Urban Mafia - Page 11

Ape Boy · 10-07-2007, 08:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nayno

Day 1 is not appropriate for lurker lynches.

Why wouldn't it be? It's a pretty safe lynch early to earn some coming flavor text and actions from the night so we can work toward productive lynches.

Pink Bunny · 10-07-2007, 08:37 PM

Because 90% of the time a lurker lynch on day one is a vanilla townie.

Tendronai · 10-07-2007, 08:40 PM

I don't really think that lynching Lunaknight each and every time we don't have any leads on day one is really fair, personally.

Ape Boy · 10-07-2007, 08:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pink Bunny

Because 90% of the time a lurker lynch on day one is a vanilla townie.

From my experience playing these games, the percentage of day one townie lynches approaches 90% by itself.

If it weren't for Luna, it'd probably be closer to 95%.

Pink Bunny · 10-07-2007, 08:43 PM

That's agreeable.
But then he already tried to get himself lynched if you noticed. This isn't the random run of the mill of "Oh well, kill him", he baited this one.

Which is the exact reason I'm not voting him because I'm afraid he's got a vengeance role because I've said repeatedly in lots of games it'd be funny if a GM gave him one, and now suddenly he's all "KILL MEEEE" this game.

Captain Combustible · 10-07-2007, 08:59 PM

here's some data on 10 day one lynches excluding games in which majority of people were scum or everyone was town. Note: Some of the people weren't actually lynched due to unlynchability.

Dragon Lance- LHN town
Totally rigged- Ogianres, town
House of cards- B_real, town
Superhero Mafia-Newb, Mafiate
Kingdom hearts mafia- Red Fighter, Mafiate
Video Game Mafia- Demetrius, SK
Warcraft Mafia- Lunaknight, town
Spiderman Mafia- Lunaknight, Mafia
Themeless- Bookie, Jester
Complete insanity- Doc Ock, town

we actually have a 50% scum hit rate for day one lynches in these games.

Demetrius · 10-07-2007, 09:02 PM

Yeah, i wasn't a SK in VG Mafia, I was a mentalist and got banned, allowing Mesden to reveal me... I finally had a role I could screw around with and I died...

Nayno · 10-07-2007, 09:04 PM

Well, sure, it isn't fair to lynch Lunaknight every time... which is why I usually don't go after him unless he puts off a really strong vibe. But it's not fair to lynch the newbie either before he gets a chance to defend himself. It's only been four days anyway and this thread took long enough to go up; we should give him the benefit of the doubt for today and possibly lynch lurkers later on. 'Sides, if he doesn't log on it's not like he's going to be sending in any night roles.

Pink Bunny · 10-07-2007, 09:04 PM

I can't help but notice that each player listed isn't much of a Lurker, at least when accused or brought up on a chopping block. The only person on that list I wouldn't be able to confirm/say that with is Ogianres.

The rest are active and say stuff. I'm not saying no-lynch, I haven't really picked yet. But I am saying that usually a lynch on a lurker on day 1 is a vanilla townie. I'm pretty sure that's where Nayno's going with this too.

Cephrir · 10-07-2007, 09:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pink Bunny

Has anyone ever claimed those though?

I've seen a Miller claim. Not here, obviously, but it has happened. It was really sad.

10-07-2007, 08:40 PM	#103
Tendronai I will crush your economy. Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Magical mystical land of Canada. Posts: 1,364	I don't really think that lynching Lunaknight each and every time we don't have any leads on day one is really fair, personally. __________________ Give me your wallet before I destroy you, mortal.

10-07-2007, 09:02 PM	#107
Demetrius In need of a vacation Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Peoples Republic of Vermont Posts: 3,236	Yeah, i wasn't a SK in VG Mafia, I was a mentalist and got banned, allowing Mesden to reveal me... I finally had a role I could screw around with and I died... __________________ DFM, Demon seed of Hell who fuels its incredible power by butchering little girls and feeding on their innocence. Demetrius, Dark clown of the netherworld, a being of incalculable debauchery and a soulless, faceless evil as old as time itself. Zilla, The chick. ~DFM Wii bishie bishie kawaii baka! ~ Fifthfiend

10-07-2007, 09:04 PM	#108
Nayno The Double Negative Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 198	Well, sure, it isn't fair to lynch Lunaknight every time... which is why I usually don't go after him unless he puts off a really strong vibe. But it's not fair to lynch the newbie either before he gets a chance to defend himself. It's only been four days anyway and this thread took long enough to go up; we should give him the benefit of the doubt for today and possibly lynch lurkers later on. 'Sides, if he doesn't log on it's not like he's going to be sending in any night roles. __________________ My NPF Mafia Record Games played: 12 (6/4/2) Wins: 2 town, 4 cult, 0 mafia, 0 self-aligned Highlights: Totally Rigged Mafia - Mafiate, cult-aligned, sole survivor Warcraft Mafia - Serial Killer, self-aligned, died night 5

10-07-2007, 08:37 PM	#102
Pink Bunny Shyguy Join Date: Jul 2007 Posts: 100	Because 90% of the time a lurker lynch on day one is a vanilla townie.

10-07-2007, 08:43 PM	#105
Pink Bunny Shyguy Join Date: Jul 2007 Posts: 100	That's agreeable. But then he already tried to get himself lynched if you noticed. This isn't the random run of the mill of "Oh well, kill him", he baited this one. Which is the exact reason I'm not voting him because I'm afraid he's got a vengeance role because I've said repeatedly in lots of games it'd be funny if a GM gave him one, and now suddenly he's all "KILL MEEEE" this game.

10-07-2007, 08:59 PM	#106
Captain Combustible Can't spell.... or count Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 27	here's some data on 10 day one lynches excluding games in which majority of people were scum or everyone was town. Note: Some of the people weren't actually lynched due to unlynchability. Dragon Lance- LHN town Totally rigged- Ogianres, town House of cards- B_real, town Superhero Mafia-Newb, Mafiate Kingdom hearts mafia- Red Fighter, Mafiate Video Game Mafia- Demetrius, SK Warcraft Mafia- Lunaknight, town Spiderman Mafia- Lunaknight, Mafia Themeless- Bookie, Jester Complete insanity- Doc Ock, town we actually have a 50% scum hit rate for day one lynches in these games.

10-07-2007, 09:04 PM	#109
Pink Bunny Shyguy Join Date: Jul 2007 Posts: 100	I can't help but notice that each player listed isn't much of a Lurker, at least when accused or brought up on a chopping block. The only person on that list I wouldn't be able to confirm/say that with is Ogianres. The rest are active and say stuff. I'm not saying no-lynch, I haven't really picked yet. But I am saying that usually a lynch on a lurker on day 1 is a vanilla townie. I'm pretty sure that's where Nayno's going with this too.