-08-2006, 08:42 AM

Well I'm gonna have to FoS: Ecurt it's strange that you keep drawing suspicion upon yourself without any real outside provocation from anyone else.

TheSpacePope · 07-08-2006, 09:53 AM

Yea, Mesden I haven't posted that much cause I have a Job.
I am a wage slave, so I get to post on my days off.

And could you please tell me something that I did that was suspiscious?
Really now, You are a better player than that...

Seems a little scummy to defend me, then accuse me.
Your thoughts?

Mesden · 07-08-2006, 11:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheSpacePope

Yea, Mesden I haven't posted that much cause I have a Job.
I am a wage slave, so I get to post on my days off.

And could you please tell me something that I did that was suspiscious?
Really now, You are a better player than that...

Seems a little scummy to defend me, then accuse me.
Your thoughts?

That wasn't defending. That was an abrasive joke between me and a dead friend and if you use THAT as any kind of evidence, so help me CmP will turn in his grave.

You want me to get serious? I'll get serious.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spacepope, The Phatom Quote

Wow, 31 pages of dojindog dying.

Awesome.
I guess you guys need to sleep.
And have a job.
Sorry I have been inactive, but working sucks.

Yes, because the eventual attempt at lynching a townie was awesome. It's not much on it's own, but it's worth note. Also, you use the "I have a job" excuse. Viable, but unable to prove in all honesty without regarding direct outside sources. For all we know you have more free time than you let on and you're using the work excuse to stay under the radar. (Something I've shown time and time again I hate and it VERY VERY applied by scum of all kinds)

Next!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spacepope, The Quote Wars

Get over yourself.

As far as any real leads go, I am going to have to say that b_real Has a good theory, makes a bit of sense. Really though, I want to hear what catlover has to say. Also at this point I am hesitant to point a finger at fenris, mostly because it doesn't jive with me. Gut wise that is.

Edit: 43 posts later I am still on the fence about b_real's theory, I want more meat. However it is not worth voting for him

Awwh, and you want me to get over myself. Well, lemme finish this first!

Hey! He agrees with B_Real and then edits to say otherwise AFTER the loud player shows how inane and scummy his plan is! You're not the only one, but that's ALL your post is about and it's still a point to note as we go onto...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spacepope, The Revenge of the Mesden

Has catlover even posted yet. Honestly I want to know what you are basing this on.

Here's you wanting Catlover's answer. All it does is reinforce your instant switch against the mafia when things were out of his favor. The first time being completely off my deduction.

[quote=Spacepope, maybe not the last hope]

Quote:

Originally Posted by My assumption on Catlover is from Mafia Basic [/quote

So you are basing this on another game?

Ummm....What?

That makes no sense....that game has nothing to do with THIS one.

Yes they do! The playstyle and ideas of past games influence all of their predecessors! It's called precedent! Just clearing it up for you! d(^ ^d)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spacepope, Mesden Strikes Back

I know that you can use that as evidence. I am just questioning the validity of the claim. There is no real reason to do that especially when catlover has not made post 2 I believe. And thank you O master mage, that post gave me a better idea on the methedology. I am still waiting for catlover's response.

Here you say that the past games CAN be used as evidence (Which it shouldn't be EVIDENCE, but enough to show referrals of similar situations and how the game may work in certain aspects). Elightened in the wrong way you are, young Spacepope.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spacepope, the Return of the Accusation

Well honestly, I think as the town, we might want to listen to b-real and take note. The accusations that he leveled just sound like a disgruntled roomate, or an unhappy employee, spilling the beans about the company so to speak.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mom

I would admit to being a mafiatte if I got frustrated and just wanted to take the person responsible for that with me. Its a perfectly reasonable suspicion

Precisely.
Now we see that Mesden is UNvoting B-real, and that is possibly to allay any suspiscion. And Neyo, you might be right about the catlover scenario.

Quote:

Originally Posted by B_Real

And I kept trying to get catlover lynched cause he annoyed the rest of us (mafiates). We kept trying to get a hold of him since he was our don and he kept saying "later later" and finally he left. We sent the night kill without waiting for him. When he came back he still kept saying later later. So we again sent in the role for him. Except this time trying to frame him since we did have a convenient kill as our night 1 kill. So we killed Silly Kitty. And there you have it. I was willing to possibly sacrifice myself to get Catlover lynched so someone else could take the helm. EDIT FORGOT THIS:::Good luck mafiate. You will need it going solo. God knows Catlover isn't going to help you. And Mesden's one backstabbing !#%$@ of a mafiate too.

This is an important list of suspects.
Catlover and Mesden
twiddy and b-real
that leaves one left.

I think.....maybe fenris, mostly because he completely debunked B-reals claim immediately without giving any kind of SOLID rebuttal, aside from calling him scummy. That is definitely the bottom of my list though. This is my only lead

Quote:

Originally Posted by FenrisWolf

You freaking scumbag. I don't believe you.

A) Why the hell would an intelligent player like Mesden try to kill a team-mate of hers for a supposed plan that she was a part of?

