Nothing is as it Seems Mafia: The Game

[P-Sleazy]

His jumping on Ole Dude WTF. According to Roy. Unless of course you mean Newb's made up story. But then you have no reason to suspect RR anymore (aside from Newb's list).

Which makes me wonder though. Roy, why are you still voting RR? The only reason you did that was because he jumped on Ole Dude WTF who was beleived to be townie at the time due to Newb's story telling. Or am I missing something else here Roy?

[Roy_D_Mylote]

Newb did not change his story multiple times. He changed it once. He has now claimed mason'd-to-dead-guy-townie.

EDIT:

Originally Posted by B_real_shadows

Which makes me wonder though. Roy, why are you still voting RR? The only reason you did that was because he jumped on Ole Dude WTF who was beleived to be townie at the time due to Newb's story telling. Or am I missing something else here Roy?

It was originally that, but now since the story's bunk it's the vibe I got when I first voted for him.

[Pink Bunny]

If you want complete honesty out of me, I'd rather lynch Tendronai instead of Newb. And the screwed up part is, I'm completely aware that Tendronai hasn't done much to deserve a lynch. I cannot really draw up a big conclusive reason of why he has to die other than a giant hunch. What I can say is this.

He's been quiet.
He tried to 'trap' people.
He tried to support me on my confirmation of town. (This is why I feel guilty over this hunch and have held out dragging it out so long),
Even Newb sees it, it isn't just me who has this hunch...

It just seems so... Safe. The actions presented are too safe and quiet. Like, "Don't pay attention to man behind the curtain."
Tendronai has never struck me as this safe. He's so open when he's town or has anything to provide. The Mason Leader deal with the roleblocks and all of that.

Also Zilla, the reason you are implicated is because you've been quiet. Your reason for being quiet is reasonable, but the bigger reason you've been implied as scum is from RR's actions supporting your crappy vote earlier. Quietness + Questionable Votes with Noticeable, Illogical Backing = Curious.

Edit: The bottom line is lynching Newb doesn't seem like it will confirm or deny anything. At all. Just him. He's already admitted to his lies. He could be telling new ones, but you know what? We can just ignore him and spend our lynch on an avenue that'd provide more information.

[russianreversal]

Like I said, I was backing Banana there, not Zilla. And how would lynching Tendronai provide more information? If you can show me a way, I might change my vote. There's still two days. It'd have to be extremly sound, though, because Newb is actually asking for it.

[Brock Samson]

The link would be in who Tendronai has supported and who has used his ideas. If Newb is mafia, then fine, but that really doesn't prove much of anything. Many people have given the reasoning behind the theory of Newb's lynching not doing anything as far as confirmations, so I don't feel the need to do so now. Tendronai on the other hand would give some solid evidence due to his over all lack of making as many boisterous lies.

[Tendronai]

Tell you what, I'm going to explain stuff now.

I am the Mystic, Town Aligned. You know how we haven't been seeing everyone's roles when they die? Not my fault, but no matter who it is hiding the stuff, I still see the results.

I want Newb dead. Mainly because Nikose was the Romano Family Don.

And since I'm telling you this right now, my element of surprise mostly just went out the window. So here's everyone else's alignment.

Doppler12, Thief
Cephrir, Reviver
Ape Boy, Roleblocker
Ecurt, Alberto Family PO
Silly Kitty, Alberto Family PO - I'm not sure if this was a typo on Fenris' part or if there are actually two PO's for the Alberto family, so don't bother asking, I don't know.
Sithdarth, Condantino Family PO, Cult of Music, Cult of Personality
Tophat, Alberto Family Don
Rygar, Vig
B_Real, Tracker
Nayno, Seer
Deathpigeon, Romano Family Vengeful Mafiate

I didn't want anyone to know I had access to this stuff, because then I could try laying a few traps and seeing who took what bait, then cross-check it with who they've agreed with in the past. But since I seem to have been called on that (God, I thought it would so easy to do this with fifty other people running around) it looks like the information should come out, since it won't do the town any good if it dies with me. I had intended to wait a while before I showed everyone this, though.

And just to make sure it gets noticed - Hey, other two Condantino's! Your Don's probably been culted. If one (or both) of you could convienently FOS or Vote him before you die, I'll be sure to pass along the message to the town who you were, and we could stop one of the cult's victory.

Finally, I'd prefer some form of protection if at all possible until we can stop whoever's screwing with the roles. I do know that there is someone out there responsible for it, and I'd rather they weren't the only ones getting information.

EDIT : PS, Ape Boy, please do not say anything about whether I was right or not on your original role. While I know it would confirm what I've said, it relies on quasi-out-of-game knowledge, and that's not really fair.

[Roy_D_Mylote]

...telling us that hurts the town so bad.

[OctoberRaven]

Hm. I REALLY wish I had another investigation now to confirm Ten.

But unless someone can credibly claim otherwise, I call 'hooray for the mystic!'.

[russianreversal]

Originally Posted by Roy_D_Mylote

...telling us that hurts the town so bad.

Well, not as much as if he'd been taken out at night. Then we'd never know at all.

Why, though, are you telling us this now, Tendronai? No one's voted for you, there are no threats to you. You could just want to get rid of Newb really bad, but I don't think that's it alone. What's your angle here?

[OctoberRaven]

He could be Culted. After all, who could prove him wrong?

Not saying that's what's going on, mind you, but it could explain it.