Mafia: Basic - Page 12

DarthMauler64 · 05-30-2006, 11:02 PM

Hey, this is strange. The thread claims there is a page 12, but when I clicked on it, it only brought me to page 11.

http://i37.photobucket.com/albums/e5.../untitled3.jpg

I clicked on the link properties to show the link was going to a page 12.

Is this a forum mess up, or did someone delete a post?

Thundergod Cid · 05-30-2006, 11:22 PM

Right after I posted, the topic list said that there were 110 replies to the topic. It still says 110 right now. I think someone did delete a post.

Mesden · 05-30-2006, 11:40 PM

That was a spam post made by Richard. An adspammer. Meister deleted it and there should be no more on the subject.

A'ight?

The Wandering God · 05-31-2006, 01:39 AM

I don't see how this puts myself in advantageous situation. Known townies are going to be very high on the death list. But since only one will be known per night by the reporter (unless they find someone else), then the Mafia will be able to keep the count of who is who down. Less known townies mean more places for the Mafia and SK to hide.

I'm not saying we do this every night. Just once. After all, I know I'm innocent. I can't say the same for anyone else. I also put in my original plan, that what would happen after would be up to the town.

The reason I want the BG and PO both to hit me is because if I just say the PO, then the mafia (or Sk, or both) would kill me, thus wasting the POs time. (Like with the reporter and the SK on the first night.) I would like for the Doc to protect the Vig or PO, but we don't know who they are yet. And until we do, I think they should be covering known townies. And the only known townie I know of is me.

And the PO won't have to reveal himself, as I'm not a bad guy. The end result of my plan is to have a known townie be alive on the next day.

Again, what happens after, I leave up to everyone else. The game does have a tendancy of changing in just one night after all.

As to what's going on right now, I don't actually see any reason to vote for anyone yet. I see a lot of people trying to push their own agendas though. (And I freely admit to include myself in that. But my agenda is in the interests of the town, I feel.)

Yes, the BG should protect the PO or Vig. But again, we don't know who they are yet. And the SoL game was the only one I saw where the player was smart enough to make the correct choices.

When, if ever, do you think the PO should reveal themselves? After finding the SK? How many mafiates? Never?

The problem with the PO NOT revealing themselves it the fact that the mafia (or SK) could get lucky and randomly snuff them. Or figure out that the PO is trying to insert there names into lists of who is guilty.

And the Vig. I worry about the Vig. But then again, it's in non-random hands now, so I guess we'll see how that goes.

The Wandering God

Silly Kitty · 05-31-2006, 02:01 AM

What is the point of just proving you innocent? If you have no special role and have no special information you are just like the rest of us. You will know nothing and continue to know nothing. The only thing that changes is we know you are innocent. I think this is just wasting a day when the PO and BG could be doing better things.

Sithdarth · 05-31-2006, 02:19 AM

Also, if he turns out to be a bad guy then we know who the PO is and thus the Doc would have to protect him/her. Leaving everyone else open to attack.

Also, with the reporter floating around the Doc is open to exposure at anytime. Thus we could end up knowing two of the towns major roles. Then someone could hit the Doc and then the PO. However, a lucky night role kill, or unlucky lynching could get the dock. In which case the PO is known and is very easy to take out.

Its better in this game that we not take chances with exposing them at least until we know the Reporter isn't going to accidently expose them. Also, a question for Newb; are you going to tell us if those rolls get assigned to no one? I mean if they had just been killed off we would know so it seems fair we be informed if they get assigned to no one. Otherwise it could drastically effect the game to never be able to find out if those roles are totally gone.

Bailey · 05-31-2006, 08:58 AM

It will be told whether they get reassigned.

Mondt · 05-31-2006, 09:40 AM

First off: I apologize for my absence. I haven't been home much at all the past two weeks. Catching up from the beginning is really no fun at all.

So, could someone please confirm this? I want to know what is happening.

B_real is said to be suspicious because of bad reasoning and quick attacks (Mesden and CmP). Catlover is suspicious because he flings votes like crazy. From what I read, TWG thinks he is found suspicious, but I can't find why. Also, Mesden is the center of almost all of the arguments right now. XD

That last one was a joke, 'cept almost not.

Am I missing anything? I hate to be a burden...

P-Sleazy · 05-31-2006, 01:33 PM

that about sums it all up. Oh and 2 rolls need to be reassigned (if they get assigned).

Quote:

Originally Posted by sk3L3t0n

First off: I apologize for my absence. I haven't been home much at all the past two weeks. Catching up from the beginning is really no fun at all.

Which reminds me...if you were away from here for that long a time, and there was apperently some people missing, people who had night roles mind you, on the first night too, we could easily assume that you were one of those roles am I correct?

Edit: http://www.nuklearforums.com/showpo...51&postcount=3 Wanted to get that in and no reason tag to fill in since this is a lightning edit but still shows that I edited.

***Fenris*** · 05-31-2006, 01:33 PM

Can we get a vote count in here? I'd like to know which way the wind is blowing at this point.