Worked for the guys in basic.

First things first
VOTE: Catlover
And hopefully the Vig wipes b-real.
maybe....

Oh ho ho. This is a big post that I shall dismantle!

Quote:

Well honestly, I think as the town, we might want to listen to b-real and take note. The accusations that he leveled just sound like a disgruntled roomate, or an unhappy employee, spilling the beans about the company so to speak.

Yes, a disgruntled roomate that wants to kill you in his sleep along with his 3 buddies! d(^ ^d) You're not the only one to think this, but things are adding up.

Quote:

Precisely.
Now we see that Mesden is UNvoting B-real, and that is possibly to allay any suspiscion. And Neyo, you might be right about the catlover scenario.

Allay suspicions? I was the SOLE person to bring suspicion on him! No matter what that turns around. Good thing I nailed a mafiate! d(^ ^d)

Also, I unvoted him on a leap of faith for the vig and the dangerous situation Catlover presented. I HAD to vote for catlover if only for self preservation, because if the situation that B_Real presented (Where Catlover and I are mafia) was a direct threat to me.

I had to look out for numero uno there. Just like ANY other player.

Quote:

This is an important list of suspects.
Catlover and Mesden
twiddy and b-real
that leaves one left.

Well...Twid died...but you were confused at this point and missing some context, as we were referring to others.

You named Catlover for some reason unbeknownest to me. The only reason I was against him, was, well, self prservation.

And then you name B_Real, but seriously, that's little to no help in your case because at this point he already roleclaimed it AND I'd done a lot of work to prove him scum which paid off.

So, you name a townie, a confirmed mafiate, the person who confirmed the mafiate(But still no proof of town allignment) and a dead man out of context.

This DOESN'T look that...purposeful. You're just going along with what others said...

Quote:

I think.....maybe fenris, mostly because he completely debunked B-reals claim immediately without giving any kind of SOLID rebuttal, aside from calling him scummy. That is definitely the bottom of my list though. This is my only lead

Yes, he called the confirmed mafiate Scummy. How freaking awful. *Eye roll*

07-07-2006, 08:55 PM	#571
Mesden There is no Toph, only Melon Lord! Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Inside of a box inside of a smaller box Posts: 4,310	Honestly, there's only a few things I can go off in the thread. Ecurt and Spacepope. Spacepope for being quiet through mostof the game and doing VERY little along the lines of production and Ecurt...well...Yeaaaaaaah. I'm going to Vote: Spacepope because aside from the circular logic of a setup via the Mafia to frame him by Killing Inbred, there was no apparent reason. __________________ I can tell you're lying.

07-08-2006, 12:39 AM	#572
neyo the king Dr. Ivo Robotnik Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Mobius Posts: 674	Ok, I'll bite the bullet for Ecurt. Ecurt was defending B_real on a gut feeling. Back then we were all just basicly going on gut feelings, really, and if everyone who's gut feeling was wrong was suspicious, a good majority of us would be FoS'd. Even though I do find it slightly odd that he was willing to sacrifice himself for B_real, I seriously don't believe that he is mafia. And on Spacepope, I'm not to sure about him, really. Can't really remember what he has posted, so... yeah... __________________ I am Doctor Ivo Robotnik, the greatest scientific genius in the universe! ~"Where There's Smoke, They Pinch Back."~

07-08-2006, 01:32 AM	#575
neyo the king Dr. Ivo Robotnik Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Mobius Posts: 674	Catlover, that's a bit harsh, you know? Maybe he forgot, or something. You need to calm down, it's not that big a deal. __________________ I am Doctor Ivo Robotnik, the greatest scientific genius in the universe! ~"Where There's Smoke, They Pinch Back."~

07-08-2006, 08:42 AM	#578
dojindog The Almighty Dojindog Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: In a House Posts: 112	Well I'm gonna have to FoS: Ecurt it's strange that you keep drawing suspicion upon yourself without any real outside provocation from anyone else. __________________ Kitten Huffing My new favorite website So we never forget (or at least so I don't) Member:The Official NPF "Crowd of Uncles" AND DAMN PROUD OF IT!!!! Get your free Elizabethan insults right here you unmuzzled boil-brained filthy rogues

07-08-2006, 09:53 AM	#579
TheSpacePope Gigity Join Date: May 2005 Location: Lincoln. Nebraska Posts: 1,536	Yea, Mesden I haven't posted that much cause I have a Job. I am a wage slave, so I get to post on my days off. And could you please tell me something that I did that was suspiscious? Really now, You are a better player than that... Seems a little scummy to defend me, then accuse me. Your thoughts? __________________ Ashes to Ashes, Dust to Dust

07-08-2006, 03:46 AM	#577
Truce Lakitu Join Date: Nov 2003 Posts: 3,856	I will admit that I am evil. Just not in this particular game. Other than that, it really looks bad for me, ne? Ho~hum. What exactly am I supposed to say? My actions are on the table, so feel free to decide for yourself what I am.