Homestuck Mafia Thread

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Karesh

That makes absolutely perfect sense. Despite being in contact with our generous host for this murderous little event to establish my entry into the game I would definitely skip out on actually noticing that I should be killing someone. And he would totally skip right into day without giving me a chance to throw my choice in for the night.

Vote: Karesh

Because that logic is so flawless.

I totally see where you're coming from there, regarding being in contact with Snake. But! We don't know what the messages between you and Snake that got you into this game were, and we don't know when they were sent. There was a single day that passed between your joining the game and Snake beginning the next day. It's imaginable that you neglected to check your PM box in the time between the two posts regarding "Cowboys & Aliens" that you made during that day. It's not probable but it is certainly possible. I don't think it's what happened, given that you were the first one to post on the following day, but I think that's where Moogs is coming from.

But Snake is totally one for being by-the-book follow-all-regulations no-exceptions-ever, so this little bit-

And he would totally skip right into day without giving me a chance to throw my choice in for the night.

-is totally feasible.

Comes with the lawyerism, don'chaknow.

[Moogle0119]

@Bard: Yeah you're right about the doctor, I was confusing him with the "strong" townie that died on Day 2.

[Moogle0119]

Sorry for the double post. But yeah, what Fenris was saying is what my line of thinking is, only better explained. I'll admit though I didn't check Karesh's posting habits prior to joining the game nor right afterward (hard to do as well as keep track of everthing else going on while I'm without my pc). It's the best reasoning I can come up with at the moment and it'ss definitely a lead worth taking a look at.

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Originally Posted by Fenris

It's imaginable that you neglected to check your PM box in the time between the two posts regarding "Cowboys & Aliens" that you made during that day. It's not probable but it is certainly possible. I don't think it's what happened, given that you were the first one to post on the following day, but I think that's where Moogs is coming from.

I see where he's coming from too, I just think it so happens he's coming from stupidtown.
I find it especially odd since he was all on about how he hates the lack of concrete evidence earlier. That post lead me to believe he wasn't the kind of person to act on those silly little scraping up evidence from anywhichway ideas. But I guess I was wrong in that.

But Snake is totally one for being by-the-book follow-all-regulations no-exceptions-ever, so this little bit-



-is totally feasible.

Comes with the lawyerism, don'chaknow.

That I'll grant you, but even still. You don't think he would at least send me more PMs or try to contact me some other way? Especially when he might not have even been sure I'd been informed of my role?

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Karesh

You don't think he would at least send me more PMs or try to contact me some other way? Especially when he might not have even been sure I'd been informed of my role?

If I were Snake, I would assume one PM would be enough. I'm pretty sure it kicks back a message if the recipient's PM box is full, so he would be aware you received it.

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Originally Posted by Fenris

If I were Snake, I would assume one PM would be enough. I'm pretty sure it kicks back a message if the recipient's PM box is full, so he would be aware you received it.

It just seems a bit faulty for him to have handed such a critical role out to me and then just kinda dropped the issue when he received no kill command. Unless Moogle's suggesting I made a conscious decision to use an inactive mafia tactic, but that being the case the obvious concurrent strategy would be to be active as fuck in the main thread in order to point suspicion toward the less active.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Karesh

It just seems a bit faulty for him to have handed such a critical role out to me and then just kinda dropped the issue when he received no kill command. Unless Moogle's suggesting I made a conscious decision to use an inactive mafia tactic, but that being the case the obvious concurrent strategy would be to be active as fuck in the main thread in order to point suspicion toward the less active.

I would imagine that Snake doesn't wish to receive any accusations of GM bias, and as such is doing the bare minimum of interacting with players.

He seems like the kind of guy that would take that kind of thing pretty hard so I wouldn't really blame him if that were the case.

But like I said, I don't really buy into Moogle's theory, but I do find it pretty interesting that the instant somebody pointed a finger at you you appeared in the game.

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Originally Posted by Fenris

But like I said, I don't really buy into Moogle's theory, but I do find it pretty interesting that the instant somebody pointed a finger at you you appeared in the game.

As I almost always do I've been reading but refrain from posting unless I actually have something to contribute.

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by Karesh

As I almost always do I've been reading but refrain from posting unless I actually have something to contribute.

That's an awful nice way to say "lurking."

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Originally Posted by Fenris

That's an awful nice way to say "lurking."

That's an awful crude way to say "reading but refraining from posting unless I actually have something to contribute."