I still don't have a concrete opinion on anybody's role.

EDIT: B_real, I know where you're drawing your logic from, but accusing a person of having a night role (good or bad) because they were gone is kinda just odd. We can also assume that anybody else who isn't posting has a night role. We can also assume anybody has a night role. Maybe whoever didn't send in their role simply didn't think a new mafia game had started yet. I'm guilty of thinking that myself until I noticed it had new posts. We can't assume Skelly has a role simply because he came in the door a little late.

05-30-2006, 11:02 PM	#111
DarthMauler64 Doppleganger!!! Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: Pomona, CA Posts: 122	Hey, this is strange. The thread claims there is a page 12, but when I clicked on it, it only brought me to page 11. http://i37.photobucket.com/albums/e5.../untitled3.jpg I clicked on the link properties to show the link was going to a page 12. Is this a forum mess up, or did someone delete a post? __________________ I like pie. GENERATION 11: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social experiment.

05-30-2006, 11:22 PM	#112
Thundergod Cid Troopa Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: The Gates of Dawn Posts: 86	Right after I posted, the topic list said that there were 110 replies to the topic. It still says 110 right now. I think someone did delete a post. __________________ Insert humorous quotation here.

05-30-2006, 11:40 PM	#113
Mesden There is no Toph, only Melon Lord! Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Inside of a box inside of a smaller box Posts: 4,310	That was a spam post made by Richard. An adspammer. Meister deleted it and there should be no more on the subject. A'ight? __________________ I can tell you're lying.

05-31-2006, 01:33 PM	#120
*Fenris* Administrator Join Date: May 2005 Location: East Coast Posts: 6,806	Can we get a vote count in here? I'd like to know which way the wind is blowing at this point. I still don't have a concrete opinion on anybody's role. EDIT: B_real, I know where you're drawing your logic from, but accusing a person of having a night role (good or bad) because they were gone is kinda just odd. We can also assume that anybody else who isn't posting has a night role. We can also assume anybody has a night role. Maybe whoever didn't send in their role simply didn't think a new mafia game had started yet. I'm guilty of thinking that myself until I noticed it had new posts. We can't assume Skelly has a role simply because he came in the door a little late. __________________ "FENRIS IS AN ASSHOLE" - shiney Last edited by Fenris; 05-31-2006 at 01:37 PM.

05-31-2006, 01:39 AM	#114
The Wandering God THE SUPREME COURT DID WHAT? Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Arkansas (for now) Posts: 1,477	I don't see how this puts myself in advantageous situation. Known townies are going to be very high on the death list. But since only one will be known per night by the reporter (unless they find someone else), then the Mafia will be able to keep the count of who is who down. Less known townies mean more places for the Mafia and SK to hide. I'm not saying we do this every night. Just once. After all, I know I'm innocent. I can't say the same for anyone else. I also put in my original plan, that what would happen after would be up to the town. The reason I want the BG and PO both to hit me is because if I just say the PO, then the mafia (or Sk, or both) would kill me, thus wasting the POs time. (Like with the reporter and the SK on the first night.) I would like for the Doc to protect the Vig or PO, but we don't know who they are yet. And until we do, I think they should be covering known townies. And the only known townie I know of is me. And the PO won't have to reveal himself, as I'm not a bad guy. The end result of my plan is to have a known townie be alive on the next day. Again, what happens after, I leave up to everyone else. The game does have a tendancy of changing in just one night after all. As to what's going on right now, I don't actually see any reason to vote for anyone yet. I see a lot of people trying to push their own agendas though. (And I freely admit to include myself in that. But my agenda is in the interests of the town, I feel.) Yes, the BG should protect the PO or Vig. But again, we don't know who they are yet. And the SoL game was the only one I saw where the player was smart enough to make the correct choices. When, if ever, do you think the PO should reveal themselves? After finding the SK? How many mafiates? Never? The problem with the PO NOT revealing themselves it the fact that the mafia (or SK) could get lucky and randomly snuff them. Or figure out that the PO is trying to insert there names into lists of who is guilty. And the Vig. I worry about the Vig. But then again, it's in non-random hands now, so I guess we'll see how that goes. The Wandering God

05-31-2006, 02:19 AM	#116
Sithdarth Friendly Neighborhood Quantum Hobo Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Outside the M-brane look'n in Posts: 5,403	Also, if he turns out to be a bad guy then we know who the PO is and thus the Doc would have to protect him/her. Leaving everyone else open to attack. Also, with the reporter floating around the Doc is open to exposure at anytime. Thus we could end up knowing two of the towns major roles. Then someone could hit the Doc and then the PO. However, a lucky night role kill, or unlucky lynching could get the dock. In which case the PO is known and is very easy to take out. Its better in this game that we not take chances with exposing them at least until we know the Reporter isn't going to accidently expose them. Also, a question for Newb; are you going to tell us if those rolls get assigned to no one? I mean if they had just been killed off we would know so it seems fair we be informed if they get assigned to no one. Otherwise it could drastically effect the game to never be able to find out if those roles are totally gone.