Homestuck Mafia Thread

[rpgdemon]

Originally Posted by Sifright

I don't actually believe him to be scum though based on his previous voting pattern and would be willing to move my vote to rpgdemon or smarty. (both of them voted for thadius before who was a towny *i did as well* and rpgdemon moved away from that vote before he was lynched prehaps in a move to remove suspicion from him self?

Defending myself from a dead guy, but it actually happened backwards to this.

I was voting for P-Sleazy, and jumped onto Thadius immediately before I was lynched, to boost the number there and try to end the day early, since my vote was being thrown away.

I'm honestly just deadset on voting P-Sleazy, since right now that's the biggest "Lead" that I have. Alternately, other people didn't post at all the other day, and voting them out can only be beneficial to the town, since either it makes our day-ending-lynch easier, or hits scum, right?

Though, if we vote them out and they're townies, then it makes the scum able to overpower us in a lynch?

##vote: P-Sleazy

Since I still don't believe him not to be scum. I've got no further reasons, aside from what I've said before.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by rpgdemon

Alternately, other people didn't post at all the other day, and voting them out can only be beneficial to the town, since either it makes our day-ending-lynch easier, or hits scum, right?

Well, there's a balance here. The days allow us to discuss and try to figure out each other's roles. It's important that we lynch people. It's not necessarily important that we lynch people quickly.

[Aldurin]

I have to put it out here that our current strategy sucks big time, we just seem to be going after whoever is the first to post in a way deemed suspiciously (it's clear that the scum are getting by because we're too busy drooling over our first couple FOS's while they wait to post and join the bandwagon).

I'm going to wait for a proper headcount from the whole group before I make a vote. Also no FOS's until I see some more posts.

[rpgdemon]

So, I went through the entirety of Day 1, and here are the stats for it. By which I mean, postcounts.
By Snake's list
greed - 2
Moogle0119 - 2
Ryanderman - 3
Fenris - 4 (+1 Questionable moddeything)
Inbred Chocobo - 3 (+1 Questionable jokeypost against Snake)
Aldurin - 2
Bard the 5th - 3
Revolving Ocelot - 3
Mr. Bookworm - 3 (Made first post)
Thadius (X) - 7
rpgdemon - 8
Smarty - 10
P-Sleazy - 5
Lumenskir - 4
Sifright - 1


By Postcount
Smarty - 10
rpgdemon - 8
Thadius (X) - 7
P-Sleazy - 5
Fenris - 4 (+1 Questionable moddeything)
Lumenskir - 4
Inbred Chocobo - 3 (+1 Questionable jokeypost against Snake)
Bard the 5th - 3
Ryanderman - 3
Mr. Bookworm - 3 (Made first post)
Revolving Ocelot - 3
greed - 2
Moogle0119 - 2
Aldurin - 2
Sifright - 1

[rpgdemon]

The options are how they're sorted, by the way.

[P-Sleazy]

I still don't quite agree that I am scum. But hey, its still a much better arguement than what we had for Sifight yestrday. Two votes of no reason, one for self peservtion (mine), and then the last one cause "thats just the way things seem to be going".

##VOTE: Aldurin
FOS: Bard
FOS: Mr. Bookworm

I had to pick one of those three might as well be Ald.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by P-Sleazy

I still don't quite agree that I am scum. But hey, its still a much better arguement than what we had for Sifight yestrday. Two votes of no reason, one for self peservtion (mine), and then the last one cause "thats just the way things seem to be going".

##VOTE: Aldurin
FOS: Bard
FOS: Mr. Bookworm

I had to pick one of those three might as well be Ald.

Why Earl, though? Why not either one of the other two? That vote for Earl can be seen as a vote for no reason if you squint and look at it kinda sideways.

[Inbred Chocobo]

As this point in time, I'm unsure. Previous people I've thrown scrutiny out no longer feel like they are scrutinious. I think inactive people are inactive because they don't really have a hold to this game, however if they were mafian they would have a hold so I don't think lynching people due to post count is an effective move either. We have people that are sort've scummy and could possibly be scummy like Thad and sifright, but we've seen how that works out. So I'm going after the one target that makes me think they are smarting up and playing nice and helpful, all while attempting to avoid any kind of threat at all to town.

##Vote: Fenris

Have you ever watched someone's post and things just seem a little too helpful? Just a little too nice and it makes you wonder? Yeah I am getting that with Fenris. Honestly I'm getting that with P-sleazy as well so there we go.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Inbred Chocobo

As this point in time, I'm unsure. Previous people I've thrown scrutiny out no longer feel like they are scrutinious. I think inactive people are inactive because they don't really have a hold to this game, however if they were mafian they would have a hold so I don't think lynching people due to post count is an effective move either. We have people that are sort've scummy and could possibly be scummy like Thad and sifright, but we've seen how that works out. So I'm going after the one target that makes me think they are smarting up and playing nice and helpful, all while attempting to avoid any kind of threat at all to town.

##Vote: Fenris

Have you ever watched someone's post and things just seem a little too helpful? Just a little too nice and it makes you wonder? Yeah I am getting that with Fenris. Honestly I'm getting that with P-sleazy as well so there we go.

I'm really glad I took a stroll down memory lane during the night and read some of the older games.

This is not the first time you've tried to get me lynched for being too helpful. In that game, you succeeded.

Please note that I was town-aligned then, too.

If we want to talk about people's posting tendencies, it's not uncommon behavior for me to be helpful towards people, especially when I've already made it clear what my ulterior motive is for being so nice.

And, once again, history goes against you in terms of people being in the game being the ones who are definitely scum. Back in Bleach Mafia, the Cult won while its leader was afk. Support.

I'm not really seeing any basis for your arguments this game, IC. I think you're grasping.

[P-Sleazy]

Originally Posted by Fenris

Why Earl, though? Why not either one of the other two? That vote for Earl can be seen as a vote for no reason if you squint and look at it kinda sideways.

Well, considering how much all of them posted when voting for Sifright.

Originally Posted by Bard

I'm going to leave the FOS: Sifright, Ryanderman, 'cause Ryanderman has been a bit silent, and Sifright's posts (that I've seen) didn't have much meat on 'em. I'm holding back on Moogle because I haven't seen him post much of anywhere.

For now though, I'm going to leave this with a ##Vote: Sifright. May be subject to change.

Originally Posted by Aldurin

We need to generate more shit to read if we're gonna get anywhere, and killing somebody should do just that.

##Vote: Sifright, since taking shots at the flamboyant posters isn't getting anywhere and gut instinct.

Originally Posted by P_Sleazy

I still do not like the way Bard or Aldurin voted for Sifright. Very little substance in thier reasoning on voting Sifright. Atleast IC is attempting to create some kind of substance to the votes on me. BUUUUuuut,

I do like to live, so in the same interests as Sifright, those interests being self preservation,

##VOTE: Sifright
FOS: Bard
FOS: Aldurin

Originally Posted by Bookworm

Uuugh. This is the part of Mafia I hate, where you have absolutely no concrete suspicions.

Sooo I am going to blatantly bandwagon and ##Vote: Sifright, and hope random chance falls in our favor.

Of those 4, Bard threw out ideas (although flimsy). I'm me. so I'm not gonna vote or FOS myself. That'd be silly. Bookworm and Aldurin gave very little in terms of reasons. Atleast bookworm had the decency to call his vote for what it is. A bandwagon vote. So, I'm left with Aldurin. Doesn't mean I like Bard or Bookworm. I just like Aldurin's vote less than the other twos.